Issues that I & some other people have w/MNKR

edabella thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
I understand that there are some people who like the idea of Samvad & Reet getting together but how come less people are watchin' the show now? I could be wrong but it was only not that long after Bhisham left the show that I heard about this show goin' off the air. I wonder if less people are watchin' it now because the concept of a guy livin' w/Reet for sometime & falling in love w/her has gotten old. This might be at least one of the reasons. This happened first w/Yagya, second w/Bhisham & Third w/Samvad- it looks like he may be falling for her. I think that this show could have went on for a longer time if the writers didn't get rid of a lot the male characters the show focused on. The show kept on goin' in different directions. It first focused quite a bit on Kuwar but then he went into a coma & he's still in a coma, then it focused on Bhisham & Yagya. After Yagya went back to jail, we just saw him a few times since then & we haven't seen him since. W/Bhisham, well we haven't seen him since he fell off the terrace. First one may have thought Reet would end up w/Yagya, then they may have have thought that Bhisham will become a better person & Reet will eventually fall for him & end up w/him & now one may think she'll end up w/Samvad. Thakur, Kuwar, Yagya, & Bhisham- All 4 of these men brought something to the show. Kuwar brought darkness & action to it, Yagya brought romance & heroism, Bhisham brought comedy & wackiness & Thakur brought warmth. I don't want the writers to get rid of any of these guys. They've already gotten rid of all them. I really wanna see ALL of them back on the show!!! I'm glad they brought Thakur back though. Kuwar better wake up from his coma & give Jasoda a piece of his mind & Bhisham & Yagya better come back. Besides, Bhisham's body wasn't found. I absolutely don't like what the writers did to Bhisham in the last episode we saw him in. Bhisham was actually improving ever since Reet performed those 2 rituals in his house & he was listening to Reet & not gettin' all creepy on her & was takin' her side. We were seeing a different side to his character & then he all of a sudden went all rapist on her & right after that, he fell off the terrace. His character had potential but the writers didn't live up & they ended up ingoring Yagya. No offense to people who like Samvad but in terms of male characters on this show, I'm more attached to Kuwar, Yagya, & Bhisham than Samvad. I guess one of the main reasons as to why this is the case is because the show used to focus quite a bit on them & they have been on the show for a much longer time than Samvad. Getting rid of these three men, how the focus of the storyline kept on changing & how the direction of the show changing in terms of which guy Reet will be with- these were not good moves on the writers part😡. In my opinion the concept of a guy livin' w/Reet for sometime & falling in love w/her- it would have been nice if this concept ended after Bhisham. It would have been nice if the writers developed Bhisham more than they did & made him a great guy & Reet fell in love with him. On top of this it would have been nice if Yagya got together w/Mun. I don't dislike Samvad but him comin' into the picture has not phased me at all in terms of who I think Reet should end up with. I'm still gonna stick w/Reet + Bhisham & Yagya + Mun. By the way, I feel that Samvad is more like Yagya. I liked how the writers made Yagya & Bhisham a lot different from eachother. These two guys were pretty much like day & night😆. The only things that they had in common were that they both loved their mommies & Reet a lot. Feel free to let me know about what issues u have w/the show.
Edited by edabella - 14 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

818

Users

4

Likes

6

Frequent Posters

telenovelle thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2

Originally posted by: edabella

I understand that there are some people who like the idea of Samvad & Reet getting together but how come less people are watchin' the show now? I could be wrong but it was only not that long after Bhisham left the show that I heard about this show goin' off the air. I wonder if less people are watchin' it now because the concept of a guy livin' w/Reet for sometime & falling in love w/her has gotten old. This might be at least one of the reasons. This happened first w/Yagya, second w/Bhisham & Third w/Samvad- it looks like he may be falling for her. I think that this show could have went on for a longer time if the writers didn't get rid of a lot the male characters the show focused on. The show kept on goin' in different directions. It first focused quite a bit on Kuwar but then he went into a coma & he's still in a coma, then it focused on Bhisham & Yagya. After Yagya went back to jail, we just saw him a few times since then & we haven't seen him since. W/Bhisham, well we haven't seen him since he fell off the terrace. First one may have thought Reet would end up w/Yagya, then they may have have thought that Bhisham will become a better person & Reet will eventually fall for him & end up w/him & now one may think she'll end up w/Samvad. Thakur, Kuwar, Yagya, & Bhisham- All 4 of these men brought something to the show. Kuwar brought darkness & action to it, Yagya brought romance & heroism, Bhisham brought comedy & wackiness & Thakur brought warmth. I don't want the writers to get rid of any of these guys. They've already gotten rid of all them. I really wanna see ALL of them back on the show!!! I'm glad they brought Thakur back though. Kuwar better wake up from his coma & give Jasoda a piece of his mind & Bhisham & Yagya better come back. Besides, Bhisham's body wasn't found. I absolutely don't like what the writers did to Bhisham in the last episode we saw him in. Bhisham was actually improving ever since Reet performed those 2 rituals in his house & he was listening to Reet & not gettin' all creepy on her & was takin' her side. We were seeing a different side to his character & then he all of a sudden went all rapist on her & right after that, he fell off the terrace. His character had potential but the writers didn't live up & they ended up ingoring Yagya. No offense to people who like Samvad but in terms of male characters on this show, I'm more attached to Kuwar, Yagya, & Bhisham than Samvad. I guess one of the main reasons as to why this is the case is because the show used to focus quite a bit on them & they have been on the show for a much longer time than Samvad. Getting rid of these three men, how the focus of the storyline kept on changing & how the direction of the show changing in terms of which guy Reet will be with- these were not good moves on the writers part😡. In my opinion the concept of a guy livin' w/Reet for sometime & falling in love w/her- it would have been nice if this concept ended after Bhisham. It would have been nice if the writers developed Bhisham more than they did & made him a great guy & Reet fell in love with him. On top of this it would have been nice if Yagya got together w/Mun. I don't dislike Samvad but him comin' into the picture has not phased me at all in terms of who I think Reet should end up with. I'm still gonna stick w/Reet + Bhisham & Yagya + Mun. By the way, I feel that Samvad is more like Yagya. I liked how the writers made Yagya & Bhisham a lot different from eachother. These two guys were pretty much like day & night😆. The only things that they had in common were that they both loved their mommies & Reet a lot. Feel free to let me know about what issues u have w/the show.

Very insightful comments.
Good reasons about the failure of the show...
edabella thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3
Thanks telenovelle. I like & dislike my experience so far with commenting on this MNKR forum. I really liked seeing the replies & discussing about the show on here but I've put in quite a bit of effort (I'm mainly thinkin' of some of the LONG paragraphs that I posted up here) & to know that quite a bit of the things that I wanted to see happen on this show may not end up happening, saddens me. I'm afraid Yagya & Bhisham are not gonna come back:-( Like I said before, the writers didn't do a good job w/these 2 characters. The guys who acted as them acted well & they could have done more w/these characters. Like they ruined Bhisham's character when he was improving (I'm thinkin' of that horrible episode where he attempts to rape her & he falls off the terrace😡). Anyways, they should have developed his character more instead of ruining him & getting rid of him😭. They completely ignored Yagya ever since those few episodes that aired after he went back to jail😭. I feel sorry for these two characters for different reasons. Unfortunatley, the writers decided to get rid of them. Seriously, did they really think that Samvad can make up for Yagya & Bhisham's absense? For me, he has sooo not made up for their absense😡. I don't dislike Samvad but I just don't want Reet to end up w/him.
Edited by edabella - 14 years ago
telenovelle thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: edabella

Thanks telenovelle. I like & dislike my experience so far with commenting on this MNKR forum. I really liked seeing the replies & discussing about the show on here but I've put in quite a bit of effort (I'm mainly thinkin' of some of the LONG paragraphs that I posted up here) & to know that quite a bit of the things that I wanted to see happen on this show may not end up happening, saddens me. I'm afraid Yagya & Bhisham are not gonna come back:-( Like I said before, the writers didn't do a good job w/these 2 characters. The guys who acted as them acted well & they could have done more w/these characters. Like they ruined Bhisham's character when he was improving (I'm thinkin' of that horrible episode where he attempts to rape her & he falls off the terrace😡). Anyways, they should have developed his character more instead of ruining him & getting rid of him😭. They completely ignored Yagya ever since those few episodes that aired after he went back to jail😭. I feel sorry for these two characters for different reasons. Unfortunatley, the writers decided to get rid of them. Seriously, did they really think that Samvad can make up for Yagya & Bhisham's absense? For me, he has sooo not made up for their absense😡. I don't dislike Samvad but I just don't want Reet to end up w/him.

Well whatever you want the show to be it is too late because the cv are pulling the plug on it.
There is no hope for the show. A show has to be at least somewhat decent from the beginning, otherwise you lose the audience as in this case. The characters were not developed or used well in this show.CryCryCryCry
Infofan thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
Edabella,

I don't really watch this show, was just browsing through the forum when I came across your post and was impressed. Very nicely articulated.👍🏼
kavya-kaabarz thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6
Edabella I acknwledge u 4 writing such a lenghty pst for this crp show.Three cheers 4 Edabella:Hip hip hurray,Hip hip hurray,Hip hip hurray..........
telenovelle thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: kavya-kaabarz

Edabella I acknwledge u 4 writing such a lenghty pst for this crp show.Three cheers 4 Edabella:Hip hip hurray,Hip hip hurray,Hip hip hurray..........




I agree. Nothing wrong with expressing one's self through writing.👏

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".