Why can Ishaan not see the change in Suhana

poshah thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#1
Off late, the whole family has kind of seen the change in Suhana, and they feel that she has changed and has become a part of the family.
My question is why can Ishaan not see the change in Suhana? Why cant he see that Suhana has changed and has accepted his family and eventually will start liking him/has already started liking him? He obviously doesnt think that they will be spending their whole life just like friends.
I agree there have not been any scenes/or instances which have shown Ishaana caring for Suhana. But cant he see that she has changed? And more than that he understands her better than anyone. Still why cant Ishaan see the change or understand her feelings ?

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.5k

Users

7

Likes

31

Frequent Posters

Maneetkraze thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#2
I have wondered the same exact thing. Even more now since Sona has come and Suhanna has been feeling a little down seeing them together. I did not like today's Sushann scene at all. I think Ishaan is just trying to find another way to accept what Sona has brought for him and not Suhanna's gift. I really don't think that Suhanna brought the sunglasses because she wanted him to be Sid, Ishaan is just making up excuses.
Nach_Baliye thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: poshah

Off late, the whole family has kind of seen the change in Suhana, and they feel that she has changed and has become a part of the family.

My question is why can Ishaan not see the change in Suhana? Why cant he see that Suhana has changed and has accepted his family and eventually will start liking him/has already started liking him? He obviously doesnt think that they will be spending their whole life just like friends.


Ishaan has seen the change in Suhana, but he has given up on the thought that Suhana will ever love him. From the very beginning she has made it very clear to him that he is not her type, and that she can never love someone like him. I think Ishaan did not accept Suhana's sunglasses because he was very hurt by the whole Sid factor, and did not want to have anything to do with Sid. He wants Suhana to love him for himself rather than turn him into Sid, and at the same time he does not think that she will ever love him.

I have seen him give up on her love. She talked about leaving several times and decided to stay back only because of his family. We the audience get to see Suhana's expressions and hear her thoughts, but Ishaan is not around to see that. He sees her angry side, her previous love for Sid, and rich life.

Ishaan's manner of expressing his love is different. He cannot be romantic with her, but a few times he has caressed her hair, bought the car, and most of all, accepted her love for Sid and stood by her when Sid hurt her. He gave her the Rs 20,000 and did not think about it anymore, this shows that he is practical and does not dwell on things. Just like that he gave up on winning her love and does not dwell on it. The ball is entirely in Suhana's court. She doesn't know that Ishaan loves her, but she is the one who wanted out from the marriage.

I don't like how sometimes Ishaan makes fun of Suhana in front of his family and does not take her side in front of Sona. But maybe that is because he thinks of her as one of the family, knows how much everyone loves her and that they will never do anything to hurt her - so he doesn't need to take her side against them. As for Sona, I do hope he eventually takes Suhana's side just to humor her because I am tiring of his need to do the right thing rather than take Suhana's side.
Sinha18 thumbnail
14th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#4
@nach_baliye
What an analysis , you gave all the sketch of present situation so correctly👏👏
SomerholicGirl thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 14 years ago
#5
@nach_baliye: u r 100% ryt...agree wid u...
aparakshitij thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#6

@ nach_baliye

Ur analysis is very apt & to the point.Loved it!👏

poshah thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#7
[QUOTE=Nach_Baliye

Ishaan has seen the change in Suhana, but he has given up on the thought that Suhana will ever love him. From the very beginning she has made it very clear to him that he is not her type, and that she can never love someone like him. I think Ishaan did not accept Suhana's sunglasses because he was very hurt by the whole Sid factor, and did not want to have anything to do with Sid. He wants Suhana to love him for himself rather than turn him into Sid, and at the same time he does not think that she will ever love him.

I have seen him give up on her love. She talked about leaving several times and decided to stay back only because of his family. We the audience get to see Suhana's expressions and hear her thoughts, but Ishaan is not around to see that. He sees her angry side, her previous love for Sid, and rich life.

Ishaan's manner of expressing his love is different. He cannot be romantic with her, but a few times he has caressed her hair, bought the car, and most of all, accepted her love for Sid and stood by her when Sid hurt her. He gave her the Rs 20,000 and did not think about it anymore, this shows that he is practical and does not dwell on things. Just like that he gave up on winning her love and does not dwell on it. The ball is entirely in Suhana's court. She doesn't know that Ishaan loves her, but she is the one who wanted out from the marriage.

I don't like how sometimes Ishaan makes fun of Suhana in front of his family and does not take her side in front of Sona. But maybe that is because he thinks of her as one of the family, knows how much everyone loves her and that they will never do anything to hurt her - so he doesn't need to take her side against them. As for Sona, I do hope he eventually takes Suhana's side just to humor her because I am tiring of his need to do the right thing rather than take Suhana's side.
I

I agree to Ishaan's logic of not accepting the sunglasses infact, he specificially said that he can do anything for her but he can not be or imitate Sid, which is good.

And also agree that Ishaan is not like 'Raj', he cannot express his love in words, but rather is expressed in actions..like care, car, dress and a lot many.

But then doesnt he know that for Suhaana, expressing love in words is also important, infact the almost first time that he expressed in words last week, we could see Suhaana staring back at him.

From day one, Suhaana had said that she cannot live with his family, but as time passed, he saw that she not only changed herself but she started enjoying their company so much that her own sis could feel that for her her inlaws are more impt..she didnt even stay back for her bday party, but took the food back to eat with her family members.

If we take the entire episode of Suhaana wanting to go back home, did we ever once hear Ishaan tell her in front of her to not go? NO. Infact until the last minute he never once said that don't go, he kept marking the dates in the calendar and reminding her when she is going. But never once stopped her. Still Suhaana did speak her mind, inspite of thinking that Ishaan always wanted her to go back. She said she doesnt want to go. After that also Ishaan didn't say he was glad etc..all he said was that she should be a good wife !!!

Every time, Suhaana has listened to Ishaan, why would she do that ? Be it riding his scooter, or for that matter buying his scooter back, going to the wedding,

making rotis for him trying to be a good wife and all that.

I still think that Ishaan should realise that if Suhaana can accept and love the rest of the family members then why not him. I don't think he has given up at all. He should speak up atleast once. Suhaana must be sick of him being a friend to her !

Neither of them now that the other likes him/her. But I know that this time as well it will be Suhaana only he will speak up :)

No wonder badi maa says that Suhaana is perfect for someone like Ishaan. !!!

payalibm thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 14 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: poshah

Off late, the whole family has kind of seen the change in Suhana, and they feel that she has changed and has become a part of the family.

My question is why can Ishaan not see the change in Suhana? Why cant he see that Suhana has changed and has accepted his family and eventually will start liking him/has already started liking him? He obviously doesnt think that they will be spending their whole life just like friends.
I agree there have not been any scenes/or instances which have shown Ishaana caring for Suhana. But cant he see that she has changed? And more than that he understands her better than anyone. Still why cant Ishaan see the change or understand her feelings ?



a v. simple answer dear😊

when the writer wants will make see ishan the change in suhana😆😆😆 till then buddy u have to have patience😭😭😭

Nach_Baliye thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#9
Ishaan is like my hubby - if I wanted to leave the house, my husband would never stop me because he loves me a lot and would prefer that I do whatever makes me happy. Ishaan is like that. He would prefer that Suhana remain happy, so he never tried to stop her from leaving. But it was clear that it bothered him. When she kept delaying her leaving the house, Ishaan was very annoyed and told her to leave and get the misery over with. Everyday for him was hell because each time he came home, he kept thinking "is she here". Living day in and day out without knowing when Suhana will leave was difficult.

Suhana changed for the family. But Ishaan thinks that his family is so lovable that everyone would love his family. So he was probably not surprised that Suhana loves them and wants to stay there. OTOH, he is self-critical and knows that Suhana does not see him as her type. He also probably does not want to hope because he doesn't want to be disappointed. If he hopes for her love and Suhana does not change, he is going to be the one hurt. So I understand that he has given up on her.

Suhana has listened to him and tried to adjust, but that has nothing to do with her love for Ishaan. Ishaan thinks the world of her, and Suhana listens and is adjusting because basically Suhana is a sweet innocent girl. Ishaan knows that it has nothing to do with whether she likes Ishaan.

I completely understand why Ishaan is not hopeful, and I am excited to see Suhana catch him off-guard. Ishaan better act the hell out of that scene because I want to see him overwhelmed with emotion.
poshah thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 14 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: Nach_Baliye

Ishaan is like my hubby - if I wanted to leave the house, my husband would never stop me because he loves me a lot and would prefer that I do whatever makes me happy. Ishaan is like that. He would prefer that Suhana remain happy, so he never tried to stop her from leaving. But it was clear that it bothered him. When she kept delaying her leaving the house, Ishaan was very annoyed and told her to leave and get the misery over with. Everyday for him was hell because each time he came home, he kept thinking "is she here". Living day in and day out without knowing when Suhana will leave was difficult.


Suhana changed for the family. But Ishaan thinks that his family is so lovable that everyone would love his family. So he was probably not surprised that Suhana loves them and wants to stay there. OTOH, he is self-critical and knows that Suhana does not see him as her type. He also probably does not want to hope because he doesn't want to be disappointed. If he hopes for her love and Suhana does not change, he is going to be the one hurt. So I understand that he has given up on her.

Suhana has listened to him and tried to adjust, but that has nothing to do with her love for Ishaan. Ishaan thinks the world of her, and Suhana listens and is adjusting because basically Suhana is a sweet innocent girl. Ishaan knows that it has nothing to do with whether she likes Ishaan.

I completely understand why Ishaan is not hopeful, and I am excited to see Suhana catch him off-guard. Ishaan better act the hell out of that scene because I want to see him overwhelmed with emotion.

I would say maybe different POV. I would personally always want the other person to also say what is in their mind, I agree its my decision to leave, but I would like to know what the other person wants/thinks. I would still probably do what I want but its good to know what the other person thinks..#
And similarly, I would tell the other person what I think too.
So probably different thinking :)
I am with dada and badi ma, that they do love each other, just that they more so Suhana doesnt realise it !

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".