STAR ONE - PLEASE DON'T EDIT GEET! UPD:GOOD NEWS

First Previous

Page

Next Last

Frequent Posters

aditi

@adits7

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#41

@starrynite : i agree ....ditto too much wrong editing takes away d very essence of d scene....

Quote

aditi

@adits7

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#42

Originally posted by: goldendays
Wow.. no wonder that some crucial epsiodes were not making scene.. they should find a way to keep the story and meet the masses demand... BTW wouldnt the bold romance increase TRPs who drool over Maaneet chemistry?

I definitely would love to see the unedited version of Roop tera Mastana.

ANd thanks for the contact information

yes dats wat....wen dey have 1 of d best lead pairs on Telly r8 nw..d unedited wud grab mre eyeballs n Trps....it wud b sooo guddd 2 watch d unedited 1...

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

-Divine-

@-Divine-

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

#43

hi all..

ALl of you are doing great job by raising this issue of editing...

But how can we assure that star one channel is getting this message....??????????????

Quote

aditi

@adits7

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#44

Originally posted by: gooseberry
hi all..

ALl of you are doing great job by raising this issue of editing...
But how can we assure that star one channel is getting this message....??????????????

chk PG 1...der is channel info posted..u need 2 send dem d feed back..dey m8 as well reply....or if v get flawless..n consistent epis lk ystrdes ......dn v m8 as well consider dt our req/msg/demand has bn granted...

but for dt v need 2 send dem feedbacks asap...😃

Quote

AnjanaYYZ

@AnjanaYYZ

Stunner

+ 6

Posted: 15 years ago

#45

Originally posted by: gooseberry
hi all..

ALl of you are doing great job by raising this issue of editing...

But how can we assure that star one channel is getting this message....??????????????

By contacting Star One yourself - use any and all of the means that Arwen's provided in her posts on p. 1. Email CC your abhorence of the Channel's editting to everyone who's email has been provided. Call them when they are open and post on their FB pages. Do this ASAP before they con't their cutting

Edited by AnjanaToronto - 15 years ago

Quote

Arwen11

@Arwen11

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#46

Originally posted by: gooseberry
hi all..

ALl of you are doing great job by raising this issue of editing...
But how can we assure that star one channel is getting this message....??????????????

well i think they keep an eye on forums for feed back so this thread is a step in the right direction

and anyways thats what all that contact info is for 😆 so start spamming😎 Geet FB wall .. Star One walls are both a good place to start .. just make sure ur post u reiterate ur point by posting it again and again .. like after every hr or so ... that way it wont get lost in all that clutter ... if u r in IndIa .. start calling .... there are also email ids available ...

remember this same star one caved when they saw that there audience wanted Rati (MJHT) ... show them what we want and they ll listen

Quote

aditi

@adits7

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

#47

d direction of d show has been brilliant till now.....d team has bn succesful to sustain d gripping story line....just some better editing wud ensure dt d show remains high on trps....or raise evn higher...😃

Edited by adits7 - 15 years ago

Quote

Sigma

@Sigma

Rocker

Posted: 15 years ago

#48

i can't believe that channel are messing with geet, now it all makes sense why the show's flow has been disrupted of late, does anyone at starone have any sense

wait til they feel the wrath of the fans now, they'll think twice before touching our scenes

Quote

Doodle

@Doodle

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 15 years ago

#49

Another Milestone was achieved but I must my mood was ruined by the Officials of Star One and Mr. Mirchandani. Didn't I tell you earlier Nissar that I want you to be firm and strict when it comes to the decision on what scenes should be edited and what not before it is aired??? This is yours prerogative and how do you let the Channel to decide what to air and what not??? They know the flow of the story but do they really know what the brainstorming that goes behind each scene??? Tell me??? I know the work that you and your team go through each day. I know the changes that been made and what is the reason behind each scene. The channel definitely bothers about the story and I don't deny that but the main thing they bother is about the TRPs. Without the TRP they cannot earn the revenue. Get that. For them it is not important how each scene is moving ahead. For the channel it is important how they can pull the sponsorships and how they can approach the advertisers and to approach the advertisers they need to show data (TRP) and for the data they want to compromise on the story line. But at the end of the day tell me whose hardwork is being chopped off??? It's your's and your teams'. Get that. They won't be bothered later on about the quality of work you do but it should bother to you. Again I am telling you never ever suppress yourself under anyone's demands. Why??? It will affect your future only. Whenever in future you will showcase your work what will you show??? You can only show those works that's been aired and not the work that's been edited. Isn't it??? Why compromise??? Please stand for yourself and your work.

Now I will talk something to Mr. Mirchandani. You know this week and next week would have been the most perfect week for us but you and your team screwed up in a pathetic way. I thought you have a wonderful vision because otherwise you wouldn't have come out with such a nice concept in Geet HSP. Yes. I adored your vision completely but now I don't. Sorry it may hurt you as I am being very crude here but I am serious. I thought that besides having Hawk Eye you have a very wonderful vision and now I see you have proved me so wrong. When you all supported me in not expanding Neha Jhulka's (Pari) entry with the foolish storyline you really had earned all the respect. We don't know each other but you still have understood the "Parineeta Metaphor" and approved the concept when Nissar and team had presented you the same. But, I am sorry I was so wrong there. Now I know that you never approve anything just because it's a good concept or beneficial to the story line but you approve because you only see the revenue in a certain story line and the TRP and the sponsorships that it can gain out if it. But when you see that certain times you don't get the TRPs as you are willing then you start taking over the scenes. And while doing that you don't even realize what it all goes while building a storyline. I know that you are here not for Social Service but for Business. At the same time I know that even while doing business you can also maintain the story line in an intelligent manner. But you think of those demands who don't even contribute to the TRPs and the story line. Yes, you can talk about me also. I don't contribute any TRP to you but since I cannot do that I try to contribute in some other way. That is why I contribute my ideas and concept to make this series a masterpiece so that people can remember this series for ever the way people still give examples of Buniyaad, Hasratein etc.

At the same time don't even think that I don't understand business and I don't want that you reach the breakeven point. Please I do know that. All I am saying is even continuing good story line you can do business and can increase the TRPs. Don't you believe in that??? I really didn't like when you edited out Maan's self analysis. When Nissar had shot all the scenes then post truth revealation scenes then why did you and your team had cut them??? Just because of TRPs. Why you think that there won't be any romance scenes and that is why your TRPs will be down??? Isn't that a foolish thinking??? Tell me.

I know very well how Nissar works and today many have understood how his mind also works and in which direction. But why don't you have FAITH in Nissar and his team??? Tell me. They have sletched Maan's analysis after the truth revealation and you all went ahead and had edited the scenes. Didn't you realize that those scenes were so necessary for the story line to justify in future why Maan will never misunderstood Geet??? Just tell me how a normal human being can accept the fact his love is carrying someone else's child in just a day??? I hope you know the human emotions and believe in Logic. But alas you don't??? leave alone Nissar you didn't even realize that even Gurmeet and Drashti and other team members have worked hard for these scenes and when Nissar had shot these scenes then he did it for a purpose. Why then didn't you take into consideration those efforts??? Don't you know that Nissar won't shot a scene unless it is necessary to the story line? Mr. Mirchandani, you should have kept belief in him. Maan's breakdown scene was one of the most important scenes in the story and also his self analysis. You even edited the cliff scene??? WTH??? Being such a high profile how could you not understand the intricacies of these scenes??? Tell me??? That is the reason why everybody including me thought that there was no consistency in the characters??? But I am soo glad that even then also I didn't blame Nissar at all and then and there I realized that it was not his fault but rather it was your fault. I remember after the railway scene also I told Nissar to stay firm on what he did and not give in to your demands. But I believe since you are the client and that is why he had to listen to you. Otherwise you were also ready to edit yesterday's water scene too. This is absolutely ridiculous Mr. Mirchandani. Just not done. I didn't even expect this from you. I thought even if the team is not sensible atleast you are sensible. Then there are certain episodes where I said that it will not pass the six sigma tests. And I am so sure now why I it won't pass the six sigma tests. How will it pass tell me??? When you curtail down the flow of the story then how in the world you expect that it will have the continuity??? Don't think that only you have to run the business and only you need to answer your bosses; here everybody have to answer their bosses and run their business. The way you need to answer your boss in the same way even Nissar needs to answer his boss; the same way now you need to answer the viewers. So, now you see that we are answerable to each other.

What you think that only showing romance will give you the TRPs??? Then why DMG and MJHT is not the No. 1 show in your channel??? Then why the viewers who watch these shows are bored of the same scenes again and again??? What you think how long you can run the show with only romance??? Why then DMG's TRP is not crossing the limit of 0.5??? Tell me??? You think I don't have the data??? Yes I do have. And Geet's TRP is way high than DMG and MJHT and RBO. Even much better than Imagines'. But still you need to screw up the story line??? What was the rush of completion for Parineeta Metaphor??? Tell me??? Couldn't you wait for a week??? You should have let Nissar sketch the character growth properly and not you doing it. He needs to show the completion of Parineeta Metaphor because he knows how to justify when the completion will happen. It just cannot come out of the blue. You need to have the proper setting for that and you need to have the story to move forward in that direction. Think logically and then answer me??? You should have let Nissar do his job. Does Nissar do your job??? Tell me??? Then why do you interfere in his job??? He also knows that you need TRPs and he is not doing social service here. Mind it. He knows that his job will be gone if he doesn't deliver TRPs.

So, my only point is he knows that when the character needs a self analysis and when the lead pair need a mature talk between them. And you even curtail the scenes out from the episode??? What was the need for completion of Parineeta Metaphor this Friday??? You should have kept it for next Friday. All in all you are so hugngry for TRPs that you even couldn't wait for the lead pair to have the mature conversation before they move in to doing mature scenes. Logically you should have started promoting the promo this Friday night and aired the episode next Thursday or Friday evening. By that time you would have generated the interest in the viewers and also the TRPs would have been generated and also the story would have seemed logical. But NO. You won't listen and I know very well that after reading my analysis you will just have a laugh and thinking that I am a fool and don't know your job and the situation you are in. Laugh loud I don't mind but you know what I know that you don't have the courage to fight your own battle and you also don't have the confidence in yourself that you tell the "Mahila Mukti" organizations and the Politicos that what you are airing on TV is no way any kind of vulgarity and that it is needed in the storyline and the concept. See this is your inner strength and still you want to laugh at me for telling so many things to you then you are very much welcome. We all know in what position you all are in but what you do not understand that even though you are under tremendous pressure you need to be firm in the stand that you should not compromise the quality of your products. Like you all have compromised the quality of DMG and see now how a crap it has become. Do you even see any mature viewers who watch these serials??? Tell me. Just mind that do not take any such decisions in life which will lead you to such a situation when you cannot even do a damage control. Remember this. Think of doing a quality work and don't run after the TRPs. It will automatically come once you do an excellent job.

Just remember this quote which was in 3 Idiots:-

"The unfortunate truth is that the system forces people to pursue success rather than excellence. But if you pursue excellence, success is bound to follow."

Edited by doodleberry - 15 years ago

Quote

Arwen11

@Arwen11

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

#50

Originally posted by: Sigma
i can't believe that channel are messing with geet, now it all makes sense why the show's flow has been disrupted of late, does anyone at starone have any sense

wait til they feel the wrath of the fans now, they'll think twice before touching our scenes

the channel is under the mis conception that it is just the strip tease and romance that is running this show and giving them TRPs.... i guess all thos hotpix polls didnt help here .... we need to show them in no uncertain terms that the show is being run on a well written and well executed story ... they have already ruined one of the high points .. we need to save the others