Originally posted by: JShukla
Hi Bheegi....... you are one of my fav writers on IF and I reallly enjoy your posts.........
I am kinda neutral viewer who was ok with AR uniting even if it meant leaving Sid in lurch to lick his wounds in solitude. But since you mention Ishq......... wot about the ishq she had with Sid?? (I am copying my own reply from another post) Oh wait she did not love him.......... only enjoyed his kisses a few times........... imagined him wen he was not there .... had loving smile on her face while touching the white and blue saree in which Sid had lifted her up during her first HM......... missed him in his absence........ found assurance wen he repeated "ILU" to her....... sings naughty naughty raat with naughty naughty expressions with her hubby . However, all this while she did have pangs of jealousy on seeing A with any other gal(yeah.....I felt it was jealousy....... and not fully concern or mother complex)........ she thought about A while with Sid......... and about Sid while with A......... Hmm wot does that make her.......... I can't use the word on IF
But if I were her hubby.......... I'd really be able to see that my wife is committing emotional adultery throughout this marriage, after giving me all the false assurances!! But the point is Ridz made Sid believe in her by giving him false hopes and that is wrong.......... What is funny is that such women do not really exist. If they have a hubby with whom they do not want to commit emotionally(read: say ILU) and physically(read: consummate) and who is broad- minded enough to let the woman decide who she wants to stay with, then such woman do not cheat. However if CVs want to depict R as someone who wants 2 or more men in her life........... well then, they should have built up her character in such a manner from the beginning. A conservative, well-brought up girl suddenly indulging in illicit acts is tough to digest wiith all the hajmola in the world. Does it mean she is a convoluted female character who likes male attention.......... and has some mental problem which has surfaced only now? Because I am yet to see a person with so much confusion. If a normal person likes someone, they know they do like tht person. So if Ridz liked A than she should have know it and must have felt disgusted with Sid's touch and should have told him so............. why did she dreamily touch her cheeks where Sid had kissed....... She is sick yaar...... and I mean literally
Also ........A had also seen the vedio of her with Sid in naughty naughty raat.......... then wen Rid had acidentally hugged him from behind in the dark viewing gallery....... they were assurances enough for him that she has moved on.
If AR fans are talking of logic than I see more logic in SR continuing, then in their breaking and R going back to A. agreed she had some jealousy regarding A.........some possessiveness perhaps, which i felt is ok for some more time and she will get over it eventually and then be ok with Sid
Besides.........donn know about the rest, but being born and brought up in a conservative society, I feel a wrong doer must suffer in the end.......... So I'll be OK if AR suffer in the end........... be it through society....... through God.......... or through loved ones who refuse to touch them with a barge pole after this crime