Mora Saiyyan: Shujat-2009 vs Sniti-2010

Who do you think did sing it better: Shujat Ali Khan, from the last season of SRGMP, or the latest performance by Sniti Mishra?!

Shujat's: youtube.com/watch?v=Xs9GwCXuqk8

Sniti's: youtube.com/watch?v=ZCi28oKdxlA

Originally posted by: diamond444

I prefer Sniti's 😊

Do you feel that Sniti's is more crystalline!

Sniti's rendition was soulful and more mature than Shujaat's rendition..Definitely Sniti was better..

We are not really supposed to compare but Sniti was better than Sujat...

Sniti all the way !! 😃

Originally posted by: Dabulls23

We are not really supposed to compare but Sniti was better than Sujat...

Loved Amanat's rendition and miss his voice...

Amanat's rendition was the best no doubt..😛

Originally posted by: lifeztuf

Amanat's rendition was the best no doubt..😛

Each one of them has put his own feeling in it. Note that that would be a masculine vs feminine different interpretations, with the extra effect due to their different masculine and feminine voices too.

I agree with saying that Sniti's is a mature version, but Shujat did also put a lot of his soul into the song and produced his own version, whereas Sniti could be easily thought as she was more loyal to the original. In spite of that Shujat seems in this song less perfected as a singer than Sniti, I think it could mainly be a matter of different choices. Sniti anyhow was so great in capturing the soul of the original song.

I have listened to the version of Amanat Ali and I found his breath control ruining it, even though his feeling of it was as much mature as Sniti's.

(Amanat's: youtube.com/watch?v=vdn8cpBxMak)

All of them have sung very well but only Shujat made Himmy Bhai cry😭

"Who do you think did sing it better: Shujat Ali Khan, from the last season of SRGMP, or the late Sniti Mishra's performance?!"


late sniti mishra?when did she die?? 😆