ISN'T THE II FOR NEW SINGERS - Page 2

Originally posted by: amritha19

which part of the following didn't you understand when sree said "I am an UPCOMMING singer in telugu and now i want to sing in HINDI thats y i'm here"... It isn't against II's rules so it isn't cheating and if he had any intentions of "cheating" he wouldn't be honest and open about it. it anycase bhairon ke saamne been bajane ka koi faida nahi

FYI rakesh has also done several stage shows as he claims, how come the people who find sreerams participation objectionable don't find that objectionable?

Originally posted by: amritha19

which part of the following didn't you understand when sree said "I am an UPCOMMING singer in telugu and now i want to sing in HINDI thats y i'm here"... It isn't against II's rules so it isn't cheating and if he had any intentions of "cheating" he wouldn't be honest and open about it. it anycase bhairon ke saamne been bajane ka koi faida nahi

FYI rakesh has also done several stage shows as he claims, how come the people who find sreerams participation objectionable don't find that objectionable?

What do you mean he is an upcoming telugu singer and now trying to sing in Hindi....Thats really sarcastic ...."Trying to sing in Hindi".... Well then what was he singing in Voice of India...SREERAM WAS A SEMI-FINALIST in VOICE OF INDIA.....He didnt sing telugu songs in Voice of India....It was a hindi competition. He got his due in VOI sorry......

"Trying to sing in hindi " means trying to make a mark for himself within bollywood... besides, i don't think any1 on earth has the right to decide to judge him on wot his "due" is, wot he deserves and doesn't. every1 is entitled to the right to participate and persevere if they wish to. so making a big deal outa nothing is just a waste of time n energy

Originally posted by: sallu79

</div>
<div>

What do you mean he is an upcoming telugu singer and now trying to sing in Hindi....Thats really sarcastic ...."Trying to sing in Hindi".... Well then what was he singing in Voice of India...SREERAM WAS A SEMI-FINALIST in VOICE OF INDIA.....He didnt sing telugu songs in Voice of India....It was a hindi competition. He got his due in VOI sorry......

even bhoomi is a previous participant of indian idol.... well everyone wants to showcase their talent and these shows give them an opportunity... wot is so unfair if one contestant has showcased their talent through stage shows, another was close enough to becoming a semi finalist in a previous indian idol season and the third was a tad bit more successful in doing so at another platform... who is any1 to deprive them off this? n u can crucify him for being a lil more successful in his earlier attempts than this conterparts http://india-forums.com/smileys/smiley36.gif

Originally posted by: irocked

Hey this matter is not about doing stage shows, this is about already participating in a similar kinda show on other channel. He had already entered bollywood if he was a semi finalist of another show like Indian Idol.

Its a shame for Indian Idol judges and Sony Tv.

😆

Originally posted by: irocked

Hey this matter is not about doing stage shows, this is about already participating in a similar kinda show on other channel. He had already entered bollywood if he was a semi finalist of another show like Indian Idol.

Its a shame for Indian Idol judges and Sony Tv.

you for your various selfish reasons trying to forget that
shashi,yashraj,vishwas,megna,bhoomi have also participated in other shows.pity thing is you already know it and your problem is sreeram reached top 3 and others couldnt .😔 abt this kind of thinking.

honestly, II5 minus Sreeram would have been the worst of all seasons..

All this publicity is very good for Sreeram. Keep it going people

Originally posted by: hossainn

Sreeram has cheated the audience. He is already an established professional playback singer.This fact was concealed and not high-lighted to the audience. He sang for a number of South Indian commercial films. Indian Idol is the platform for the new comer amateure singers and not for the professionals. Indian Idol organizers doesn't deserve the credit of discovering a well established professional singer like Sreeram. Judges, particularly, Anu Malik should not get so excited about Sreeram. It looks odd. Because, Sreeram is already a known figure in the South Indian film industry. In any case, Sreeram should have not been allowed to compete with the new singers. It has been completely an unfair situation.

@bold...not really.Indian Idol in fact appreciates well established singers.If youve ever heard what happens in the actual auditions,the participants are asked to bring forth any recordings they have done or experience they have so far in the music industry.people with experience are given credit and respected.The judges attitude is way different with these people than the others.However if an established singer fails to perform,they receive the judges flak.the judges have a very good idea about a contestants capacity and pass comments accordingly.So if some Sreeram fans think Sunidhi has been bit unfair towards Sreeram in passing comments,its coz she knows his potential and knows how well he can do.Amateurs just get selected due to plain dumb luck.And this season has been quite stringent in choosing the candidates,im glad Sunidhi and Salim were on board this season,unlike judges like Farah Khan or Sonali Bendre who gave too much importance to looks and screen presence