bunmaska thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
Oh how I hate this term being used blatantly in our serials. Is it a crime to be a ghar jamai. And who is objecting. Mahaan Simi, herself being a woman is putting her foot down. Shame on her being a woman is taking such a stance. She can object to Anuj, Abhi being jobless but what the heck is she objecting about ghar jamai. When a girl after marriage has to stay in her husband's place why not the husband stay with her parents. Maybe for not forever, for sometime. I hate this concept being looked down upon in our society. Personally speaking we are 3 daughters and no brother, so what if one of us stay with our Parents to take care of them during their old age. Does Simi's shaan , maan maryada hurt if her brother stays with his wife's parents. Why these double standards. She should be objecting to all of them enjoying inspite of being jobless and not earning a penny. Just mauj masti they do with their parents money. shame on them.

Created

Last reply

Replies

6

Views

1.2k

Users

6

Likes

27

Frequent Posters

sayhi2nimi thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
sorry to say but i dont agree with ur thoughts,the situations r completely different.if its a serious need u have to stay with ur inlaws then its ok ,but just to satisfy one's selfishness i dont think in any way its correct to stay with them,by the way " yahaan par RS,manju,simi,abhi aur milli ko hi problem hai anuj ke ghar jamai ban ne mein ",anuj doesnot have any problem bcoz as RS said he doesnot have his own selfrespect.y do u need anuj to stay with his inlaws just to satisfy anitha's evil plans ,the tarneja's have a son and capable of handling every problem and to look after them .and what about anuj's responsiblities towards his parents.
sonika74 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
Well !!! try it and see if your hubby agrees..every man has self respect
WithlovefromUSA thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: tvdost

Oh how I hate this term being used blatantly in our serials. Is it a crime to be a ghar jamai. And who is objecting. Mahaan Simi, herself being a woman is putting her foot down. Shame on her being a woman is taking such a stance. She can object to Anuj, Abhi being jobless but what the heck is she objecting about ghar jamai. When a girl after marriage has to stay in her husband's place why not the husband stay with her parents. Maybe for not forever, for sometime. I hate this concept being looked down upon in our society. Personally speaking we are 3 daughters and no brother, so what if one of us stay with our Parents to take care of them during their old age. Does Simi's shaan , maan maryada hurt if her brother stays with his wife's parents. Why these double standards. She should be objecting to all of them enjoying inspite of being jobless and not earning a penny. Just mauj masti they do with their parents money. shame on them.

Wow....never thought abt. it that way. But you do have a point here
WithlovefromUSA thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: sonika74

Well !!! try it and see if your hubby agrees..every man has self respect

So you mean women don't have self-respect when they stay with their in-laws. What's so special abt. men's self-respect. And I don't think we are just talking abt. self-respect here....not even what Anita wants. Think about it from a different perspective. Its whether or not Simmi has a right to make the judgement here. And abt. Manjuji's thinking that it would ruin their family's respect
mb25 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#6
I think it really depends on the circumstances. Both the son and the daughter should take care of their own parents and their in-laws, especially if they have no other support.
In the Taneja's case, they already have Abhi/Simi helping them whereas Sethi's would have no one with them if Anuj goes. Milli is there for now but she'll leave eventually for school/marriage. I don't think it has to do with self-respect really but with sense of responsibility. It would be irresponsible of Anuj and selfish of Anita to not live with Sethi's but then again maybe Sethi's are better off not having such an evil, manipulative daughter in law living with them.
Laila2009 thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: tvdost

Oh how I hate this term being used blatantly in our serials. Is it a crime to be a ghar jamai. And who is objecting. Mahaan Simi, herself being a woman is putting her foot down. Shame on her being a woman is taking such a stance. She can object to Anuj, Abhi being jobless but what the heck is she objecting about ghar jamai. When a girl after marriage has to stay in her husband's place why not the husband stay with her parents. Maybe for not forever, for sometime. I hate this concept being looked down upon in our society. Personally speaking we are 3 daughters and no brother, so what if one of us stay with our Parents to take care of them during their old age. Does Simi's shaan , maan maryada hurt if her brother stays with his wife's parents. Why these double standards. She should be objecting to all of them enjoying inspite of being jobless and not earning a penny. Just mauj masti they do with their parents money. shame on them.

TV Dost, you bring up a very important point about girls being allowed to be with their families after marriage especially if there are no sons to take care of the parents. However, in the case of KB, Anuj has a responsiblity in taking care of HIS parents. Anita's parents are the responsibility of Abhi and thus have someone to take care of them. So Simi's frustration with Anuj choosing to stay with Anita's parents is valid.
Edited by Laila2009 - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".