Voting/ Selection criteria based on week/ season?

-Sush- thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 15 years ago
#1
The question of elimination brought an interesting thought in my mind...so I though I will open a topic to share various views. Zee DID says that eliminations are based on votes obtained every week. May be they are based on that...may be they are not....who knows....
However, one interesting question I have is...when people vote ...do they consider performance of the week or do they vote based on what they think of the dancer based on their earlier performances....?I think it is the latter. I think...Zee probably also considers voting history of a contestant has rather than their votes for the week.....(it would be better if they admitted to doing so😉...but any way...transparency is not their strength).
Consider Manoj for example.....He has had pretty bad luck in past 2-3 performances...but he was also very good in the ball room round....and he has shown very good performnace with his ring dance on Suraj hua...+ some others with stunts...They stood out. Papiya was fantsatic last week with cloth choreo, has had some outstanding ballrooms, and mujra but her first performance and her performance with Divyam (superhero) was pretty bad....Vaishnavi has had mostly good performances some outstanding ones...including Jhansi rani, Lavani and ek do teen ...but the ball room episode was quite bad, and on saturday she fogot steps...Rutu has had mostly good performances some really bad ones but nothing exceptionally good so far. Jutu has done very well recently but was very average in the beginning (Even if you don't agree with every single characterization here...you know what I am saying).
Although, I was feeling very bad last week that Papiya got the lowest I am thinking may be it is OK for the voters (not sure about Zee) to consider the overall performance curve in keeping some one in or not (Please don't read this to mean I want Papiya out...I think she should be in based on everything, but I understand...how I feel may not be how majority feels). Any way the point is what should one consider for voting..how about other things...not related to dance...meaning how well a contestant talks or how cute/ handsome/goodlooking they are.....
Edited by MsUniverse - 15 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

876

Users

4

Likes

1

Frequent Posters

gr8love thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#2
I agree with you to an extent that stage presence and personality does matter. The winner needs to be the whole package, a super duper etertainer with bucketloads of talent.
The only reason Manoj is still in da show ( assuming that the eliminations ARE based on voting and are NOT scripted). is coz he connects with the masses just like Jitumoni does. However a large part of this 'connection' is totally coz of the jokes and all that extra attention both these get from the judges ( 'aloo paratha' and Farah telling Jitumoni that she wants to take him home etc.....) The same kinda attention is not given to Papiya. The comments to her are mostly restricted to her performance. So she does not connect with the masses so much. Since this is a dance talent show, ideally , the voting should be based on the weeks performance with some consideration given to the overall performances of the contestant.
Its_Sash thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#3
For Zee everything is based on Profit & Loss 🤢
onizuka thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#4
😛 For me.... put aside talent...
talent jumps to i dunno what number...
even sometimes look doesn't count.....
the most important thing is political influence and business factors....
in ur country i dunno how they do it...
but in mine.... the truth will come out months later.... but who cares...
the winner is no longer the idol that time.... he/she won already ....
what can the public say....
anyway by that time the public is following a new idol......
so here we are .... enjoying ourselves...
what ever the producers' decision.. just let it be.....
just like me..... i hate the show but i still watch it...
becoz of the chance to see jai again on tv....
so i add the number of viewers watching that show.....
actually DID is not the kind of show of my liking.....
but i just cudn;t believe myself why i got stuck with this JAI
and he is giving so many controversial issues......
I never like a reality show contestant the way i support him.....
😊
Edited by onizuka - 15 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".