whose Mahi Ve was better?

For those who didnt hear Amey's Mahi Ve, herez the link...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zBk9E45nUnk

Vinit's mahi ve... here's the link... its in episode 49.... click on "Mahi Ve"

http://saregamapa.sifymax.com/videos/week10/

I've heard vinit's mahi ve many times..... but i found Amey's muchhhhh better.... what do u think..... who was better?

guys if u like amey's mahi ve.... so plsss vote 4 him.... this is his todays gala performance...

sms AMEY to 2525

or dial 1904424252505

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Vinit's Mahi Ve was a taaad bit better. Amey's was horrible today. karunya, as always, was SUPERB technically, but somehow i feel he lacks feel while singing.

I'd want any of Amey and Karunya to win the II2. Is there a chance both can win? 😛 😉

so u voted 4 vinit in the poll.....

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Yes, I voted for Vinit in the poll. I usually like Amey, and want him to win the II2, but today, he was very besura and lifeless.

Sandeep is a BLOODY BESURA clone of Uditji. Anuj isn't even a singer.

Anuj sounds like Narendra Chanchal. 😆

Kahin end mein Anuj aur Sandeep final 2 mein na aa jaye. Public ka koi bharosa nahin. 😆

Originally posted by: SolidSnake

Anuj sounds like Narendra Chanchal. 😆

Kahin end mein Anuj aur Sandeep final 2 mein na aa jaye. Public ka koi bharosa nahin. 😆

Arre nahi, Anuj is not as high-pitched or nasal as Narendra Chanchal. 😆

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Karunya's a misfit in II2. He should've been in SRGMP. He would've given the toughest fight to Hema. If there were judges, Karunya would've won against Hema on just ONE point - Karunya's diction is perfect unlike Hema's.

A song is nothing without feel. So there is no way Karunya can ever beat Hema (not talking about janta voting). And comming to Hema's diction, its like chand ka daag jo uskho aur bhi nikhartha hai.

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Karunya's a misfit in II2. He should've been in SRGMP. He would've given the toughest fight to Hema. If there were judges, Karunya would've won against Hema on just ONE point - Karunya's diction is perfect unlike Hema's.

u know it would be a tight fit....ya if there were judges now on public voting if the last 2 were hema and karunya....who would have won????? well idk and the funny part would be that they are ccousins and competing over each other

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Vinit's Mahi Ve was a taaad bit better. Amey's was horrible today. karunya, as always, was SUPERB technically, but somehow i feel he lacks feel while singing.

I'd want any of Amey and Karunya to win the II2. Is there a chance both can win? 😛 😉

yes i agree with you and ya it is a tough competition between Amey and Karunya

adwarakanath wrote:
Vinit's Mahi Ve was a taaad bit better. Amey's was horrible today. karunya, as always, was SUPERB technically, but somehow i feel he lacks feel while singing.

How can u say dat!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! it's wasn't horrible it was so gud.........i think u r karu's fan dat's y u r saying dis we all know in today's gala karu was da best but amey was also gud n u know wut judges were also NOT critical towards amey

n da resaon amey wasnt best today bcoz dis song is sung by 4 or 5 singers but amey was alone 2 sing that whereas when vinit sang dat song, ujjani n paresh ( dun rememba clearly) were literraly singing wid him.

amey sang it alone n he dint even have space to breathe.