whose Mahi Ve was better? - Page 2

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Vinit's Mahi Ve was a taaad bit better. Amey's was horrible today. karunya, as always, was SUPERB technically, but somehow i feel he lacks feel while singing.

I'd want any of Amey and Karunya to win the II2. Is there a chance both can win? 😛 😉

I know I wish that could happen..I love them both!!!😳

Amey Date is my long favorite, but what the hell did he sing today. My expectations from Amey was much much higher. I must say Vinit was much better in this song. Karunya was just mindblowing today. It was an extremely difficult song but what a performance. I don't even feel like talking about the other besura's.

But I have question: Is Farha Khan out of her freaking mind? She had the audacity to say that anyone could sing " Mere haathon mein nau nau chudiyaa hai". You tone deaf Farha do you know that this song was sung by the Goddess of Music and the music is by SHIV-HARI. So before making such idiotic comments think twice. 😡

I think Amey sang well, but I felt that his song lacked "masti".

I wouldn't want to compare him with Karunya when evaluating his performance of this song.

Udit, Sonu and Shankar have sung this song together. I must say that I haven't seen any other singer on FG, II or Saregamapa who has done justice to a song sung by Shankar. His voice is forceful.. both Amey and Vinit sang the song "softly" in his comparison.

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Karunya's a misfit in II2. He should've been in SRGMP. He would've given the toughest fight to Hema. If there were judges, Karunya would've won against Hema on just ONE point - Karunya's diction is perfect unlike Hema's.

Hmm... but I think Hema's classical base is stronger and Hema has got variety. Karunya failed miserably when he sang "Sanson ko saanson mein" from Hum Tum. But maybe Karunya would have improved a lot more in SRGMP. The trainers of II2 suck a lot.

Yesterday, Antara was horrible. Anuj was nasal. Sandeep was besura.Karunya was superb, Amey was uh.. not upto the mark, but his grin scored above the rest😃😆

Originally posted by: MrspetloverUS

Best scenario would be Amey and Karunya in Finals. 😛
Nightmare would be Anuj and Sandeep in Finals. 😒
Don't know where Antara fits in to this 😕

Antara has a big chance of wining since sony wants a girl to be the "idol" this time. I hate Antara... she is such a nautanki. Her voice quality is good but she has no range and no control over sur.

After seeing Sonu's non baised comments show after show, i so much wished he was the mentor at SRGMP. Atleast talented singers like Hema would have got their due recognition if not the winner title and people would realize what good singing is all about instead of getting confused by the bloody biased judgement of those stupid mentors.
My heart felt congratulations to Sonu for doing such a great job as a responsible judge 👏 👏 👏

amey is good usually
but he really dissapointed me yesterday
karunya was awesome
i hope sandeep and anuj r kicked out soon

Karunya was mind blwoing! I love that song and he did such a good job with it. He has a very nice voice, its fresh and you will like a cool breeze is just going through you.

Its good that Karu ddnt come for SRGMP. i would die decidin who was better between him or hema... but i think hema is a better performer... he seems to enjoy his songs more than karu... but karu's diction is just fantastic..

hema really improved his diction from teh beginning to the end, so all credits to him.

i just wish amey n karunya make it to finals, it wuld be awesome..last yr also i felt abhijit n amit were the ebst singers in males and prajakta in females..rahul vaidya was gud..very good..but it sounded toooo much like sonu singin...

Thanks for the link(I missed II yesterday)..Surely Vinit was better

Originally posted by: adwarakanath

Karunya's a misfit in II2. He should've been in SRGMP. He would've given the toughest fight to Hema. If there were judges, Karunya would've won against Hema on just ONE point - Karunya's diction is perfect unlike Hema's.

true

I vote 4 Vineet.

😳