'Dying in the place of someone I loved....' Bella

Page

mishthan

@mishthan

Beginner

Posted: 15 years ago

Hey,

So, as the thread says- it is a quote from Bella (twilight). Okay, we criticise her saying that she's selfish and other stuff...

But she does have a gud side too.......

1. In twilight, the above quote shows she loves Edward selflessly and can die in his place.

2. In Eclipse, she is ready to go into the arena of the battle to make it easier for the Cullens and the wolves.

3. In new moon, she does feel bad when she realizes that she has to choose between Edward and Jacob, the immortal enemies.

4. In Breaking Dawn, she is ready to follow Edward (when she is a vamp) in the arena when he goes to the volturi.

Okay, so i think she is sumhow gud too..........

what do you think?

Quote

Frequent Posters

disha_sen

@disha_sen

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

me an ardent hater of bella so no comments.
One thing i typically dislike abt bella is that she is too dependent on everyone around her.
everyone has their own views. in some places bella shows that she is not selfish but in many other places she shows her selfishness.
sorry if i hurt u but i seriously dont like bella.
its my opinion but ppl might have other things to say.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Varsha

@cuteluv

Navigator

+ 2

Posted: 15 years ago

here if think bella is selfish just coz wht happened with jacob thn its wrong... coz from the very begining she kept on saying to jake wht she felt for him, but still no one can take edwards place in her life... it was jacob's fault tht he always kept on thinking tht he can change bella's mind...

Quote

Zaria

@fly_chick

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

I do think at times bella is not selfish and is good but the times she is selfish the consequenses are much more dramatic so i didn't really like her in NM and Eclipse. Her selfish actions hurt others whereas when she wasn't selfish they didn't affect anyone or change things like in Twilight- what she did was good but it didn't help in the slightest.

QUOTE- cuteluv

QUOTE

i disagree- jacob could see and understand bella better than anyone else, he knew she was in love with him and she denied it saying no one can replace edward- however making hiim the most special guy in your life in NM- meeting him all the time what impression did that give to him- the obvious answer- she loves him. He wanted her to confront her feelings so later there'd be no regrets that what if? She was selfish to him because she clung onto him and she snuck off to meet him what's he supposed to think? She should have left him alone. he thought he could change bella's mind in NM because in twilight she flirted with him and then went with edward so maybe he feels that now edwards not here- she might consider me because she liked me before.

Quote

Mrs.Pattinson/Robert/Cullen/Edward

@ROBlicious.

Sparkler

+ 4

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: cuteluv
here if think bella is selfish just coz wht happened with jacob thn its wrong... coz from the very begining she kept on saying to jake wht she felt for him, but still no one can take edwards place in her life... it was jacob's fault tht he always kept on thinking tht he can change bella's mind...

You are so Right! I mean in New Moon she didn't ask Jake to be her BF or something He wanted to be so he tries to kiss her. As they say if the kiss wasn't suppose to happen it didn't.

Because If Bella Kissed Jake there and remember she was like He could be mine forever. Bella would Die for Edward but then he called ☺️.

So Bella tries to do anything for Edward. Jacob does it all him self so Bella doesnt.

Quote

disha_sen

@disha_sen

Navigator

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: fly_chick
I do think at times bella is not selfish and is good but the times she is selfish the consequenses are much more dramatic so i didn't really like her in NM and Eclipse. Her selfish actions hurt others whereas when she wasn't selfish they didn't affect anyone or change things like in Twilight- what she did was good but it didn't help in the slightest.

QUOTE- cuteluv

here if think bella is selfish just coz wht happened with jacob thn its wrong... coz from the very begining she kept on saying to jake wht she felt for him, but still no one can take edwards place in her life... it was jacob's fault tht he always kept on thinking tht he can change bella's mind...

QUOTE

i disagree- jacob could see and understand bella better than anyone else, he knew she was in love with him and she denied it saying no one can replace edward- however making hiim the most special guy in your life in NM- meeting him all the time what impression did that give to him- the obvious answer- she loves him. He wanted her to confront her feelings so later there'd be no regrets that what if? She was selfish to him because she clung onto him and she snuck off to meet him what's he supposed to think? She should have left him alone. he thought he could change bella's mind in NM because in twilight she flirted with him and then went with edward so maybe he feels that now edwards not here- she might consider me because she liked me before.

i totally agree. bella always gave the wrong hints to jake n so he thought that maybe he can try to atleast win her back.

But anyways i guess we should end the discussion here coz if v continue it will lead to arguments n in return affect the peace of this forum.