Why meenal in bottom 3?

Page

Poll

What do you think is missing in her singing?

saira khan

@gigishah

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

My opinion to her

She should stop singing legend singers songs ............cus when ppl .......... camper her voice quality ..........with reshma ..lata ..nusrat fathe ali ..or asha she is not up to that level .......... I think the most voters are from young generation they hardly listens to this songs......... she should pick some songs sang by sundhi chauhan .shreya ghoshal . alisha chinoy or alka yagnik

please post your reviews

Quote

Frequent Posters

anonmember

@anonmember

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

Meenal did sing a song by Sundhi Chauhan, Ishq Samandar, but still ended up in the bottom three. Singing songs by legends has nothing to do with being in the bottom three. Antara sings Lataji songs, Karyuna sang a song by Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan in the last gala too.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Huzaifa Kaderbhai

@kothra

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

hi
meenal is a great singer..he can very far and i blv in her..she just needa support from ol of us
huzi

Quote

Kadwiphool

@Kadwiphool

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

Originally posted by: sonyaee
Meenal did sing a song by Sundhi Chauhan, Ishq Samandar, but still ended up in the bottom three. Singing songs by legends has nothing to do with being in the bottom three. Antara sings Lataji songs, Karyuna sang a song by Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan in the last gala too.

i agree with you. meenal's always been in bottom 3 except once (when she said amey was hot) despite her really goood singing. antara herself has picked horrible songs to sing except past 2 weeks and still she's never been in bottom 3! so there u go.

Quote

Natasha

@SoNi_KuDi

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

the reason y she's in bottom three is cuz she's NOT from a small village 😭

Quote

smartalec21

@smartalec21

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

Originally posted by: SoNi_KuDi
the reason y she's in bottom three is cuz she's NOT from a small village 😭

c'mmon...i don't think tht's da reason....it's just tht even though i really like meenal's singin a lot i find tht sometimes in her singin the soul's missin..she's just singin from her 'gala'..not her 'dil'....but the thing tht i have a pr with is tht..thr r worse singers then her on the show but they've managed 2 stay out of the clutches of bottom 3...😭

Quote

Zulu

@nibbler

Inactive

Posted: 20 years ago

about my opinion

i am going to say it is due to the foolishness of the indian janta.......... 😆 😆 😆

Quote

effervescent

@effervescent

Navigator

Posted: 20 years ago

Originally posted by: tpam
MEENAL IS IN BOTTOM 3 FOR NO OTHER REASONS BECOZ NEITHER SHE IS FROM ANY BIG CITY NOR FROM ANY SMALL REMOTE AREA!!
IF IT WAS A BIG CITY, SHE WUD AHV GOT PLENTY OF VOTES AND IF FROM REMOTE AREAS THEN ALSO PPL GETS VOTES ALL OVER THE COUNTRY, NO OFFENSE TO SANDEEP AND OTHERS..
SHE IS FROM INDORE WHICH IS NT A RICH PLACE NEITHER IT IS SO SMALL THAT PPL FEEL BAD FOR HER!!!
SHE DESERVES TO B AT LEAST IN TOP 3!!!

BUT I DNT SEE ANY HOPE LEFT FOR HER 😭 😭 😭

I agree.