Injustice... - Page 3

Originally posted by: Sunita182

Also, people referring to some of the contesttants as ''recycling products''

the world knows and agrees RECYCLING is good for everyone and is the way forward LOL

😉

I am fine with recycled contestants especially those who were very good singers, but were eliminated too early on other shows and one's who won or were runner ups on a no name show and got nothing out of it.

Now if someone like Harshit, Debojit, Toshi, Raja, Sharib, Rahul, Vineet etc. was taking part again in this show then I would have agreed that injustice is being done because all of them are doing fine in different ways.


😊

If II is abt welcoming new and fresh talent then what is Manisha Shree Ram doing here. If judges don't have problem w/ Manisha and Shre Ram and other relaity shows contestants then y w/yash Raj. The only diff between Yash Raj and manISHA and other recycled contestants is that YashRaj had luck so won whereas Manisha and other recycled ones didn't. If Yashraj had luck w/him and won what's his fault on that....Like someone said the show he won was not that popular so I think it's fair.
if u wanna hear my opinion I say sONY shld n;t take any contestants from any other shows. But since sony has already done that i think YashRaj is equally as deserving as Manisha and Shree Ram for this title =]

Originally posted by: Angad_Kripa_200

Before I start this post... Let me clarify, this is not a Yashraj bashing post :P

Okay... Guys as well all have witnessed, this year the contestants of II5 are from other reality shows... To be really honest... I don't have a problem with the "recycled contestants"... They have participated in II5 because they have not been able to win the reality shows they have previously been a part of and also because even though they have been a part of those shows, they have not been able to make a impact in the music industry...

But this is what I have a problem with...

Yashraj is one of the contestants taking part in II5 who has already won a reality show... I mean if he has previously won a title and earned recognition, why does he need to be a part of II5... Don't you think injustice is being done to the other contestants for whom this is their first reality show... This guy has already won, that mean he does have a lot of voters out there from the previous show so definately he is bound to do good in II5 as well... If he has not won, it was reasonable for him to be a part of this show... But since he is already a winner... Why take part again and take away chances from other potentials...
<div></div>

exactly my point!!! it is unfair if he has WON a previous talent show................i beleive manishha is also a winner of some show............not saregamapa....she was out of that but i read somewhere she won another talent show!!!

but whats ur take on the professional hyderabadi singer.............sreeram i think.........is it fair on others becasue he is a professional hyderabadi playback singer? 😕 😕 😕