Footage of selected top 16/17 contestants - Page 2

Originally posted by: somone999

I guess judges must have seen something good in those who are selected.
Let's see how they go on with the show. I hope they prove themselves.

Originally posted by: ready2rock

oh the judges also saw a lot of good in suhit, remo, altamash and a lot of others whom we all know r not that good singers...what i mean to say is that judges can also be wrong sometimes...i as an audience surely wud have preferred to see all the top 25's singing if not the entire 112 that were selected...maybe then i wud have been content that ok my so and so fav singer didn't sing good and that's why they r out😉 now it's like bhatakti aatma kind of situation 😆 as i really don't know if three of my early favs i.e SairaBanu, Geetesh and Neha really deserved to go out🤔

Originally posted by: somone999

I agree with the high-lighted part, but this time I have full faith in 'these' judges, WHY?, because it is entirely a musical panel - a composer, a singer and a composer + singer! yeah but kinda wierd na ki is musical panel mein kabhi kabhi teenon mein se ek ko sur dikhta hai do ko nahi, do ko lay dikhta hai teesre ko nahi😆

There are no choreographers, no actors and no lyricist! i'm fine with lyricist as a judge obviously Jaavedji had great knowledge of music haa choreographers or actors no ways So, it makes their judgment more believable and trust-able. Cheers!

Originally posted by: ready2rock

That shows that music is very 'subjective', everyone looks for different things in the singer. But at least, they all belong the music industry, so it gives them a point for credibility. That disagreement also comes in our IF musical competition as well.

Yes, Javed Saab is an excellent judge, no doubt. But, I prefer this panel over the earlier panel as they are more into what is modern music along with the old music. Also, an inclusion of an actor in the panel was completely absurd earlier!

Originally posted by: somone999

but then addition of jaavedji imo wud have been really great...i always liked him as a judge😛

Originally posted by: ready2rock

Naahh, I have seen enough of Javed Saab! (joking) though he is an excellent judge, but this new panel is very refreshing for me. I have no problem with it. Maybe Javed Saab can come next year. Let's see whether this panel proves itself better than the previous panel or not.