i like it ,they make it difficult

this time there style of choosing is so difficult and i like it now this show will get rocking singers.they change the scale or taal for the contestants. wow.

Yeah Bratz.. me too liked the change! =]

I loved that as well.. Not only does the show become more interesting for the viewer but it allows the contestants to be seen out of their comfort zone and eventually expanding their musical capabilities

plus it enables the judges to squeeze out a stronger group vocal-wise as opposed to their competition

I like the change too!!!

AWESOMENESS!

Reminded me of the good old SaReGaMa when Sonu Nigam used to host. There used to be a judges choice round, where contestants would have to sing a song given by the judge on the spot! And there was a chord round where the singer would have to catch the right scale of the song from the chord and sing the whole song with only the chord to back them up!

True test of singing talent. Indian Idol 5 is going to rock!

That shows that Indian Idol needs Real Judges who are actually singers/Composers or related to music. Not just anyone who knows what music is.