How rude should judges be? - Page 2

Originally posted by: mintyblue

I agree with cosworth kid

Today's kids especially below 15 yrs are a different sort than those in the 18-25 age group and older age group...the latter being more balanced

a. The kids of the mid and late 90's are extremely precocious - They think TV, Internet is their life. They can't see beyond the visual life. that's why this generation does not read books like their counterparts did a decade ago. Not even Tintin, Tinkle comics, but Enid Blyton books, imagination, creativity,outdoor games...all on d way out.

b. These kids are lacking in General Knowledge - India is fast becoming like the U.S, just ask the 10-15 yr olds today any question as simple as - 'How many oceans are there in d world?' - 90% won't b able to answer.

c. Thye are celebrity- crazy - They idolize Hannah Montana, Twilight and such bizarre stuff. Last generation at least had Harry potter which was intelligent enough. Nowadays the trend towards pop-music taht too of a crappy kind is being idolized by kids. This pop music is far worse than even Backstreet Boys n Britney Spears of a generation back. There is much dumbing down in name of music.

Overall the music relaity shows will only get bigger is my prediction. The kids are competition- crazy. i saw last year in little champs 2009 the way the kids were bitching about each other and the unhealthy attitude to competiton ( except Abhigyan of course). On the other hand, see the contestnats of shows like Challenge 2007 where Aneek, Raja, sumedha etc are such good friends.

I think that the judges can be too harsh sometimes too, these ppl come in with there expectations really high thinking that they can sing, there is a way of talking to someone and falling asleep at the table while they are singing is not it.

Originally posted by: Sujal_Fan_No1

I think that the judges can be too harsh sometimes too, these ppl come in with there expectations really high thinking that they can sing, there is a way of talking to someone and falling asleep at the table while they are singing is not it.

I wonder what there reactions would have been, if it was them having a adution and someone was doing that too them??

I think judges should be strict but not RUDE sometime they insult too much to the singer they should say politely that they cant sing instead of doing dramas because they r like teachers and teacher should not insult their students even if they r weak in their study they can send them back without insulting them