are Creatives really creative enough?

Page

Next Last

Bani

@Omshanti1111

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

are the creatives really creatives or are copy masters...😆 I remember even a showman like Sanjay Leela Bhansali copied the movie "Hum dil de chuke sanam" from a bengali book called "Nya hanyate"...but he never gave any credit to the author...

I feel many of the incidents of Bidaai are taken from old Hindi movies and also new...
we have definitely seen "taare zameen par" scene in the shlok track...

Anamika Anmol story: there are many, but recently if someone has seen the movie Sirf tum, it followed the concept from there. I can name a few more also..

Sadhna-Alekh abnormal part is shown from the movie Khilona of 1970s...and then normal Alekh-Sadhna from maine pyar kiya...

lets see if others can add more...

Quote

Frequent Posters

Rose-Petals

@Rose-Petals

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

agree with u same circle revolving around movies & plays yet all

prove successful in gaining viewer's attention 😊 whether copied from old concepts. 😆

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Bani

@Omshanti1111

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

actually most of the shows copy stuff from hindi movies, that too from old movies, so that many people cannot make out...

Quote

-SalShah4eva-

@-SalShah4eva-

Elite

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

RS use to give credit to Rajshari in the begging of the show..

but these smal moments

they should give credits too

or just dont copy if u dont wana give credits

Quote

Bani

@Omshanti1111

Inactive

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: KiNnY-pArTnEr
RS use to give credit to Rajshari in the begging of the show..
but these smal moments

they should give credits too

or just dont copy if u dont wana give credits

actually they take names of Rajshri..but they copy from many places..but they keep secret...or else their blunt copying will get caught...

Quote

-SalShah4eva-

@-SalShah4eva-

Elite

+ 3

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111

actually they take names of Rajshri..but they copy from many places..but they keep secret...or else their blunt copying will get caught...

he took name of Rajshri coz RS inspired by their movies

thats why YR and Bidaai is like Rajshri movies

abt other things they copied

they shouldn do that

Quote

Rose-Petals

@Rose-Petals

Dazzler

Posted: 15 years ago

yes i also appreciate Rajshri movies coz of their superb stories 👏

Quote

Pallavi

@-Pallavi-

Voyager

Posted: 15 years ago

Originally posted by: Omshanti1111
are the creatives really creatives or are copy masters...😆 I remember even a showman like Sanjay Leela Bhansali copied the movie "Hum dil de chuke sanam" from a bengali book called "Nya hanyate"...but he never gave any credit to the author...

I feel many of the incidents of Bidaai are taken from old Hindi movies and also new...
we have definitely seen "taare zameen par" scene in the shlok track...

Anamika Anmol story: there are many, but recently if someone has seen the movie Sirf tum, it followed the concept from there. I can name a few more also..

Sadhna-Alekh abnormal part is shown from the movie Khilona of 1970s...and then normal Alekh-Sadhna from maine pyar kiya...

lets see if others can add more...

Now this Anand's story looks like "Trishul" and other similar stories. Not so sure how the track proceeds.

Quote

BeOptimistic

@allizzwell

Stunner

+ 5

Posted: 15 years ago

Yes , Bani..... many filmy masalas are added as ingredients to get the recipe "Bidaai".....now to forget the base itself got derived from ' Vivaah'........yes offlate the seq. had its concepts straightly lifted from Maine Pyaar Kiya... so many small concepts have been used if we see the seq. we will be able to compare them better......Yeh Rishta, i am happy has its own concept and its own derivations regarding the relationships....till now, i am under the assumption, it has been quite innovative in presentation.....😊