Mithun Da's opinion as the Grand Master.... - Page 2

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😃 I agree Sahana, it doesn't matter much who he gives the POTD too. And if it matters then it should also matter who he gives grand salutes too and who he has said his favorite contestant is. 😃 I mean we can't just pick and choose can we? If Mithun Da thought Shakti deserved all those POTD awards and we think he was being fair then, it would be logical then to believe he was also being fair when he said Dharmesh sir was his favorite contestant, no? 😃

Well he is a human being too, and he can make mistakes, and he does. So i dont rely on his judgement, i rely on my own.... if people feel that he is right when he gives potd to shakti and wrong when he gives it to dharmesh then thats their choice, but I dont think like tht...

Originally posted by: hindu4lyf

Did you not read my post or do you do this for some sort of entertainment I do not understand.
I clearly said that the POTD is not something where you need to know the technicalities of dance because most of the time even an average viewer will be able to tell you what the best performance was (based on judges comments).

LOL...Some comments are hard to understand, H4L 😉

Ankit---Anyone can judge which performance is adjudicated as the best one for the day:
1. The performance which received the best comments from mentors (such as Shakti-Amar's Kalaripayattu, Vandana-Shakti;s duet)
2. The performance that is entertaining (such as Jack and Amrita)
3. The performance that receives superlative comments from one or two of the mentors and which is a new style (Dharmesh-Binny's Waltz).

Even while watching, the normal junta could tell, so it wont be difficult for Mithun to judge. As a GM he does not make any comments that sets him apart from the other three mentors. Whatever he says is already said by the mentors first.
Mithun himself confesses kie "mein dance ke baare mein zyada nahi jaanta".

Originally posted by: sunandshine

LOL...Some comments are hard to understand, H4L 😉

Ankit---Anyone can judge which performance is adjudicated as the best one for the day:
1. The performance which received the best comments from mentors (such as Shakti-Amar's Kalaripayattu, Vandana-Shakti;s duet)
2. The performance that is entertaining (such as Jack and Amrita)
3. The performance that receives superlative comments from one or two of the mentors and which is a new style (Dharmesh-Binny's Waltz).

Even while watching, the normal junta could tell, so it wont be difficult for Mithun to judge. As a GM he does not make any comments that sets him apart from the other three mentors. Whatever he says is already said by the mentors first.
Mithun himself confesses kie "mein dance ke baare mein zyada nahi jaanta".

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

So then according to you Mithun Da doesn't know much about the "technicalities involved in dancing", so that means the POTD's which he in charge of judging and awarding are pretty meaningless, no? 😃

You have to take everything counted, masters' comments with exception of Geeta, other contestants reactions, audience reaction, anchor reaction and then match with Mithun da's reasoning if everything seems in sync then POTD is meaningless else it is meanignless. And take my opinion too.😃

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

I am confused about something......So Terrence and Shakti supporters love to use her POTD awards to support their opinions as to why Shakti is the best dancer on the show.....If that's the case then they surely would agree that Mithun Da is awesome at judging dance as he is the one solely incharge of giving POTD. So then why is it that the same Mithun Da is jeered by Terrence fans and mocked when he says anything positive about Dharmesh, Amrita, or Binny. I mean which is it, if Mithun Da is biased towards Geeta ki gang then why would he give all those POTD awards to Shakti? and if Mithun Da is not biased then why bash him and mock him as not knowing anything about dance when he praises Geeta and her contestants? 😃 To me it seems very comical when Terrence and Shakti fans jump up and down over their contestant winning POTD from Mithun Da and in the very next breath bash and mock Mithun Da as someone not qualified to judge a dance show when he praises Dharmesh sir, Amrita and Binny? 😊

Im not sure you realize that this is a personal call to Terence and Shakti supporters.
Do you really have to always bring them into every conversation/topic?

Originally posted by: nadiim

the answer is simply they are jealous and are insecure...

Personal attack.
First warning cause its violative of rule #3 of DID section rules.
And no you cant PM me and say that its unfair of me since you were bashing Terence & shakti supporters & that im a major terence fan.

You're being warned for your personal attack.

Originally posted by: ankit_nyc

😃 I am starting to think the same

Same as the other member.
Personal attack. TWICE. In this thread.

FIrst warning.