Created

Last reply

Replies

25

Views

3.3k

Users

13

Likes

46

Frequent Posters

bambooshoot thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: nithyak

The same studio audience voted in earlier matches too and made teams loose or win.

My question to topic starter:

You say studio audiences votes can be manipulated easily. Do you think they were manipulated in earlier matches too ??



A valid question! Yes, I did think that audience voting was a means to manipulate things to make things work according to the channel's whims and fancies right from the beginning of the competition. Since the judges here were contestants as well, it would have been difficult to control the marking that they gave. So audience voting was used as a means to have control on the decisions made.

However, I never expected that audience voting would be introduced in the finale on pre-recorded songs. Till before that, decision-making for the semi-finalists and finalists have been based only on the previous points and the public voting. So I at least did not expect this in the finals as to me it seemed very illogical to consider the votes of a small studio audience in front of millions of viewers across the world. The on-line voting and the SMS counts can be traced if required and there are some legal implications to it. We ourselves had to go thro' disclaimers on the website while voting. But there is absolutely no control over the studio audience voting.

So I feel cheated!
428419 thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#22

Originally posted by: cosmos2010

Shankar is a LEGEND and deserved to win by all means even without regional support . There was a burning desire in him to win which was missing sadly in Shaan. Even without the prefinale lead of 2 marks they would have won they were ahead of Shaan in the medley round by 3 marks.



This is the biggest mistake people have in their mind.MKMM is not about individual singers,but the teams.its not about whether SHANKAR IS A LEGEND or not....Everyone knows that Shankar is a legend...but what about his team.........the show is about Shaan's Strikers v/s Shankar's Rockstars..............and not about Shaan and Shankar.......Its about the teams.If u look at the teams......just say one thing.......how many times have u seen chupa rustam sanjeev singing in MKMM??(he hardly gets chance to sing)..then coming to Neeti....no idea how can she goof up so many times.she goofed up in the medley of the finale too........and her besura rendition in the pre finale.who can forget that........then there is sharib who shout shouts to get votes.so left is Rahul Vaidya....he is the only deserving candidate.but alas,Shankar gives no one a chance.he goes in every round and performs and gets 10 marks........and its quite obvious that people will dare not give him less than 10,which shows the 9-9-9-9 score startegy at the finale pre planned

Shaan's fans have not hijacked this forum but there are certain fanatics who can never hear bad about their favourites.We are saying shaan is better because he was the best captain with respect to MKMM.he has always given a fair chance to all his team mates......even though anwesha is the strongest in his team,but shaan never relied on her.....I think the deserving teams to reach the finale were Shaan's team and Shreya's team .they had the finest contenders fit to be in a finale and were great as captains(though aneek's talent was not used to the fullest).................


Edited by rijul1 - 15 years ago
vasamv thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#23
Yes,we were talking of Shaan's team and his captainship..He knew whom to send when for batting,Chhupa Rustam,Shadaab,was used properly.Anwesha was the winner,but it was not all about Anu only.
Look at what Himesh did with another bundle of talent,Aishwarya.We wonder why she was not given enough chances.Had Himesh used her talent properly he could have been in finals.
rahul_02006 thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#24

Originally posted by: rijul1



This is the biggest mistake people have in their mind.MKMM is not about individual singers,but the teams.its not about whether SHANKAR IS A LEGEND or not....Everyone knows that Shankar is a legend...but what about his team.........the show is about Shaan's Strikers v/s Shankar's Rockstars..............and not about Shaan and Shankar.......Its about the teams.If u look at the teams......just say one thing.......how many times have u seen chupa rustam sanjeev singing in MKMM??(he hardly gets chance to sing)..then coming to Neeti....no idea how can she goof up so many times.she goofed up in the medley of the finale too........and her besura rendition in the pre finale.who can forget that........then there is sharib who shout shouts to get votes.so left is Rahul Vaidya....he is the only deserving candidate.but alas,Shankar gives no one a chance.he goes in every round and performs and gets 10 marks........and its quite obvious that people will dare not give him less than 10,which shows the 9-9-9-9 score startegy at the finale pre planned

Shaan's fans have not hijacked this forum but there are certain fanatics who can never hear bad about their favourites.We are saying shaan is better because he was the best captain with respect to MKMM.he has always given a fair chance to all his team mates......even though anwesha is the strongest in his team,but shaan never relied on her.....I think the deserving teams to reach the finale were Shaan's team and Shreya's team .they had the finest contenders fit to be in a finale and were great as captains(though aneek's talent was not used to the fullest).................


I think mistake people have in their mind is that mkmm its just about the teams???? I think it is about the individulal singers and the teams combined. Shankar being a legend does matter as he is a part of the team. Not only uses his talent and experience for his singing but also for others performances and ofcourse the medleys. I think Anwesha has sung more then any other singer int he strilers neways if you think Shaan is the best captain as he has given fair chance to all and dint rely on anwesha completely then I really think I can also become a captain. I definitely will not compete against other contestants and also make sure all r given fair chances. Only thing I cannot sing or encorage the team as good as shaan does. I could atleast satisfy half of the required qualities to become best captain.
Ranbir.Fan thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 15 years ago
#25

Originally posted by: susan29

[]

This is not the first time that sms voting is there in a show.....so you must know its pros and cons before u even spent yur money on voting....the team you vote for doesnt always win !!!

I completely agree with this!
I myself used to vote in Indian idol 1, but then latter on when more & more reality shows started coming I stopped. I hardly watch reality shows. After a long time I watched a reality show, i.e MKMM bcoz I saw shreya in the promo, and i think after 4 years I voted, just bcoz shreya is my favorite, but she didnt make it to finals! Actually I would advice you that dont take these reality shows so seriously, the more u do the more upset u will feel! So just relax!

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".