DOTW:Is it's correct 2 donate organs for money?

Page

Priyank

@Priyank.

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

Well, we saw in yesterday's episode that amit getting no other way to get the 4 lakhs, he decided to donate his kidney for money

It is not only amit, there must be so many poor people in India who do such a thing

He decided not to commit suicide but instead donate his kidney

Do you guys think it's correct and justified to donate your organs for money when you have no other option left ??

Quote

Frequent Posters

birju4baby

@birju4baby

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

I cannot tell you if it is correct or not to donate one's organs ... but it is very very sad and tragic .. that people have to do that ... When someone decides to do that .. he or she must be in so much distress and desperate to take such step .. It is sad that poverty drives people to take such step ..

I wish nobody in their lives have ever to do such step .. I was wondering if AMit could take a loan for studies .. as they do in western world and then he can continue his studies ..

BTW .. I love discussions we have in this forum ... these discussions make us think ...

Edited by birju4baby - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

binita

@binie

Voyager

Posted: 16 years ago

well i dont know if it is correct or not....

this is wrong: u shouldnt sell ur body part to get money.... but the person who is in that situation it can be the only way he can see.... thats why he might think to do so.....

this is right: to sell ur body part and get money is better idea then commit suside..... so if anyone has decide to commit suside with having probs like money they can save their life by doing such a thing.....

i m very confuse.... but lets pray to god to give everyone enough in life thats why they do not need to take any step like this 😛

even i wonder why Amit is not taking LOAN?????

Quote

pinufan

@pinufan

Navigator

Posted: 16 years ago

i dont think so that selling an organ is a right thing when u dont have money. but when someone is dying yes then if he wishes he can do so..

but what amit did was wrong..

Quote

Angelic

@Angelic_A

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

Seems like a good topic for DOTW.. so making it a sticky topic.

Quote

Priyank

@Priyank.

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: birju4baby
I cannot tell you if it is correct or not to donate one's organs ... but it is very very sad and tragic .. that people have to do that ... When someone decides to do that .. he or she must be in so much distress and desperate to take such step .. It is sad that poverty drives people to take such step ..

I wish nobody in their lives have ever to do such step .. I was wondering if AMit could take a loan for studies .. as they do in western world and then he can continue his studies ..

BTW .. I love discussions we have in this forum ... these discussions make us think ...

very well said, even i hope that no human being on this earth ever faces such a situation that he or she has to donate their organs but reality is always bitter, as u said poverty is the main factor that drives ppl to do so and this is quite prevalent in our country

Yes, Amit can certainly take a loan, i guess that will be the only option he will have

Quote

Priyank

@Priyank.

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: binie
well i dont know if it is correct or not....

this is wrong: u shouldnt sell ur body part to get money.... but the person who is in that situation it can be the only way he can see.... thats why he might think to do so.....

this is right: to sell ur body part and get money is better idea then commit suside..... so if anyone has decide to commit suside with having probs like money they can save their life by doing such a thing.....

i m very confuse.... but lets pray to god to give everyone enough in life thats why they do not need to take any step like this 😛

even i wonder why Amit is not taking LOAN?????

nice views Binie, yes agree, rather than commiting suicide and ending ur life, it wud be good if the person goes for this option when definately there is no other option left with him/her

Commiting suicide is a crime and an insult to God who has gifted us this beautiful present to us, we should all be thankful to Him

Quote

Priyank

@Priyank.

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: pinufan
i dont think so that selling an organ is a right thing when u dont have money. but when someone is dying yes then if he wishes he can do so..
but what amit did was wrong..

Yes certainly, one can always opt for donating their organ after they die, this way they can keep themselves alive in some or the other way

the best donation i think is to donate your eyes