WHY PEOPLE LIKE PANNA'A VOICE

Please give us a reason why you like Panna's voice. Please be comparative and ignore his dancing avility and his look.

Originally posted by: sadhana K

Are you asking for a technical analysis of his voice? Not all people base their choice of a singer on objective analysis alone.
For people like me, there is a total dissociation between the objective and subjective analysis.
Panna sings fairly well, (sounds good to my ears),and is very presentable; so ,I like his voice. I don't think there are specific criteria which need to be fulfilled to achieve that.

In this stage of this competation every one expected to sing well, because they were chosen as a cream out of corn. However, out of 12, do you think Panna has an outstanding voice which can take him to long way. Obviously, performance is important for this kind of show, but when you do the playback, do you realy need performance? It is very essential for a person to be good at in singing rather than in performance in oder to establish himself or hershef as great singer for a long time.

In this stage of this competation every one expected to sing well, because they were chosen as a cream out of corn. However, out of 12, do you think Panna has an outstanding voice which can take him to long way. Obviously, performance is important for this kind of show, but when you do the playback, do you realy need performance? It is very essential for a person to be good at in singing rather than in performance in oder to establish himself or hershef as great singer for a long time.

I totally agree w/ u...i mean look at Asha Bhosle, Lata Mageshkar, Mohammed Rafi, and all the famous "singers"....they don't perform! but they r still in the industry and r considered a legend...Indian Idol shud live to the level of being considered as a legend...

do u guyz think if Panna wins...he will be called a legend in the future??

Originally posted by: anik

In this stage of this competation every one expected to sing well, because they were chosen as a cream out of corn. However, out of 12, do you think Panna has an outstanding voice which can take him to long way. Obviously, performance is important for this kind of show, but when you do the playback, do you realy need performance? It is very essential for a person to be good at in singing rather than in performance in oder to establish himself or hershef as great singer for a long time.

This competition is more of a contest for stage performance-hence, voice alone is not the criterion. Why do you think Farah Khan is on the judges' panel? Not to judge the pure singing talent. In fact, she has really put down Meenal(a good singer!) on more than one occasion for lack of performance.

Again, I maintain what is important in this contest is 'a total package'. Also, Panna is not a bad singer - I would rank him in the middle order amongst the current contestants.

Originally posted by: Pari_88

In this stage of this competation every one expected to sing well, because they were chosen as a cream out of corn. However, out of 12, do you think Panna has an outstanding voice which can take him to long way. Obviously, performance is important for this kind of show, but when you do the playback, do you realy need performance? It is very essential for a person to be good at in singing rather than in performance in oder to establish himself or hershef as great singer for a long time.

I totally agree w/ u...i mean look at Asha Bhosle, Lata Mageshkar, Mohammed Rafi, and all the famous "singers"....they don't perform! but they r still in the industry and r considered a legend...Indian Idol shud live to the level of being considered as a legend...

do u guyz think if Panna wins...he will be called a legend in the future??

Originally posted by: sadhana K

Excuse me! I don't think the stage has been set to hunt for playback singers! At least, that is not what I understand.

This competition is more of a contest for stage performance-hence, voice alone is not the criterion. Why do you think Farah Khan is on the judges' panel? Not to judge the pure singing talent. In fact, she has really put down Meenal(a good singer!) on more than one occasion for lack of performance.

Again, I maintain what is important in this contest is 'a total package'. Also, Panna is not a bad singer - I would rank him in the middle order amongst the current contestants.

I totally agree w/ u...i mean look at Asha Bhosle, Lata Mageshkar, Mohammed Rafi, and all the famous "singers"....they don't perform! but they r still in the industry and r considered a legend...Indian Idol shud live to the level of being considered as a legend...

do u guyz think if Panna wins...he will be called a legend in the future??

You mean to say-Abhijeet Sawant/Qazi/Rooprekha-are all going to be known as legends? If so,then Panna will too!

Yes...i do think that Abhijeet Sawant in the future will be a legend bcz he was the FIRST II.....Qazi and Rooprekha r already gone in the wind...😆😆 and i didn't mean to say that Panna is a bad singer.....as u said v r looking for a "complete package"......so u think Amey or Karunya r not complete packages?? they don't entertain u??