Nothing Personal,Just An Opinion,Do reply

nandini76 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

dear friends

just wanted discuss a few things...share a few thoughts...need opinions & reactions...was thinking of this whole show of sa re ga ma pa....things that happened....ect...

Do we really feel what happened was right...right from the begining i noticed that the mentors especially HR & ID were discussing personal issues & problems of the contestents...were these justified...what is the need of personal things like debojit not having a mother or his noble deeds like serving old age home,vinit not doing financially well & respecting mother ect be talked about...that too if u all have observed..it was only done with 2 contestents debojit & vinit..what has any of this got to do with a singing competition....did shreya goshal use the same method to win the competition....when painters exibit their paintings do they even exibit a list of their personal problems beside it so that if people dont like their painting & buy it atleast they'll buy it seeing their problems....that will only show what kind of an artist he is it will only prove how bad his art is...& if the mentors felt it has got to do something then what happened to the others...is it their bad luck that their parents are alive or is it their bad luck that they dont feel the need to discuss their personal problems or is it their bad luck that they only believe in working hard & reaching their goals & nothing else...do we realise what wrong messege is being passed here...is it really right to win competitions on the note of sympathy...now why should i not believe that debojit got all those votes only coz of the sympathetic talks...i do agree he has a very good voice...he has talent but in my opinion he isnt worthy of the no 1 postion... i would have still accepted the decision of the public if debojit had got all these votes without these personal matters being talked about in each & every episode...ismail ji did that even in the last episode which only proves that people or public got emotinal & voted for him...so then what values r we teaching today's generation...what messege are we passing that talent+little hard work+lots of sympathy/cheating=winning....i am really happy that nihira is out of this dirty game...iam happy that she got out with dignity & maturity...probably our mentors need to learn a lot from her in my eyes she was the winner the minute she said that today if she is voted out 1 challenge ends & a new 1 begins....i feel nihira,swananda,himani,hemachandra,vinit all of you are any day better to debojit & my messege to you all is that never give up...today by whatever voting debojit wins tomorrow every1 will know the truth...you all must prove the public that their decision was wrong.....i want to pass a messge to all the participants that never give up challenges coz a cheaters win is just for today but a hardwork & sincerity wins for life..you all are very good & just make all of us proud😊

debojit fans just want to let you all know that i have nothing personal against debojit.he has a very good voice.but this is my opinion.

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.1k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

jay_delhi_guy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
your POST is good but after looking at the last Paragraph understood one thing clearly....You are a VINIT fan. Now sorry to say, VINIT will be out of the contest as you wasted your time writing such a big post (and that too discussing the same thing again and again as you did in many other post) and not voting him...and so he will be out very soon...Go dear save him....
Before achieving anything he has become so proudy...what to say..another AS in making...
nandini76 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
jay_delhi_guy

no my friend you got me wrong..iam not a vinit fan..i was never a vinit fan...i would rather say i liked everybody...but personally my fav were nihira,swananda,himani & hemachandra....u r right that i have been repeating a few things again & agin coz people are just ignoring these issues...i dont care if debojit wins or vinit looses...as i have said before tomorrow people will know they were wrong...this is not the last platform of competitions...by the way even iam kishore kumar fan...but as ive said before debojit might have a voice like him but to sing like him he will need a lot of training & voice moulding...& i hope he comes up to ur expectations 1 day..as of now for me its just nihira among girls & hemachandra among guys 😊
mdroy thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4
I agree that personal issues should not matter but the PRODUCERS went
with that angle and then HR exploited it and then the other mentors
followed suit.

BTW it is Kolkata ki Ladli Ujjani and Mumbai ki Mulgi Nihira. In fact those
without nicknames lost first (Raktima, Sharib, and Swananda).

What about Rajiv's cook with a new look? I wanted to go to Costco and
buy Mother's day cards for Vinit, Sharib, Raktima, and Himani --did I miss
anyone? I need the bulk discount. We can throw in a father's day card for
Debo.

Ujjaini's I missed a year of school for this -- so may a graduation card
when she gets there.

Swananda emotional plea to let her come back to india - - as if she was
on some sort of watch list where she won't be allowed to come back
without SRGMP.

Only Paresh, Hema, Nihira, and Twinkle did not pull out sob stories
(though Paresh had the accent advantage).

nandini76 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#5
hi mdroy

very true 😊 have to agree well said...😆

lajawab thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#6
chukkna said--
"What is so wrong about that? If Debo visited some ashram and had a resolution that he will help them no matter what, do you think it is a drama?"

Yes it is. Dont you think so? Can he not help older people by not letting the whole world know that he is doing so.I think it wasnt very subtle of him to do that. I am not going to vote for him just because of that. It felt like a neta coming and hugging old and poor people for getting votes.

I am not blaming only Debo,same goes for Vinit, and whoever did it. How does you not knowing to dance get you votes??? No it does not(talking about Nihira). and She did not get any votes and she is out.

When Vinit said that he wants his same mom every life he was being true...that was the only time he was not acting but "reacting".

SO if its a Mahayudh anything is Fair, then there is no need to argue about anything...One thing is for sure that I dont want to watch such a mahayudh, I will go watch Ekta kapoor's serials instead. Atleast there we know it is farce.

So why even get singers for this competition, why is there a singing competition, Dont sing, We will vote for the guy who is the most F***ed up in life. No parents, no money, no house, struggling,....give him a makeover say the sob stories and get votes.

But sadly it is not going to happen. So the point is try to see over, all the crap, all the emotions, all the politics and vote for someone who earns it not someone who needs it.

I do not wish to attack anyone, just frustrated with the system. Ther are people who think they can fool Indian people and try various stunts and I am shocked to see Indian people getting fooled. Think about it the TRP rating for this show have doubled....Think....Think.....

Do not fall into teh politics of the system...vote for the guy who is good in your view, whether it is Debu, Vineet or Hemu.

Be a smart Indian....
ComeOn123 thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: lajawab

chukkna said--
"What is so wrong about that? If Debo visited some ashram and had a resolution that he will help them no matter what, do you think it is a drama?"

Yes it is. Dont you think so? Can he not help older people by not letting the whole world know that he is doing so.I think it wasnt very subtle of him to do that. I am not going to vote for him just because of that. It felt like a neta coming and hugging old and poor people for getting votes.

I am not blaming only Debo,same goes for Vinit, and whoever did it. How does you not knowing to dance get you votes??? No it does not(talking about Nihira). and She did not get any votes and she is out.

When Vinit said that he wants his same mom every life he was being true...that was the only time he was not acting but "reacting".

SO if its a Mahayudh anything is Fair, then there is no need to argue about anything...One thing is for sure that I dont want to watch such a mahayudh, I will go watch Ekta kapoor's serials instead. Atleast there we know it is farce.

So why even get singers for this competition, why is there a singing competition, Dont sing, We will vote for the guy who is the most F***ed up in life. No parents, no money, no house, struggling,....give him a makeover say the sob stories and get votes.

But sadly it is not going to happen. So the point is try to see over, all the crap, all the emotions, all the politics and vote for someone who earns it not someone who needs it.

I do not wish to attack anyone, just frustrated with the system. Ther are people who think they can fool Indian people and try various stunts and I am shocked to see Indian people getting fooled. Think about it the TRP rating for this show have doubled....Think....Think.....

Do not fall into teh politics of the system...vote for the guy who is good in your view, whether it is Debu, Vineet or Hemu.

Be a smart Indian....

WOW...Excellent reply....Hats off👏

taikoo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#8

Originally posted by: sangeetluv

....Actually I get sick as soon as HR gets up from his chair!

😆 😆😆..sangeeta, I press fastforward button immediately after the camera zooms in on HR....or if in case I can't, I mute the volume....

Edited by taikoo - 19 years ago
ts9787 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: sangeetluv

Chukkna's point :
Didnt Hema mentioned in one episode that he dedicated the song for his parents as it was thier annivesary. What is so wrong about that?

-----------------------------------

WoooWooww. Wait a min. Do you see any sympathy flowing towards Hema just because he called his parents on the stage for their anniversary. To me it looked like celebration! And moreover he did not announce his grandparents anniversary on the stage for the next episode and his sister's , mom's or dad's b'day for the episode after that. That was one time celebration! Thats it. Unlike HR talking about Vinit's love in each and every episode. Actually I get sick as soon as HR gets up from his chair! And ID and Debojit talking about his Mom's dream. As someone earlier said, you cant form opinion's on a person by seeing a "shoot" of th person in old age home! You kidding me. He is 29yrs old and much older to other contestants. Hence he is wise enough to play his cards well. For Vinit, HR helps in playing cards :)
Sorry, mdroy I think you missed Himani in the list of people who have not used any publicity whatsoever.

I like AS in that respect. Even for Rajeev, he always said Dil se gaatha hain. But never said, yeh cook hain ya gareeb hain ya kisika sapna hai ya kisi se pyar hain.

very well said! you are right...AS never used family background to try to gain votes. he would always praise his students by saying that they have an original voice, or that they sing immensly well...never did either rajeev, himani, or hemachandra use the family card...which is the biggest difference in all of the gharanas

affluent thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: ts9787

very well said! you are right...AS never used family background to try to gain votes. he would always praise his students by saying that they have an original voice, or that they sing immensly well...never did either rajeev, himani, or hemachandra use the family card...which is the biggest difference in all of the gharanas

AS played all dirty games which are more horrible than hyping his students😡

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".