Hey guys!
Some viewers have disliked Shaan's attitude in the last episode, in which his team was against Mohit's. Shahid and Genelia were guests. This poll is to measure the level of backlash against Shaan after that episode.
For those of you who are new to this debate, I'm posting a piece by nehlove without their prior permission (she/he is not online atm). It's the most well rounded account of the whole question I think.
Alright, here I go with mytwo centsregarding this topic but I must warn you that this post might get quiet lengthy..
Shreya has questioned the judges decision in the past regarding Aabhas asking why Anwesha was chosen singer of the day (I would totally call that "putting down" another team member.
Mohit's team member Amey created a ruckus and all this drama but I saw NO efforts on Mohit's part to stop him from saying anything. As a captain, Mohit should have snatched the mike away from Amey and questioned judges himself if he wanted to. Amey was "putting down" a beautiful performance by Sharib.
Shankar's team Rahul and Sharib have over and over criticized the judges even though they have gotten good points all the while and Shankar has pleaded with audiences a number of times to ask for votes.
HR and Mika.... Do I even need to get into all the drama they create??? Meena, I urge you to watch the last two episodes on youtube since they are not aired in the states yet so you'll know what REAL dramebaazi is.
I DO agree with you that Shaan should not have brought out Debo's daughter out in the audience "especially" before the voting. Debo is a good singer and they don't need to rely on cheap tactics to garner votes.
As far as the point regarding Shahid peforming is concerned let me assure you that I am such a crazy Shahid fangirl that if I had a chance I would do that mehndi task to go meet him on Lift Kara De (ok maybe I am exagerrating.. but you get the point). So despite being a hardcore shahid fan, this is a musical show and yes I would have had no problems if Shahid would have just performed but he had no business singing. And yes you could clearly hear Shahid's voice during the dhan te nan part (or maybe it was just me since I concentrate on every aspect of Shahid sooo much).
Genelia blew kisses and a couple of songs later, Shahid did too. Also, again I have no probs with him dancing along in support of Mohit. Priyanka danced with Mika's team too... but the problem that concerned me was him SINGING with them not performing.
Shaan was not "putting down" Amey... HR actually retorted the anchor and said Amey's points were out of liniency and Shaan just wanted to know how the judges were giving points so that he could strategize his play accordingly cuz just like the rest of you I too believe Amey and Hemachandra are just as strong as Debojit and Anweshaa so it was a tough competition IMO.
All in all... I do agree that Shaan probably resorted to a bit of drama to get points but hello... who doesn't like to win? Atleast it wasn't as bad as HR or Amey (from Mohit's team) or Rahul-Sharib (from Shankar's team) or Shreya (putting down Anwesha for Aabhas) or Mika and his constant swearing... They have all tried to put down other teams and Shaan has not criticized the other team members but as a captain is only encouraging his own team through "some" drama... that certainly does NOT make him "FULL" of drama...
Edited by xobile - 15 years ago
Debate Mansion
