15th elimination- didnt seem that fair

np2007 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Guys,
Till last week i was also in support of eliminating Ameeth.... But for Do or Die performance,,, he really did much much better.............actually it was his best till today.... He did show that he can do something out of his range....While Kishore did what he has been doing till now...nothing new and he does that like that only every time.............There was nothing new or that impressive except HIS Looks (No offence to his Fans) but this is Dance show Not the Model show...

Created

Last reply

Replies

19

Views

2.3k

Users

10

Likes

12

Frequent Posters

bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Agreed today Ameeth was good and better performance wise than Kishore.
Ameeth should have gone out last week itself. IMO, GM didn't announce it bcos of Ameeth's sad story. It looked to me like GM didn't wanted to put out one more "Speed Breaker" in his life announcing his exit.
Hence it was done today regardless of todays performance.
The way I take it - Ameeth had to go and he did.
Edited by bee5 - 16 years ago
sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: bee5

Agreed today Ameeth was good and better performance wise than Kishore.

Ameeth should have gone out last week itself. IMO, GM didn't announce it bcos of Ameeth's sad story. It looked to me like GM didn't wanted to put out one more "Speed Breaker" in his life announcing his exit.
Hence it was done today regardless of todays performance.
The way I take it - Ameeth had to go and he did.



I totally agree!! Ameeth rocked today, but he deserved to go last saturday. Actually, even Kishore has a sad story attached to his life. I just think that the DID team should stop getting people's personal lives into open. Last season it was overdramatization of Mangesh's life. This season they have started with Ameeth and Kishore. Basically, viewers just start sympathizing with their lives and then focus slowly shifts on everything else but dance😕
np2007 thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Ya i agree...he should have been out last week itself.. I already mentioned till watching his today's performance i also felt he should go.....But GM said he is going to make decision based on today's Do or Die performance so he should be rated exactly like what he mentioned and based on that He should not go today

But if you are saying GM didnt let him GO listening his story last week then i believe it went other way today listening to Kishore and his Dad's story....So basically you are saying if we listen some emotional story , then we play this game so this dance reality turns to emotional drama...Then its better to watch All Ekta's daily soap and Not such reality..

They should keep this more reality show


sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: np2007

Ya i agree...he should have been out last week itself.. I already mentioned till watching his today's performance i also felt he should go.....But GM said he is going to make decision based on today's Do or Die performance so he should be rated exactly like what he mentioned and based on that He should not go today

But if you are saying GM didnt let him GO listening his story last week then i believe it went other way today listening to Kishore and his Dad's story....So basically you are saying if we listen some emotional story , then we play this game so this dance reality turns to emotional drama...Then its better to watch All Ekta's daily soap and Not such reality..

They should keep this more reality show




True..I agree to the bolded part😊 Also, IMO the channel plays an important role in deciding the eliminations as well. I dont think they want Geeta to lose her contestants like that (Shruti and Kishore) in one day itself. What we say does not really matter, we can merely speculate and cant say whats going on in GM's mind. I just gave an opinion on the 'emotional atyachaar'. I agree that they should keep this as a reality show and not a daily soap.
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sunandshine



I totally agree!! Ameeth rocked today, but he deserved to go last saturday. Actually, even Kishore has a sad story attached to his life. I just think that the DID team should stop getting people's personal lives into open. Last season it was overdramatization of Mangesh's life. This season they have started with Ameeth and Kishore. Basically, viewers just start sympathizing with their lives and then focus slowly shifts on everything else but dance😕

yes, fully agree. They should stop going into contestants personal lives.
bee5 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Networker 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: np2007

Ya i agree...he should have been out last week itself.. I already mentioned till watching his today's performance i also felt he should go.....But GM said he is going to make decision based on today's Do or Die performance so he should be rated exactly like what he mentioned and based on that He should not go today

But if you are saying GM didnt let him GO listening his story last week then i believe it went other way today listening to Kishore and his Dad's story....So basically you are saying if we listen some emotional story , then we play this game so this dance reality turns to emotional drama...Then its better to watch All Ekta's daily soap and Not such reality..

They should keep this more reality show


Oh! That was just a scripted statement (a dialogue). Sometimes it is necessary, we do not take word-for-word meaning. I fully knew he had to say that. It was a hollow statement. GM had made his mind based on performance last week itself, but he felt bad after listening to Ameeth's sad story.
Being the GM of the show, he shouldn't have swayed with personal story, thats not what he is for.
Everyone have their tragedies in life and as you have mentioned too - Its not a daily soap but a dance reality show.
My comments - Ameeth had to go was not based on either of their personal stories.
Thats not what I am looking for in this show.
jeffmish thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
Agree! Ameeth shudnt have been tortured today after giving a better performance than Kishor. If GM had already decided, then he shud hav eliminated Ameeth last week, if he asked them this, then he shud choose between the best dance today, not overall!
Anyways, please can anyone tell me if the cousin Kishor was pointing to, sitting beside his mom(the one in green shirt, with a ponytail) was Paulson. he looked a lot like him.
:)
sunandshine thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9

Originally posted by: jeffmish

Agree! Ameeth shudnt have been tortured today after giving a better performance than Kishor. If GM had already decided, then he shud hav eliminated Ameeth last week, if he asked them this, then he shud choose between the best dance today, not overall!

Anyways, please can anyone tell me if the cousin Kishor was pointing to, sitting beside his mom(the one in green shirt, with a ponytail) was Paulson. he looked a lot like him.
:)



LOL..I thought he did look like Paulson as well..But they would have said do if he indeed was Paulson😊

Also Kishore is a Kannadiga while Paulson is Malyali..😳
gossipgurls thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
I agree yaar... Ameeth deserved to be on the show, his perfomance was much better.
I really hope that these sob stories dnt over shadow perfomances...... its called life and everyone has one story to tell.. but this is a dance show and not saas bahu serial.
I'm so dissapointed .... it was unfair

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".