Doodh ka dhoodh, paani ka paani

I think this gala has proved who's a real singer and who's a mediocre. Amey, Karunya, Meenal , Antara and Monali were given tough songs. Out of these Amey's and Karu's songs were toughest. To sing Manna De's song is no joke and both the guys have sung them splendidly. Among girls I think Antara outshone everyone. Ravi, Sandeep, Panna and Anuj were very average.

Does this gala ring a bell anywhere in the minds of the ppl? I think it should b'coz I guess Amey and Karunya among boys have proved that they can sing any kind of song and they have unique and original voices. They deserve to win the title more than anyone else. The difference is crystal clear. Doodh ka doodh, paani ka paani.

I disagree about Antara. I think both Meenal & Monali were as good if not better than Antara.

u r right lovlina----in this round it's been proven who's a true singer n who's a bathrrom singer.....any1 can sing the current songs---only when u sing a manna de or rafi song, do u realise who has the real calibre....n amey 👏 n karu 😊 👏 proved themselves today---they showed y they were the msot deserving....

PANNA woz rockin alng wid Amey n Karunya 😳

Meenal was also rocking guys
It was a difficult song haina?

well said thsi time all concentrated to singing more....

Only AMEY KARUNAY & ANTARA did good job singing wise....

Originally posted by: ifra

Meenal was also rocking guys
It was a difficult song haina?

She was definitely good!!

Pata nahin sonu kyo aisa bola. But Sonu is a better judge of music than me.

Here we should not mistake the dancing to singing.. Panna can perform very well, this we all know, but actually singing wise, when compared to KArunya & AMey, he is not upto the mark.

Where as lot of us know that Antara CAN sing well, where as monali has not shown any improvement in comparision to her piano & theatre rounds. We all unanimously agree that MEENAL is terrific singer, she has been performing well in all the previous rounds..Its her badluck that she is landing up in bottom 3 in the previous round..

But we can't say much about anuj, becos, this is his first gala, we must give him one more chance before we criticise his singing, where as RAVI & SANDEEP got no excuse.. if they are bad, then they are BAD, no two ways about it...But i heard that RAVI gave good performance? so he is 200% safe then?

I think you are right indianman, Ravi definitely gave a good perf this round and should be through.
Anuj, obviously was very nervous and the fell wasn't there in the song as he wasn't groomed as much as the others.

Meenal did sing a tough one but I somehow found she was low in her confidence. I cud make out in her shaky voice.