Janta will never pick girl to win - Page 2

Originally posted by: ifra

I think thats because most boys don't have intresst in voting or in this kind of show snd girl vote defenatly for boys

i agree! thatz exactly i wat i think...but y dont the girls vote 4 girls...my favoritez have alwayz been girls...ladki hi ladki ki dushman hoti hai...n i think guyz should really get more involved...

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

you guys ever think about this? in SRGMP when girls used to win was only when public voting wasnt even in the show and only judges picked the winners. in fame gurukul only reason ruprekha won was because of qazi otherwise there's no way janta wouldve let her win either. then indian idol was abhijeet sawant and top 3 were guys not a girl in sight. indian idol II it seems like all girls will be out before the guys. esp in SRGMP nihira joshi deserved to win but didnt because she didnt get enough votes. INDIA WILL ALWAYS BE SCARED OF A WOMAN'S SUCCESS.

I think you may be right but are shows like FG, II2, SRGMP representative of India as a whole? How many people in India actually watch these shows and vote? We shouldn't use reality TV to judge this.

I agree that in these reality shows, TALENTED and DESERVING female singers don't get their dues with respect to voting. In II2, the top three contestants were all male. Same in SRGMP Challenge 2005 though Nihara and Himani were equally as good and even better than some of the male singers. But in II2, I think the trend is audiences are scared of DESERVING and TALENTED singers. The same may be true of SRGMP. Why else would the most talented contestants receive the least amount of votes? Its not just gender, but a lot of factors that go into play with such shows like who is voting, why they are voting for their favorite etc.

I think we should see each contestant as a singer first. If we do, the most deserving, talented singer will win.

last year was unfair as there were 8 guyz nonly 2 galz bt this yr its more fairer(i mean it was..nw that jolly is gone n that stupid anuj has come)so i think galz hv gt a chance...well me 4 one wld def. lyk a gal 2 b the nxt indian idol... 😉

i think tht they should hve brought dilpreet back to the show tht would hve been fair replacing a girl with a girl

Dilpreet was awesome in the piano round. Wish she had come back. I wonder which other contestants auditioned again besides Anuj.

Originally posted by: Kadwiphool

you guys ever think about this? in SRGMP when girls used to win was only when public voting wasnt even in the show and only judges picked the winners. in fame gurukul only reason ruprekha won was because of qazi otherwise there's no way janta wouldve let her win either. then indian idol was abhijeet sawant and top 3 were guys not a girl in sight. indian idol II it seems like all girls will be out before the guys. esp in SRGMP nihira joshi deserved to win but didnt because she didnt get enough votes. INDIA WILL ALWAYS BE SCARED OF A WOMAN'S SUCCESS.

you know....i 1000000000% agree with you....let me give the reason as well...

we know that the majority of viewers of these shows r females...lets say

60% female and 40% male

Now...out of this 40% male, tell me how many will vote...very very few....

And out of 60% girls....many will vote...and obviously girls will vote for boys....

Moreover, girls are most passionate about these shows and their contestant...have u seen any guy saying 'I love Meenal' or 'I love Monali'....ya boys do like girls but they are not as passionate as girls...on the other hand, we have seen so many girls saying 'I love Panna or I love Amey'....

Just tell me if there had been a girl in place of Qazi, would she have got as many votes as Qazi got?...NO

and thats Y I can gurantee u that no girl can win II....thats for sure...but having said that I never mean that girls are less deserving, they are sometimes more deserving than boys...like Prajakta

yeh das tru dey wont.. well i wud prefer a boy winnin dis year too coz da girls aint all dat! only Monali iz gd.. but boys mostly all r gd.. Panna, Amey, Karunya 😃

Rooprekha winning is proof enough that woman CAN win.

But i dont think they shud judge THE WHOLE THING on audience's votes!

The viewers votes shud be a guideline not the exact option