Are we overreacting? - Page 3

Created

Last reply

Replies

27

Views

1.9k

Users

11

Likes

17

Frequent Posters

-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#21

Originally posted by: souro


Saying what happened in the past is inevitable. It may grow less with time but it will remain there.
What one must not do is rest on past laurels. Indians of the past generation used to do that a lot. We invented zero and all that. They just don't seem to accept that the West has after that discovered several such zeroes.
Coming to the current situation, sometimes accentuating a problem actually stresses the need of an urgent solution. There is nothing wrong in that. It helps one to become more alert, active and ultimately superior.
I don't know if you're familiar with the Indian media of yesteryear's. Earlier media always used to downplay Ind-Pak animosity and even used to ignore PDA for an unofficially enemy state, just to keep up that charade of peace and brotherly love. That lax attitude didn't give any positive results and ultimately got us nowhere.
People or country always need a driving force to motivate them to become superior. Sometimes that motivation comes from strong hatred and contempt, nothing wrong with it. Forgetting the past and acting as if everything is fine and dandy and going back to sleep is the actual problem.


Yeah I agree with the first part. But I am still not ok with the fact that people go on and on about it for years. I am totally for learning from the past happenings and evolving from there, but why stress so much on things which we couldn't possibly change decades later? What I only meant is, media tries to stress far too much on the problem, when they should actually lend a helping hand in the solution.

Somewhere though, it is totally true that the media shows what the public wants to see. Why is a certain show on something successful? Because the audience likes watching it and the media would definitely take advantage, that being their job at the end!

However again, I don't really feel a country should become superior to another, or that feeling hatred or animosity against the people of any other country is a good thing either. Nothing wrong if motivation comes from hatred or contempt, but surely, everything is totally wrong if the same motivation comes for hatred or contempt, especially on being instigated by the government or its adjoined medium.

Also, I agree, but no one is saying to feign ignorance on anything that happened previously. There again, I say it once more, I am totally in for discussing past events in order to learn from them, learn being the key word, it is dramatizing any happening to bring on useless emotions is what bothers me.


Agreed on the extra sound effects part. But as for repeat telecast in general. If you don't like it, don't see it. It's as simple as that.

Yup, that's somehow what I do now. I really appreciate everything the media does for its country, for any country. We can't overrule the fact that a proper media can take a country to unimaginably great heights. It is the part where a media takes down a population or a country that gets to me. But then, it's always been so: If you want the good part, learn to take it along with the bad, or just forget about it... 😆


As far as I remember no one protested about Riteish Deshmukh visiting along with his father. What everyone protested was Riteish bringing Ram Gopal Verma along with him. Maybe, they felt that RGV was there on a first person recce so that he can show it later in one of his films.

But was it confirmed he would show it in one of his movies? Didn't the media invent all that hype unnecessarily? Again, I am not against the fact that they voice out their opinion and say what was wrong simply was. What I far from liked what that they actually stressed on for days on the matter. Again, dramatizing what they should simply have stated. And I was in India those days. If I am not mistaken, one of the news channels was even playing some Bollywood songs from war front or something along with the pictures of the two walking in Taj. If that kind of dramatizing is good, tell me what's bad then?


Why all that botheration with a wink and why all these worrying thoughts??


I think winks ease out a situation, take out the worry factor from it, make you feel better about yourself and others, that's why the wink! 😉 😆 And as for the worrying thoughts, I am always worried about the world, it's the random people in it that I don't really care for.
😆 - Kidding!

gumsum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#22
I think when it comes to 11/26, media is doing a better job than the Govt itself. I like when media builds up the pressure as it forces govt to take an action. It is not media's job to find a solution, their job is to raise an awareness which in turn forces people like us to think. India is a democracy and the goverment gets elected on the basis of awareness around various issues. Also one must remember it is easy to forgive than forget. These wounds are engraved in history and can never be forgotten.
And as far as the Ritesh Deshmukh visit is concerned, I care the least.
return_to_hades thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 6
Posted: 16 years ago
#23


It is easy enough to not watch the repeat telecast. However, in my opinion I feel that the Indian media tends to have degraded to sensationalizing instead of reporting. I can understand repeat telecast to restransmit information or until new information is available. I did not watch the local American coverage because I found it too politically correct for my tastes. However, while watching the Indian media coverage I felt it lacked some professional journalism ethics. The same edited video footage, same shots and same sound effects were repeatedly shown for dramatic effects. What irks me more about the media is that it is not genuinely empathetic to the state of the victims and their families nor does it compel anyone to be so.

I do not feel the Indian citizen or Mumbaiite overreacted in any manner to the event. I'm more of a pacifist and disagree with aggression, but I feel that in this case aggression was justified. However, I do believe the media overreacted or rather misreacted by invoking fear/anger/terror and a range of emotions but never really channeling it to anything constructive. I thought citizen journalists actually did a better job.

The media is extremely powerful in its ability to influence people. Instead of the same repeated coverage I would like to see them bite the a$$ of our complacent politicians more often. Grill them in public, a carefully planned journalist's interview can really strip a politician bare in front of the people. I'd like them to interview Pakistani officials and Pakistani people and bare the diversity of attitudes from all sides of the spectrum for the world to review, digest and draw conclusions. These people claiming that Indians are overreacting, get to them, grill them, put them on the spot - ask them to justify their lofty claims and notions - lets see how they fare. Sometimes something simplistic is more faithful to the truth of the matter that histrionics.
gumsum thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#24
I follow NDTV and Times now online. NDTV because I like their reporting style, Times now because they are usually the first one to get the news. So far I have witnessed responsible jouranlism from them. I can't comment on reports aired on other frequencies.
n RTH, I have noticed that NDTV invites people across the world to comment on the issues but that is mostly on will. You can not force someone to limelight if all they want to do is bad-mouth behind your back and no show upon challenging their views.
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#25
I really appreciate watching NDTV. I think NDTV has got some of the best reporters India has in the present time! And undoubtedly a good CEO too by the looks of it!
Eventide thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#26

Perhaps the numerous terror attacks have de-sensitized people. Replaying the images of the attacks, asking the victims how they feel one year on, are not required. Why not put the people responsible in the dock. Times Now and NDTV made an effort, atleast.

I disagree about NDTV reporters being the best. The Kargil war may have made Barkha Dutt what she is today. Or has contributed to it. But at what cost??
Edited by Eventide - 16 years ago
-Sneha thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#27
Eventide: The problem is, NDTV reporters seem to be the best ones out of what I watch over here, and obviously out of the Indian channels, because everything else is pretty crap except NDTV as news channel! That's what I meant. Apologies for that. I meant it only in my case out here in Mauritius.

About Barkha Dutt and the Kargil war, well looks like I'll have to go and do some research! 😆
Eventide thumbnail
15th Anniversary Thumbnail Navigator Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#28

Hey Sneha, Nothing personal here. 😊 Before the Kargil war, I too had high regard for the channel and its reporters.


NDTV started off well. But the TRP war got the better of them too. I honestly don't find any difference between NDTV India (it's hindi channel) and rest of the Hindi channels.


@Barkha Dutt: Let me save you all the research. In spite of repeated requests and eventually warnings, she did not stop sending out the news feeds. These were intercepted by the enemy to find out exact location of troops. To top it all, her 'one for the camera' shot (firing the Bofors gun) resulted in soldiers being killed. The army has wisened up now. No media on the front line. Period.
Edited by Eventide - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".