why Amay and Minal were in Bottom 3?

Why is everyone shocked to see Amay & Minal in bottom 3?? 😕

My observation:

Amay, Minal & Panna all 3 from Mumbai


So votes were bound to be divided and they did, on the other hand rest of the contestants are still enjoying their home grounds. As simple as that, you don't need a rocket science for that 😕

Amey...he shouldn't have been in bottom three....BUT HE DIDN'T SING tht well AS HE HAD BEEN SINGING


But Meenal didn't seing that well....tht's wht i think.....Meenal is getting wrost n wrost every week....

well i think that meenal and amey were one of the best
i really think that indian idol is not about singin anymore it is about sympathy because why do u think antara is always in the the top numbers and the way ravi sang yesterday and antara i think instead of
meenal and amey they should have been there. antara keeps sayin i am from a small village and blah blah blah what else god knows and ravi keeps mentioning about how his dad didn't agree etc etc etc

sorry people no offense just my opinion

Originally posted by: dididada_111

well i think that meenal and amey were one of the best
i really think that indian idol is not about singin anymore it is about sympathy because why do u think antara is always in the the top numbers and the way ravi sang yesterday and antara i think instead of
meenal and amey they should have been there. antara keeps sayin i am from a small village and blah blah blah what else god knows and ravi keeps mentioning about how his dad didn't agree etc etc etc

sorry people no offense just my opinion

Just to let u know..in yesterday's episode, not once did Antara mention about her village background. Neither did she cry. She won solely becuz of her performance. Download the clip and watch it again..u'll see what I mean. Antara is a improving performer. She performs, watches the reactions, keeps in mind the negative points and tries to eliminate them in her next performance. All her performance show this pattern. Antara got through becuz she knows her stuff. She's in control of herself.

Meenal was in the bottom three becuz there is no connection with the audience in her case. She does not have the "zing" thing in her performance. To be honest, I dont see her going far. She's good no doubt, but nothing "sensational". Sorry.

In my opinion, It is luck nothing else.

I give u an example, see, if meenal's fans are 10 and panna's fans are 4 but meenal's fan are voting for once only and panna's fans are voting for thrice then definately Meenal will get 10 votes and Pana will get 12 so here is the luck i was telling about.

if people will vote for only once then results will be accurate.

Originally posted by: vikksterr

Just to let u know..in yesterday's episode, not once did Antara mention about her village background. Neither did she cry. She won solely becuz of her performance. Download the clip and watch it again..u'll see what I mean. Antara is a improving performer. She performs, watches the reactions, keeps in mind the negative points and tries to eliminate them in her next performance. All her performance show this pattern. Antara got through becuz she knows her stuff. She's in control of herself.Meenal was in the bottom three becuz there is no connection with the audience in her case. She does not have the "zing" thing in her performance. To be honest, I dont see her going far. She's good no doubt, but nothing "sensational". Sorry.

I agree....Why is "dididada_111" blaming Antara??...I mean antara did not metion her anything abt her village......N her performnace was good...ya i know the song wasn't tht great.......But her performance was excellent..Go antara....we luv u....N WE Luv AMEY toooo

Originally posted by: karish89

I agree....Why is "dididada_111" blaming Antara??...I mean antara did not metion her anything abt her village......N her performnace was good...ya i know the song wasn't tht great.......But her performance was excellent..Go antara....we luv u....N WE Luv AMEY toooo

"dididada_111" is blaming Aantra b'coz except yesterday she used to say like "Please vote for me b'coz I am from a small village and used to cry " Ofcourse yesterday she didn't say anything bad. Yesterday I liked her.

Originally posted by: dididada_111

well i think that meenal and amey were one of the best
i really think that indian idol is not about singin anymore it is about sympathy because why do u think antara is always in the the top numbers and the way ravi sang yesterday and antara i think instead of
meenal and amey they should have been there. antara keeps sayin i am from a small village and blah blah blah what else god knows and ravi keeps mentioning about how his dad didn't agree etc etc etc

sorry people no offense just my opinion

U better should be sorry....May eb u r frustrated with ANTARA sicne she didnt say any village stories thsi time...also didnt overperform too....

Keep trying to find out any faults more....But before writing just watch teh show clearly OK? no offence...

If i ahve to say Meenal though sang well she didnt have teh right feeling to touch that song ...she is still nervous & becoz of that song no one noticed that much....Also aditi sang well...

Abt Amey its his fate becoz hsi vote divided to ravi sandeep & panna....

well its ridiculous that people so bad as ravi and monali are safe and people who do well like amey and meenal should be in the bottom at this stage