Bring back Dilpreet & Jyotsna??? - Page 2

dilpreet def deserved to be in galas!!!!
if they bring back ppl i want it to be
dilpreet and abha!!!
they were awsome!!

If Sony decides to replace Jolly, then they will have to bring Jyotsna back(As she was the one who was fourth in her group)

I highly doubt she will be replaced...Coz I surely would have been pretty angry if Aditi had been replaced.

Hi gang here is my take on the latest chickenpox thing.
Remember only one will be the agla indian idol.
So all but one will get eleminated. who at what point gets eliminated is of no significance in this whole game. So doesn't matter if sagar gets eliminated before neha or jolly. THINK ABOUT IT and give your creative minds some rest and enjoy the journey

I want Dilpreet in and Meenal should be out

I am not saying abt piano rounds..till piano round it was ok to have seperate rounds for boys and girls to bring equal number to the finals.

I am talking abt first and the second gala round in which there are seperate rounds for boys and girls....and these are the finals...mind u!!

Boys and girls shud be performing together right from the first gala and till the end and the one who survives shud be the indian idol....why all of a sudden when neha falls ill, there are seperate rounds.. Also during piano rounds Mini and Aman said that from galas all the participants would be performing together till the end. Till Neha was fit there was no such seperate round announced then why suddenly this change in format????

U know ppl think that these are seperate rounds of first gala...but actually speaking Neha already got a bye in the first round and poor Sagar faced the axe....was it mistake of Sagar that Neha was ill???

I understand your point of view on Jolly Dus getting a bye to gala three. My opinion on the matter is that it works against her. This a TV show and if you are absent for so many shows the audience forms their favorites with out you. Also, the other singers now have more expierence on that gala round platform as opposed to Jolly when she enters. The rest of the group will have more practice, Jolly will have a hard time with her voice while she is recovering. Unless she is a premium quality singer, I doubt she will make it as far. In regards to other singers staying in longer or being elminated earlier than necessary, I think is just a matter of semantics, somebody has to go. As far as singing they are all on a close level with one another and it is preformance to preformance show.

As far as seperating the girls from the guys, I think it was more of a demographic issue. Most people who vote are young women and teenager --- who naturally vote for the boys. Seperating them out you are looking at a good male singer vs a good female singer. It makes a better show.

Originally posted by: simpleguy

I want Dilpreet in and Meenal should be out

hey, i wunt dilpreet in too, but meenal is a good singer. jolly or antara should be out, according 2 me!