Sa Re Ga Ma Pa Challenge 2005Latest News

Any body out there try to say anything about 19 Dec show. Should use some brain to analyse what happened.

I am not concerned about what some has said to the other this is behavior matter, individauls own reflection. If someone really shitty sitting out there what to do.

Lets take the episode where it started the Kawali show with N.S. Sidhu.

The song/kawali Debujit has sung is the one of the most difficult kawalis

ever attempted and sung in the history of India cinema and Music.

The wordings with extremly complex lines change of scale lots of complexities for a singer.

{I just wanted to comment on this: When I was in class 6th no normal boy can understand the Kawalis etc. and thereforenever likes kawalis but it was election time may be 1984 and movies are relayed whole day and the movie was one off them and this was the first time I ever understood a kawali and liked it}

When Debu attempted this kawali me( 33yrs) and my father had a word that if he can sing the whole kawali with 'Isshq, Ishq ...... properly he is done, he is the best.

I noticed the error in the wording he made ( Hamsafar ki talash hai) but that was not the point we were not accessing his memory to repeat the original piece. What we were accessing is his singing capabilities, who cares he repeated the same wording or not what we care is what he sung was good or not.

He has has to get the highest votes because what he attempted was so difficult kwali that any popular singer of taday will not dare to attempt, he has WON the completion with his successful completion of that kawali.

And I fully agree with Ismail Darbar that the "GAME IS OVER"

What he did afterwards is his behavior.

But what I know is he was pissed off with the behavior of other two mentors they were partial when they gave 6 and 7 on Debu's performance. Mr Jatin is not a fool to give 9.

Non of these music directors sitting there completly understand the essence of that kawali any of their work show that complexity so why they started it? Why they tried to pull someone back because he is not from their team or state? Adesh and HR started this polarization tactics

Now when it hit their candidate now they were crying.

Regarding other three threating to walk-out who cares if they do so Debu will win anyways.

They knew the rule since start of this round. They should have raised the voice at that time. Till the other participants were being eliminated by same process and they were winning the rule was good and now when it hit under their belly they are crying that is not the sprit of competition.

Any participant who starts competiting in a competition shold know the complete rules and play till he /she wins or loose.

Change in rules cost India the 2003 world cup in cricket. Change in field hockey rules (introduction of truf, penalty corner etc) cost India to loose its dominance in the game.

But once you start a competition and get to a closing stage if you loose you can not complaint about the rules.

Debo is the best after he sang that kawali and that is it. And if is performance related he has to get maximum votes.

He can under perform in comming parts and can loose but other needs to complete. This darama will yeild him more simpathy votes.

That day not the Ismail Darbars behavior but Adesh comments after might as well yeild him couple of thousand votes.

Acting smart not always yield favourable results like Adesh and Himani.

And am not making this statement because he my fan or anything I never voted and nor has any plan to do so, because I do not belive in public vote either it is an political election or else. People not capable of understanding the actual facts can vote a stupid person to power run a nation.

And what will I gain who so ever wins but I can comment on performance.

Again all thsi is ZEE TV publicity stunt, not always what ever happens on the stages of these programs is always shown. We know this is not a live show. They show such things to gain hipe and pulicity their goal is getting fulfilled and publis is fooled.

So lets think before taking this agenda outside of TV show and start fighting, making political or regional battles. I will not be surprised if this issue is taken to Parliament question hour or a public litication filled in Suprem Court to stop the Sa Re GA MA PA, which will agian give hipe to ZEE TV show and more people will be willing to watch the drama so much is discussion.

simple logic.
Some people love Mohd. Rafi Ji, and some love Kishore Kumar Ji.

Both were legends. Does it mean one was better than the other?
KK Fans will say KK was better, MR fans will say MR was better.
Still someone else may come and say Mukesh was better.

So, why are you trying to make a point that DEBO is better!!!!!!

Let all the people decide, I am sure you must not have got so upset even when you came to know about the match-fixing fiasco in cricket.

Everyone just relax and do not vote. You are playing into the hands of these reality show mongers.

Either vote and accept results or do not waste your money.

If the intention of these shows was to not make money on your SMSes or phone calls, they would have given you toll-free numbers as they do here in US.

I for once am laughing on you all Indians who are being swayed into this trap. And I am no racist or biased person.

Wake up buddies. Wake up!

Dear Mr. Mehta,

I did not say Debo is better.
In this particular competition on that day he sung better than the rest that to as per my opinion. Other can have different opinion. I only commented on the candidates (Debu's) performace that day and the probable reason of highest votes.

Just like u voiced ur opinion , I feel something like this.
The whole drama of walking out was started by Ismail Darbar , whom many people think here to be an awesome guy. I personally dont agree becoz I dont see anything coming from his heart. He very well knows why Nihira lost , even then he created a scene . Going by what U say that Debojit sang a very tough song ... he dint create an impact with that song as it should have been when u sing a qawali . Which I feel was good when it came to hema and vinit. I also dont vote for anyone nor am partial towards any contestant. All am looking for is good music.

Its Ismail Darbar who manipulated so easily the people , becoz he knew nihira is gone and with that day's performance debojit would have gone too . Agreed to the fact that Jatin-Lalit is not a fool to give Debojit 9 for his performance , but if u see he gave 10 to others . Debojit is a good singer but not as good as himani or hema.

I would only like to conclude it this way .... the channel is making money and its no point for us to voice our opinion in any fashion . The mentors are getting money for their per episode screen presence. Zee has to be blamed along with Gajendra singh the director for showing how much percent vote is received by the contestants from each state. This is what is leading to so many issues.

Gajendra singh has spoilt the show by making it commercialise to this level , although the concept was good for the contestant to be trained by a music director and then perform , instead of public voting they should have called some good people in the industry to judge without any bias for the top 12. Moreover I felt the top 12 were very good so it would have been the days performance when it comes to judging . Instead the channel and the producer of the show are making money , and showing all edited stuff and unnecesarily creating problem in the name of regionalism.

In the process now we have started disliking some contestants for their behaviour. There was no need to telecast the show with the fight or if shown then show it fully , instead showing all edited version and making people dislike .

indiantandoori,

I am no fan of ID but will U please explain what would you have done if your candidate who attempted one of the toughest Kawaali and sang well (I am sure everybody will agree he sang well). Where you differed is, whether people felt impact of it or not. Hey, if pandit jasraj or some classical singer sings, majority of people can not make head or tail of it. That does not make them any less competant. So, I find this your argument wierd.

Another question, Did other singers had guts to take on difficult songs at this stage of competition? Why to gang up on a contestant?

Last but not least, AS and HR are going out and out promoting their candidates every way possible, for example: what about Vinit's love story hype by HR all the time?

Any way, for the record, I enjoy songs more than competitions.

LaLLa lalla laala, LaLLa lalla laala, LaLLa lalla laala, LaLLa lalla laala,LaLLa lalla laala..................................😆

Originally posted by: BuddyforAll

Any body out there try to say anything about 19 Dec show. Should use some brain to analyse what happened.

I am not concerned about what some has said to the other this is behavior matter, individauls own reflection. If someone really shitty sitting out there what to do.

Lets take the episode where it started the Kawali show with N.S. Sidhu.

The song/kawali Debujit has sung is the one of the most difficult kawalis

ever attempted and sung in the history of India cinema and Music.

The wordings with extremly complex lines change of scale lots of complexities for a singer.

{I just wanted to comment on this: When I was in class 6th no normal boy can understand the Kawalis etc. and thereforenever likes kawalis but it was election time may be 1984 and movies are relayed whole day and the movie was one off them and this was the first time I ever understood a kawali and liked it}

When Debu attempted this kawali me( 33yrs) and my father had a word that if he can sing the whole kawali with 'Isshq, Ishq ...... properly he is done, he is the best.

I noticed the error in the wording he made ( Hamsafar ki talash hai) but that was not the point we were not accessing his memory to repeat the original piece. What we were accessing is his singing capabilities, who cares he repeated the same wording or not what we care is what he sung was good or not.

He has has to get the highest votes because what he attempted was so difficult kwali that any popular singer of taday will not dare to attempt, he has WON the completion with his successful completion of that kawali.

And I fully agree with Ismail Darbar that the "GAME IS OVER"

What he did afterwards is his behavior.

But what I know is he was pissed off with the behavior of other two mentors they were partial when they gave 6 and 7 on Debu's performance. Mr Jatin is not a fool to give 9.

Non of these music directors sitting there completly understand the essence of that kawali any of their work show that complexity so why they started it? Why they tried to pull someone back because he is not from their team or state? Adesh and HR started this polarization tactics

Now when it hit their candidate now they were crying.

Regarding other three threating to walk-out who cares if they do so Debu will win anyways.

They knew the rule since start of this round. They should have raised the voice at that time. Till the other participants were being eliminated by same process and they were winning the rule was good and now when it hit under their belly they are crying that is not the sprit of competition.

Any participant who starts competiting in a competition shold know the complete rules and play till he /she wins or loose.

Change in rules cost India the 2003 world cup in cricket. Change in field hockey rules (introduction of truf, penalty corner etc) cost India to loose its dominance in the game.

But once you start a competition and get to a closing stage if you loose you can not complaint about the rules.

Debo is the best after he sang that kawali and that is it. And if is performance related he has to get maximum votes.

He can under perform in comming parts and can loose but other needs to complete. This darama will yeild him more simpathy votes.

That day not the Ismail Darbars behavior but Adesh comments after might as well yeild him couple of thousand votes.

Acting smart not always yield favourable results like Adesh and Himani.

And am not making this statement because he my fan or anything I never voted and nor has any plan to do so, because I do not belive in public vote either it is an political election or else. People not capable of understanding the actual facts can vote a stupid person to power run a nation.

And what will I gain who so ever wins but I can comment on performance.

Again all thsi is ZEE TV publicity stunt, not always what ever happens on the stages of these programs is always shown. We know this is not a live show. They show such things to gain hipe and pulicity their goal is getting fulfilled and publis is fooled.

So lets think before taking this agenda outside of TV show and start fighting, making political or regional battles. I will not be surprised if this issue is taken to Parliament question hour or a public litication filled in Suprem Court to stop the Sa Re GA MA PA, which will agian give hipe to ZEE TV show and more people will be willing to watch the drama so much is discussion.

I agree with rahul everyone has own choice.And also agree he sang the tough song....but who asked him to take such a risk at such a crucial time ...People will only look at who sang good and bad and only few look at how he sang the tough song so well..........its competition so compete .

Hellllooooo,

Dont forget this is a game show! and Music is just one of the criteria..popularity is what counts, not the depth or quality..

To get to this stage, ofcourse you got to be better in music. But then you are at the mercy of votes!!

have fun, and enjoy whatever is left of music. Waiting for regular SRGMP to start so that we can start enjoying new talent..;-))

hi guyz new in this forum, well am frm Pakistani family living in Bahrain...and we all wanna give our all 6 best vote for Nihira Joshi she sings ver well and we all like her

Hi Guys ,

We get to see the recording of this show on Monday and Tuesday in US. Though I had read your reviews before hand and I knew what happened during that show but still I wanted to satisfy myself completely. So I did see the program telecast on Monday and these are my finding:

We saw the disgust of Sa Re Ga MA today, they should go back to their original format of getting new singers....enough of TRP race.

Planned activity by Aadesh and Himesh,

All these 3 didn't realize till date that voting can make them lose. They're scared to lose.

Facts : Vinit was at number 1 at least 2-3 times and at that time he received 40 to 50% votes from North.

Himani, was number 1 at 2 instances, she received 65% from North one time.

No one ever took count of all this.....when they were winning public votes....no one bothered to ask why so many votes??

Clear Indication of Planned activity:

1) Debojit and other 3 were sitting separately.

2) Aadesh & Himesh were exchanging comments while
those 3 contestants were not able to answer why they
are doing this?.....fake acting as if they didn't know.

3) Poor Mathematic sense of Aadesh, he noted all votes
for debojit ( first time he noted votes )
and he was asking why he got 80% votes from Northeast?
Aadesh should know that they are not 80% of overall votes
( 70 lakh ). Those 80% votes could be 80% of
What he actually got could have been say 15 lakh votes.( for example )

4) Looks like there is something else cooking there
otherwise why collective stand against debojit alone.

5) Perhaps, Ismail was correct to get Nihira back because
they were so sad after her defeat. Then they should get her back because she was in true sence winner of this show.

Himesh was at his utmost worst, he was shouting like one ill mannered ghetto.

I'm sure you all must have found these things in this show quite dramatic and ridiculous.

May the best one win…