Plz put an END to baseless NE VOTING issu

uselogic thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

i have collated al my articles on NE voting thing..Please go thorugh it with open mind and then let me know if it si worth of an issue.


*****>>> As i always say , debojit should win the hearts of other region people with music and always maintained good music transcends all boundaries.IF so many people are accusing hinm for getting votes from NE ( which is not so correct, please read my next comment), there is some element of truth. After all "Aag ke bina dhuan nahi uthta")

*****>>>> Analysis:

-> last week the overall votes were 60 lakhs ( nihira got 14+ % votes and Debojit 16% +, himani 17%, vinit- 30%, hema - 23%).
Debojit = 9.6 lakhs
Nihira = 8.4 lakhs
Vinit = 18 lakhs
himani= 10.2 lakhs
Hema= 13.8 lakhs.

-> This week total votes = 70 lakhs ( debjot = 42%, second highest = 25 %, third highest = 20%, fourth highest = 15%)

second = 17.5 lakhs
third = 14 lakhs
Fourth = 10.5 lakhs
Debojit = 29.4 lakhs ( 80% FROM nE = 23.52) = 5.88 lakhs

1. lets discard 50 % of the votes from NE, so net vote = 5.88 + 11.76 = 17.64
2. lets discard 60 % of the votes from NE, so net vote = 5.88 + 9.4 = 15.28
3. lets discard 70 % of the votes from NE, so net vote = 5.88 + 7.1 = 12.98

now i cannot go beyond that , then that would be very unfair....If they are voting in such high numbers than no body has stopped other regions to vote , so i cannot go below 70%. Now even if we divide the remainig votes equally among the three ( 58/3) = 19.33. which means the lowest would have got around 17 % ( logically, i think it should be even less that that).

fourth highest = 17% of 70 = 11.9..

mind it i have not discarded some % of regional voting from the fourth person.

Conclusion:
----------

1. In all worst case scenario , debojit is still the third.
2. Debojit increased his vote share by ( 11.9- 9.6) =
3. Two of the remaining contestants have actually reduced their votes share.

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

1. very true , agreed. however there are equal chances of UPites, Biharis, South Indian in east , north and equal chances of southindian in up , bihar, and equal chances of west people in south and north. there could be al of them every where.. However the probabilites of UPites, Biharis, maharasthrians, south indian, are very less in NE .. you will not find much of them there....

2. So i did the analysis based on that assumption.. and i have discarded 70% of the votes from NE..however till i see debojit coming to the top three..

3. It is not that we have to accept public voting because it is there. If u do an good in depth analysis, the whole controversy of NE voting for debojit is baseless.......

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

i thought the internet voting was not working..

1. people do say there are programs runnign all the night to vote for contestants..this is wrong ..
a. then they would not have been able to segregate the vote according to the region.
b. beleive me if you run programs all the night, the ovreall voting would have been in crores and not lakhs....

2. i am also confused whne they said for one of the contestant that , he got 6% from delhi, and blah which constitute around 30 % of the entire vote..what about the remaining 70 %.. do they mean to say they got 1 % each for seventy different regions , which is not worth mentioning. it defies all logic at least for me who "uses logic", do they mean there are 70 regions which doesn fall under any bigger region? what a joke...


%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

well, there were times hema /nihira were the lowest and they were about to get eliminated , they came back to top, then there were times debjit sldied from top to bottom....

i think there are consistent voters for each contestants and there are considerable bunch of voters ( who are really musically bend rather than contestant biased ) who vote according to the performance and that is what actually decides who tops and who loses out...

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%

this is=n response to the latest article , as peopel said, published in india today

1. See my analysis on NE voting...that shoudl clear up some thing

https://www.indiaforums.com/forum/sa-re-ga-ma-pa-singing-superstar/183448/ne-voting-analysis-a-must-read


i should not say anything till the reports are cleared..but analysis holds truth if there any bogus voting from assam, as i have already discarded 70% of them, but if it is happening from other states, it the analysis doesn't hold truth...:(


2.Well, i should not question, india today's article( if it is true),can some one please verify that for me.....they may be true but this the bad time they brought that out, they should have brought that in when nihira was voted out...

3. well those three , as people say , stood up for a cause, i would have appreciated , if they had stood up when nihira was out..

4. Well, i would like goverment to chip in and cancel public voting....however if this happens and lets say nihira and few others are called in again , then i am sorry to say , few contestant out of top three will be in trouble :( .....


%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

1.i did the analysis, when this bogus this was not int he picture.

2. As i said we need to verify the facts, till then we shoudl nto say anything... my only point is that , for a second also, if i beleive that was true, still i see debojit as part of top three...please read the psot properly...

3. even if goverment chips in( which should n't be as then there not giving respect to people votes), i am sorry it would be good for debojit, because if u introduce ,sur , taal and other rounds, some other contestants will be in serious problem....

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%%%%%%%%%%%%%

the point is , in all calculations, debojit should havebeen part of top three...if I consider 70% of votes are bogus, still debojit is into final three, and if u dont , then he is the topper..so stop spreading the message that he is winning because he is getting votes from NE

%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%%% %%%

now lets put an end to all the issue about NE voting....


Created

Last reply

Replies

2

Views

543

Users

2

Frequent Posters

avjtroy thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
The lady who shouted that"We dont want Assam's voice, we want India's voice", should be prosecuted for using her foul mouth against the very basis of Indian nationhood. I want to ask those people who are up in arms for the no. of votes got by Debojit from NE ,then please be ready to hear this word that Indian parliament is mostly represented from the cowbelt and majority of these so called representatives are either criminala or crooks. So judge yourselves.
uselogic thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3
just got a intresting fact from one fo our readers..i am sorry i forgot his name...

as i way saying/shouting that if you do an analysis, the whole NE voting issue is baseless. One of the user pointed out that 7% from say UP for vinit, or say 6% from maharashtra for Himani, could be actually smaller than 2% of debojit from say Delhi, if you consider the real numbers....this is very true and if we go thorugh my analysis, this actually echoes the same thing...

can some body psot about these to leading daily...this will put rest to all the controversies...guys now can we stop this issue....

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".