Ehsaas thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#1

Do not critisize ID and Debo if you think they are playing some tactics. Lets analyse the situation by some facts; I think Trios walk out was nothing but a pre planned drama to win back the sympathies of voters. All the contestants know it very well that Nihira is better singer than all of them ad her elimination was kind of a sigh of relief for them. Now it is matter of getting votes not better singing. HR has been manipulative over the past few months but when I look back, it seems like he is doing it as a retaliation caused by the humiliative attitude of JL and AS. AS and JL were always making fun of HR about the fact that when is he going to offer Vinit some playback songs. This attitude backfired later and Vinit became the most strong cntestant. I am not writing this in favor of HR but just analysing the whole kaos of this program. As and JL really dominated the show and way they were rude (especially AS) to Khayyam Jee was really surprising. It seems like AS had some personal grudge against Khayyam Jee. Later on As was bit relax due to tha fact that Hema and Himani are really popular and can win the contest. But recently Debo's getting highest vote has shocked HR and AS. ID walked out and did that drama to get Debo in the winners line, I think he had every right to do that becauase that is the only way to beat AS and HR in their own game.

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

445

Users

4

Frequent Posters

rahulsen73 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#2
i agree with you fully, the walkout drama has been staged by HR and AS and acted through the trio..and remember Vinit said..i know what i am singing..who has provided those dialogues and overconfidence ..its HR..of course !!

My feeling is that Debo was quite shocked at this sudden attitude from fellow contestants..and ID did the right thing by literally opening up the mouths of contestants and mentors to the actual fact that they were jealous of Debo getting max votes...they were not at all willing to say this publicly.. ID had the courage to challenge Vint on his singing abilities and also on the fact that if they had planned this walkout last time..there was no need to even appear on stage that day..and esp. watch what happens to Debo and then react..its a clear cut conspiracy against this poor guy..

Since he comes from a lesser known town in India and from a region which hasn't seen many great musicians from India except Dr. Bhupen Hazarika..its a deliberate attempt to malign him by talking about ULFA and all that..either its a joke or else a cooked up story..its a known fact that if you're from a certain town/city, you'll get maximum support from there compared to the rest of the country..so Debo getting 80% from NE, and not just Assam by the way..is no coincidence..especially after his diffiuclt rednition of the qawwaali " Na to Karwan kI", and AS and HR's deliberately shabby treatment to his performance (they gave 6 and 7 TO HIM ONLY AND 10 to all others)..the public is no fool to appreciate how well he really sang that..no matter what opponent mentors say !!

i appreciate good music and after listening to Debo's earlier renditions of Kishoreda songs, and also the qawwaali and the other songs..i believe he has the talent to be crowned "India ki Voice"..
inku_73 thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#3

Originally posted by: rahulsen73

i agree with you fully, the walkout drama has been staged by HR and AS and acted through the trio..and remember Vinit said..i know what i am singing..who has provided those dialogues and overconfidence ..its HR..of course !!

My feeling is that Debo was quite shocked at this sudden attitude from fellow contestants..and ID did the right thing by literally opening up the mouths of contestants and mentors to the actual fact that they were jealous of Debo getting max votes...they were not at all willing to say this publicly.. ID had the courage to challenge Vint on his singing abilities and also on the fact that if they had planned this walkout last time..there was no need to even appear on stage that day..and esp. watch what happens to Debo and then react..its a clear cut conspiracy against this poor guy..

Since he comes from a lesser known town in India and from a region which hasn't seen many great musicians from India except Dr. Bhupen Hazarika..its a deliberate attempt to malign him by talking about ULFA and all that..either its a joke or else a cooked up story..its a known fact that if you're from a certain town/city, you'll get maximum support from there compared to the rest of the country..so Debo getting 80% from NE, and not just Assam by the way..is no coincidence..especially after his diffiuclt rednition of the qawwaali " Na to Karwan kI", and AS and HR's deliberately shabby treatment to his performance (they gave 6 and 7 TO HIM ONLY AND 10 to all others)..the public is no fool to appreciate how well he really sang that..no matter what opponent mentors say !!

i appreciate good music and after listening to Debo's earlier renditions of Kishoreda songs, and also the qawwaali and the other songs..i believe he has the talent to be crowned "India ki Voice"..



Totally agreed! Secondly, ULFA is a liberation movement of Assam not Bengal and Debojit is Bengali! (Not that it is important but just to get the facts right)
sweety001 thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 19 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: daiz

Ismailji and Debo are good human beings. Just because one supports HR and Vineet too much , they shouldn't start criticising by inventing some false allegations.



thats just what i was about to say! i agree

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".