Y dont they bring composers as judges?

Dont u guys think it'll be better exposure for the contestants if compsoers, like Shankar MAhadevan or my fav. AR Rehman, come as celebrity judges. These people will give in useful input on improving singing. And it'll also help us decide who actually sang better because all Anu does (more often than not) is his faltu shayiri and farah doesnt know music. Most of us judge the singing going by our ears and Sonu's comments- so it'll be valuable for us is Sonu's comments r backed up by a composer's.

Or why not bring in a Shaimak Dawar- atleast he can give input of performance and help them improve....although I feel the need for a 'singing' judge is more at the moment- no one seems to have a major 'performance' problem.

Why do they bring film actors- who's comments r virtually useless- Im sure AR Rehman will garner the same if not mroe trp's than a Mallika Sherawat.

NB: I am fine with the current panel of judges. I'm talking about having composers as celebrity judges.

I agree they should bring in composers. They just try 2 gain the audience's attraction by bringing in celebs whom dont even know how to give a proper cooment based on their singing n performance

Im talking abt the celebrity judges here- Im fine with Anu,Sonu n Farah

In any case no one bothers about the comments of these so called celebs. Sonu said it well "boliye na boliye, sab suna suna sa hai"

But yes, I feel Dino Morea was very polite and encouraging, he spoke within his musical knowledge and didn't speak nonsense like 'chaara paat diya' and stuff.

To continue the thought, I think composers/singers would be an excellent choice to bring in as celeb judges. The public also would get some more guidance, which comes only from Sonu right now.

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

Im talking abt the celebrity judges here- Im fine with Anu,Sonu n Farah

Hey even I too got it wrong pls u should have mentioned it as celebrity judge

Pls I wouldn't want Shaimak Dawar as a judge but rather have Vaibhavi Mercahant or Terrence Lewis.

sorry guys if I've confused u- Im fine with the current panel of judges- it's the celeb judges I was talking abt.