Posted:
I live in USA, so I haven't seen the walkout episode yet. I will be watching this on Monday.
However, I think in whatever circumstances the three participants had to walk out, it is not right. This challenge is like a game and irrespective of the voting, the participants should agree on outcome just like a player does in a game.
I also think that it is not wise for mentors to ask to vote to keep Ismail Darbar happy.
It would be great to see that mentors stay away from promoting their candidates. If they must do, then all mentors should be given equal opportunity. Something for Gajendra Singh to establish as rule for 2006.
Mentors should be not allowed to ask for vote, if they do, then all mentors should be allowed equal time of about 30 seconds or a minute to do so.
Because of persuation by mentors, people are voting by region, origin, etc. etc. but not concentrating on singing. I hope people will objectively vote based on singing of the participants.
I think Nihira should not have been out of the show so early.
I also think Debojit tried to get sympathy vote by showing how he cares about elders in elderly home. I respect that but I think that changes the rules of this game. I also think Himesh is trying to hype the love story of Vinit to gain votes for him.
I think there is nothing wrong if Debojit is getting most votes from NE states, isn't that part of India? So ofcourse the votes are legitimate.
Also, mentors should not get upset if other mentors do not give good points to their candidates. Ismail walked out when it happened, he shouldn't have. When he came in the show, he knew the rules, why not accept the outcome?
It would help to understand why each mentor is giving vertain points to participants. In last few episodes, this is not happening properly.
I also think people should vote based on overall past performance of participants, not just on last one.
I think Gajendra should have created two top spots, one for Female and one for Male singer. he could have made the show by maintaining equal number of male and female participants.
Here is my ranking of selected top singers:
MALE - 1.Vinit 2.Hemachandra 3.Debojit
FEMALE - 1.Nihira 2.Hemani 3.(Bengoli girl, forgot her name)
Overall I am very happy with the show. One of the great show on TV. I can't miss it. I hope Zee TV does more shows like this.
However, I think in whatever circumstances the three participants had to walk out, it is not right. This challenge is like a game and irrespective of the voting, the participants should agree on outcome just like a player does in a game.
I also think that it is not wise for mentors to ask to vote to keep Ismail Darbar happy.
It would be great to see that mentors stay away from promoting their candidates. If they must do, then all mentors should be given equal opportunity. Something for Gajendra Singh to establish as rule for 2006.
Mentors should be not allowed to ask for vote, if they do, then all mentors should be allowed equal time of about 30 seconds or a minute to do so.
Because of persuation by mentors, people are voting by region, origin, etc. etc. but not concentrating on singing. I hope people will objectively vote based on singing of the participants.
I think Nihira should not have been out of the show so early.
I also think Debojit tried to get sympathy vote by showing how he cares about elders in elderly home. I respect that but I think that changes the rules of this game. I also think Himesh is trying to hype the love story of Vinit to gain votes for him.
I think there is nothing wrong if Debojit is getting most votes from NE states, isn't that part of India? So ofcourse the votes are legitimate.
Also, mentors should not get upset if other mentors do not give good points to their candidates. Ismail walked out when it happened, he shouldn't have. When he came in the show, he knew the rules, why not accept the outcome?
It would help to understand why each mentor is giving vertain points to participants. In last few episodes, this is not happening properly.
I also think people should vote based on overall past performance of participants, not just on last one.
I think Gajendra should have created two top spots, one for Female and one for Male singer. he could have made the show by maintaining equal number of male and female participants.
Here is my ranking of selected top singers:
MALE - 1.Vinit 2.Hemachandra 3.Debojit
FEMALE - 1.Nihira 2.Hemani 3.(Bengoli girl, forgot her name)
Overall I am very happy with the show. One of the great show on TV. I can't miss it. I hope Zee TV does more shows like this.
