ADESH: THE REAL VILLAIN

Friends just watched today's episode. Although I was never a fan of Vineet but I must say today he really impressed me. It was one of the toughest song ever tried by Vineet. I felt that he was besura on two occasions, once in the middle and when he ended the song. Other than that he was really very good today. But those two mistakes could be overlooked. Good job Vineet and this is the first time I am saying that.

It was quite evident from Himani's performance that her guilty conscience was a big burden on her today. To describe her performance in one word, I would have to say it was Pathetic. It was flat; and there was no expression and feeling at all. This song proved that her versatility is very very limited. Her final song was just aweful compared to Nihira's final song and compared to Debu. I am wondering how much AS would have given her for this performance. Because after Debu sang this song so wonderfully (except one voice crack), he had given him 4. Then today she deserved a minus 10.

Now let me come to the main point. Adesh, as a human being you cannot even be compared to pig shit, but as a musician you are even worse. Why are you hell bent to destroy Hemu? Hemu has a very good voice quality and is properly trained and has the potential to attempt difficult songs. So, what is your explanation for giving Hemu the easiest song (amongst the four) in the Qawali round? And today you have crossed all limits. You have brought down Hemu to the level of Qazi, because this is the very song that Qazi sings on all occasions. If Qazi can perform this then, we can understand the difficulty level of this song, no matter what you say after the performance. Hemu deserves a much more difficult song than Bhoomro. Why are you slowly killing him? For the past few weeks he has been singing the songs that does not have (or have a very little) classical touch. At this point of the contest where Debu is trying the most difficult songs in the history of hindi films, you are making him sing Bhoomro and Tumse Milke. No matter what is the final outcome of this contest, he has to show his capability just like ID is doing with Debu. You don't deserve to be called a MENTOR. Mentors are supposed to bring the level of the students to a higher plane, not bring them down. First you spoil the public image of the contestants by playing dirty politics along with your buddy Himesh, and now you are spoiling their talents too. SHAME ON YOU. Calling you VILLAIN would be an understatement. YOU ARE A DEVIL.😡

Hemu fans I am not criticizing Hemu, so please don't misunderstand me.

Agree. But you also have to understand that most of the public doesn't know the sa re ga ma pa of music. They vote based on the choice of songs and not the toughness of the song. Nihira sang her last song in the gala (episode b4 vote out) so beautifully, but frankly I had never heard that song, and probably a lot of people in public had the same problem. And hence less votes.

If you make public the judge, then you need to impress the public. Sad state of affair, but true.

AGREE DAT AS IS DA MAIN CULPRIT

Originally posted by: mademoise11e

Agree. But you also have to understand that most of the public doesn't know the sa re ga ma pa of music. They vote based on the choice of songs and not the toughness of the song. Nihira sang her last song in the gala (episode b4 vote out) so beautifully, but frankly I had never heard that song, and probably a lot of people in public had the same problem. And hence less votes.

If you make public the judge, then you need to impress the public. Sad state of affair, but true.

My friend you will have to understand that the entire music industry does not revolve around AS. He has to prove his potential to other music directors, producers, and directors too. Vidhu Vinod Chopra discovered Sanjeevani from this stage, Sanjay Bhansali picked Shreya from this show. So this show is not only about votes and pleasing the public. I may be wrong, but that's what I feel.

I agree with you but HR is also responsible for the drama. If one coould observe the reaction of AS and HR when the lady told that SRGMP is for India voice not for Assam voice. It was plot by HR and AS to take revenge against ID for ID's boycott. They were trying to to prove that what ID did these 17 years old kids can do. IT was clearly pre-planned. And you are correct about Hema song selection and performance. I know Hema is much better singer than Qazi. But when Qazi sings this sing there is better feel. In this song even Qazi never slipped on Sur. But it is pity still public could not understand who is the best among these 3.

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

I agree with you but HR is also responsible for the drama. If one coould observe the reaction of AS and HR when the lady told that SRGMP is for India voice not for Assam voice. It was plot by HR and AS to take revenge against ID for ID's boycott. They were trying to to prove that what ID did these 17 years old kids can do. IT was clearly pre-planned. And you are correct about Hema song selection and performance. I know Hema is much better singer than Qazi. But when Qazi sings this sing there is better feel. In this song even Qazi never slipped on Sur. But it is pity still public could not understand who is the best among these 3.

I agree with you completely, even with such an easy song, Hemu's performance was very mediocre. I really don't want to discuss about those two idiots. Thinking of them makes my blood boil. Why can't they appreciate good music. Debu's performance was best in this round and neither of them had any reactions. And HR's reaction to that stupid lady in the audience was disgraceful. He was so thrilled as if the NE is not in India. I felt like kicking him so hard that his b**ls would come out of his mouth.

Hemas performance was awesome and best of the three and I completely disagree with ur opinion.

Originally posted by: fm_qazi

I agree with you but HR is also responsible for the drama. If one coould observe the reaction of AS and HR when the lady told that SRGMP is for India voice not for Assam voice. It was plot by HR and AS to take revenge against ID for ID's boycott. They were trying to to prove that what ID did these 17 years old kids can do. IT was clearly pre-planned. And you are correct about Hema song selection and performance. I know Hema is much better singer than Qazi. But when Qazi sings this sing there is better feel. In this song even Qazi never slipped on Sur. But it is pity still public could not understand who is the best among these 3.

u know wht plzzzzzzz gimme a break..v know who iz the best......

if debu iz really the best y he iz getting support from home town unline hemu, himani n vinit who r getting support from all acrosee india.........

hemu performance was the best ............
debu performed well..vinit was good too..

I feel that AS doesn't swant Debo to be in the competition for some reason. He needs to learn to be fair. I hope he matures up someday unlike the walkers.