ARRANGED MARRIAGES

romayesa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Hello Friends
After watching many Ekta serials, i wanted to start a topic on arranged marriages, since most of ekta serials revolves around it, i personally agree with arranged marriages ( since i am in one myself). we tend to criticize ekta kapoor, for having the most unrealistic serials, but after watching so many of her daily soaps i have come to realize that she to is pro arranged marriages. the reason i believe arranged marriages tend to work is because both parties have low expectation for each other, and in most cases both parties create love between each other, i personally strictly believe that Love does not just HAPPEN at first or second sight, but instead it must be created between 2 people and that to when their relationship has a strong foundation/base such as marriage, after witnessing a few Love marriages i have come to believe that love marriages seem bright and colorful in the start but because of high expectation of both parties that color seems to fade, also please note that i am not insisting that all love or arranged marriages end up the same, but going by statistics arranged marriages do work better , in conclusion i feel that at some point Ekta kapoor serials
does have a impact on todays society, and also shows some of our cultural truth.
Please do share your thoughts on this post, and express your beliefs on arraigned marriages 😃

Created

Last reply

Replies

9

Views

1.5k

Users

8

Frequent Posters

ammoos thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 4
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
I totally agree with you roma.... i have expressed similar views about Ektaa and arranged marriages in another thread.... like you said arranged marriages have less expectations .... there is always happening unexpected.....love that happen gradually will have a strong base of trust for each other and it will be difficult to move.... Sanraj love is the same...they gradually fell in love after knowing eachothe and accepting eachothers nature.....their love will be/is eternal..........
sg08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Yes, I too beleive that arranged marriages have better chances of succeeding than love marriages....the divorce rate in the west where most marriages are love marriages is a testimony to that. And I also agree it's because you don't really know the person too well, so you are mentally prepared to accept them as they are and making compromises on the way when things don't really go your way...you enter into it knowing that the marriage is going to require work and you work hard to ensure it is successful. Whereas in love marriages people think they know everything about the other person, so when they find out something new about them, it comes as a surprise and in most cases people are not prepared to accept it....also there are too many expectations and when they don't come true, it leads to disillusionment...plus they enter a marriage thinking it is going to be easy since they know the other person well but no marriage is easy and all marriages require constant work. Believe me...I have seen too many couples who had years of courtship but their marriages didn't even survive a year...

As for Ekta's reason for showing arranged marriages or marriages of conveniences....I think thats because they are more interesting. If a couple fall in love and get married after crossing some obstacles, whats interesting in that unless you want to show the fights after marriage...lol. But showing love develop between couples who do not know each other or might not even want to be with each other, so much more interesting...
Edited by sg08 - 16 years ago
soap-critic thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#4
Interesting topic and one on which arguments can be made both in favour and against it.

However, in reference to Ekta's serials I would say that the marraige of the lead jodi is either forced marraige or a contract marraige or a dulha/dulhan getting exchanged (a kind of dhoka despite the circumstances). The jodis in those marraiges went through divorces, EMA's and re-marraiges to the original spouse. Therefore, they could in no way be considered perfect or ideal marraiges.

In Bandini itself, DM has been shown to have had a very successful love marraige with his college sweetheart Subhadra to the point that he still cannot get past her and has kept her alive and has conversations with her portrait. This marraige has lasted for around 20 years till death did them apart.

sg08 thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 30 Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
I am by no means an expert on Ekta's serials.....have only watched one before Bandini and in that show too, the marriage was a forced one....the guy forced the girl to marry him for revenge....but thankfully there was no divorce, although they did come pretty close before the guy realized his mistake, no extra-marital affairs or illegitimate kids for the lead pair although the girl's father had both (lol!) but they did get married multiple times even though they were already married and for the love of God I don't know why....maybe just because Ekta likes weddings...lol....maybe around this time Ekta decided not to have the lead pair go through divorces and EMAs and illegitimate kids and multiple marriages, plus the show wrapped up in a couple of years, so she probably did not have to resort to such gimmicks....hopefully Bandini will be different as it has been so far.

Yeah....DM did have a very successful love marriage and now he is going to have a very successful arranged marriage....well actually a marriage that started of as a convenience.....he definitely is one very lucky guy :)
romayesa thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: sg08

Yes, I too beleive that arranged marriages have better chances of succeeding than love marriages....the divorce rate in the west where most marriages are love marriages is a testimony to that. And I also agree it's because you don't really know the person too well, so you are mentally prepared to accept them as they are and making compromises on the way when things don't really go your way...you enter into it knowing that the marriage is going to require work and you work hard to ensure it is successful. Whereas in love marriages people think they know everything about the other person, so when they find out something new about them, it comes as a surprise and in most cases people are not prepared to accept it....also there are too many expectations and when they don't come true, it leads to disillusionment...plus they enter a marriage thinking it is going to be easy since they know the other person well but no marriage is easy and all marriages require constant work. Believe me...I have seen too many couples who had years of courtship but their marriages didn't even survive a year...<br><br>As for Ekta's reason for showing arranged marriages or marriages of conveniences....I think thats because they are more interesting. If a couple fall in love and get married after crossing some obstacles, whats interesting in that unless you want to show the fights after marriage...lol. But showing love develop between couples who do not know each other or might not even want to be with each other, so much more interesting...<br>



First of all thank you all for adding your thoughts.

and i completely agree with you, that when a person agrees with arranged marriages, your mind is 100% ready to accept change, surprises, up/downs etc. my marriage was completely arranged my mother in law saw me at a funeral, and refereed me to her son, she ( my husband), followed me to school a couple of times, they came to our house with proposal in mind, and after a few visits ( and investigation form my parents), they had us engaged, and after our engagement we first went out, and discussed our life ahead of us back the i was 18 after 3 successful years were still together, i have a daughter who is 2 years old. and like SG08 said both of us were mentally prepared for a rocky life, but since we were our lives went smooth. and inshallah will continue to.

and as for ekta serials, well the only thing i love about it is the fact that she gets two people married who are in the beginning completely opposite one another, yet after some time passes, these people find it hard to live with out one another.
adoremevirgo thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
i hv always been in favour of love marriages. even i dont believe in love at first sight....but i hv seen around me boys and girls who hv been friends for years eventually realising their love for each other and then getting married. fortunately all my friends r very happily married, except one....but then he married an Australian girl....so we did not expect the marriage to work.
i, personally will never go for arranged marriage....its just my POV....cant go into any details....because honestly i dont hv any concrete reason for this.....u may just say i am yet to come out of my M&B days.
fuzzyface thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Commentator Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

the big M word

dun remind me abt it
KaneBC thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
Just because a marriage doesn't end in divorce doesn't necessarily mean it's a successful marriage, doesn't mean the couple is happy and fulfilled. This may be a generalisation but Western societies tend to be less judgemental, believes in minding its own business and recognises people should be free to pursue happiness as they choose. All of these things probably makes it easier to get out of a bad marriage. My parents come from a generation where some people had aranged marriages and some had love marriages but most people of that generation didn't believe in divorce. As a result some marriages are happy and some are stuck in miserable marriages but whether it was an arranged marriage or not doesn't really play a factor and it's difficult to say which marriage started that way. I come from a generation where arranged marriages are almost unthinkable because first of all most parents would not arrange their children's marriage. They don't believe in making decisions for their children, that their children will have to live with, even long after the parents are dead and gone. I think it's near impossible to say which is a more successful type of marriage, you have to look at the broader society in which these marriages take place.
Edited by --BC-- - 16 years ago
dalals thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Hi,

Thanks for bringing up the topic. I do believe in aranged marraiges as long as they are not forced upon the couples. The reason they have a chance to last longer is because you have the family, friends and the society to support you. Plus in an arrange marraige love grows on you as time goes and you start understanding each other, it also make you more compasionate towards each other. But all marraiges comes with expectations and how you deal with that is the key to any successful marraige. Not all love marraige are disasters not all arranged marraiges are successful.
As for Ekta, I am not sure if she believes in marraige at all. All her serials I have seen so far there it is contract marraige or forced marraige like someone pointed earlier. Not one of her serial is with out umpteen divorces and remarraiges between the same couple and their friends.
Edited by dalals - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".