Indian Idol 2 Update 16/1/06 - Page 3

hyperluv, Panna got confused in the middle of his performance n said CUT...this infuriated Tarun Katial...Panna got a blasting for saying "cut", coz this is a reality show, not a film....

BUt then instead of showing Panna's blopper, Sony decided to re-shot Panna's song...so Panna got a second chance to improve his performance...while every1 else got only one opportunity.

Originally posted by: Rumi

Well . for me this is the rating.
1. Amey: he sang perfectly and 10/10.
2. Panna: his performance was superb and song was also ok. so 9/10.
3.Karuniya: although sonu and farha did not praise him i liked his song and performance. may be he was not real Karuniya today but he can get 8/10.
4.Ravi: he will get 7/10 from me.
5..Sagaar: his song lacked energy a bit. so i will give him 6/10.
6. Sandeep: he could not sing the lower notes well.So he gets 5/10 from me.

100% agree with you, i have the same comclusion. You should be the judge of the show. Well done, very fair.

Originally posted by: breathing_irony

hyperluv, Panna got confused in the middle of his performance n said CUT...this infuriated Tarun Katial...Panna got a blasting for saying "cut", coz this is a reality show, not a film....

BUt then instead of showing Panna's blopper, Sony decided to re-shot Panna's song...so Panna got a second chance to improve his performance...while every1 else got only one opportunity.

That is soo infair to all the other contestants.. 😡