Himani Jiya Dhadak Vs RFAK Jiya Dhadak

I admit I liked it first when Himani sang that Jiya Dhadak. But Trust me, Please go and download RFAK's version.
After hearing both versions: I conclude the foll.(No prejudice here, I respect her hardwork)

1. Not effective Breath Control.
2. Mis-pronounciation of the word Dhadak EVERYtime.
3. Mood of the Song has been totally reversed.

And all this after selecting a song from her home pitch.
Not defying anybody, just my observation...

to compare RFAK with himani is ridiculous.

I agree with you that her breath control could be better but remember that hers is live and RFAK's is recorded. I do not agree with you on the rest of your statements. (no offense 😃 )

COMMON GUYS!!!!!!!!!
HOW CAN U ALL B SILLY??????
RFAK DINT SING LIVE.... THAT WAS RECORDED... MIGHT HAVE TAKEN SO MANY RETAKES....
HIMANI SANG IT LIVE IN SINGLE TAKE AND M SURE IF SHE RECORDS IT SHE WILL DO FULL JUSTICE......
AND ONE MORE INFO.......
SHE GOT 5 STAR RATING WHILE RFAK GOT 3 STARZ.....GO AND LOG ON TO COOLTOAD.COM U'LL SEE......

Tellus,
I was going to open a topic on her breath control in that song. Good observation. I am surprised none of the opponent judges mentioned it. It was really obvious.
As far as stage performances go, it wasn't like she was dancing. She is good just had a bad day on that one aspect and luckily got away scott free.

i think as a live performance it was already up to standard wht say..?

She did good on every other aspect except the breathing. If there were judges, they would have commented on that.

On the contrary I loved Himani's singing she has a superb voice for this genre of songs and can do miracles...if continues with this spirit...I loved the song only because of her singing it so beautifully.only this morning I was comparing them and felt like bringing this here...
anyways good observation guys...but as it was live performance so you have to give her some room.

Originally posted by: juhisingapore

On the contrary I loved Himani's singing she has a superb voice for this genre of songs and can do miracles...if continues with this spirit...I loved the song only because of her singing it so beautifully.only this morning I was comparing them and felt like bringing this here...
anyways good observation guys...but as it was live performance so you have to give her some room.

WELL SAID MAN 👏👏👏

Originally posted by: juhisingapore

On the contrary I loved Himani's singing she has a superb voice for this genre of songs and can do miracles...if continues with this spirit...I loved the song only because of her singing it so beautifully.only this morning I was comparing them and felt like bringing this here...
anyways good observation guys...but as it was live performance so you have to give her some room.

I agree with you. She did aalap at the end which is not in the original song and it was beautifully done.