This is serious-do reply(chk pg 7)

ranjitha thumbnail
19th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Fascinator 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Good morning people
Yesterday Headlines Today had called on Rajeev with a few experts like Psychiatrist and two other people(don't remember their details) to discuss about the concept and the impact of SKS!!

The debate was probably expected but couldn't understand why was Rajeev called to speak about the lie detector and polygraph test. One man was continuously shouting at Rajeev for spoiling the society by motivating people to put their families at risk just for the sake of money and the other person was stating the polygraph machine to be not genuine. Rajeev initially spoke well with confidence but later when these two men started shouting, his confidence fell flat and he didn't know how to convince them and the viewers.
Myself and Vandu had an hour long of chat about this and we weren't convinced about two things:

1)The questions that were shown to the experts were from MOT and not SKS , and as stated by Mr.Basu Indian version will have lighter questionss that suits its culture
2)Why didn't Mr.Basu participate in this debate when he is responsible for everything and would have knowledge about the tests the questions and so on. The host neither creates questions nor forces somebody to reveal truth. His job is just to ask questions, then why was he held responsible for everything?
3)Would these people talk in the same way to SRK or AB if they were hosting the show??

And ya some TV stars were asked their opinion about the show. Bidai start had mixed opinion and were justified. But there was one actor who said "SKS s***s". Don't want to name him bcoz I know that his fans are blind followers of him and taking his name might lead to fights.

I fear the show will be banned bcoz the reporter was mentioning about MOT being banned in many countries every now and then!! I hope I'll be proven wrong.
Do U think a show like this would affect his filmy career?????
This was an update with a POV
Plz state UR take on it.

Edited by ranjitha - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

86

Views

5.4k

Users

28

Likes

24

Frequent Posters

Bugger thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
thx for the info
i guesst his show will hav their set of viewers!! and i feel the participants themselves r responsible if they r families r broken cuz of the show!! they r not forced into teh show , they came cuz of money ...they can quit at any time and moreover they know teh questions before hand so i dun think we can blame the producers or teh channel!!
or bechare host ka toh kuch lena dena hi nahi hai in sab meiin!
jyothi_cool thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
ranjitha this was some thing i expected when u try to do some thing diff it always happens it happened with kjo during kank where he and srk had to defend the movie and the people were shouting at them.

as far as the other stars are concerned they always will talk wrought of another show such as to spoil it .

the Indian audience have already accepted the show with open arms.
.Rabi. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

I agree with u Ranju, Rajeev is not responsible for the show... he is just doing his job for asking question... I dont know why people behaving like this? i didnt watch that interview u are talking abt but i read people reviews many where abt the show and i saw people bashing him very badly thats not good...

People should accept the show .... dont know why this all? Rajeev is a great human he can deal people but if they shout over him then no one can bear after a limit.... i dont know wot they hell they are doing this?? or i think they are doing just for insulting him??
Surya.Ravi thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#5
ranju now this is a shock.. first of all the people who were shouting at Rajeev should understand that he is just hosting the show & doing nothing more than that... it is the producers choice that he wants to take such a show..& coming to the participants they are not kids joh jaisa kahe waisa karenge, they have come to the show by their own will, whatever the reason may be money, or relief or anything it is the participants choice...they are given time to think if they want to participate if the contestants are coming forward to take part in the show how can anyone stop them...& how can they shout at Rajeev....can you give me that programs or that channels mail id, i would really like to ask them this question...& i agree Siddarth Basu should have been there for the debate...& they showed MOT's clipping this is one more mistake which they did, as it is a fact that SKS has been mellowed down a little for the Indian audience.....
.Rabi. thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

pls tell me abt the interview it was on aajtak??

MoonDesir thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7

Originally posted by: cute_rabi

pls tell me abt the interview it was on aajtak??



der wer 2 interviews 1 was on aajtak at 8.30-8.55p.m,

da headlinestoday argument 😡 was at 9-9.30 p.m.
Daebak thumbnail
20th Anniversary Thumbnail Visit Streak 180 Thumbnail + 7
Posted: 16 years ago
#8

Glad you opened this topic Ranju !

Firstly....Headlines Today people ought to be bashed mercilessly for being foolish enough to not call the creatives and the technical people dealing with the polygraph test !!
A host....even if a very interested one will only find out about the general information about the lie detector test.....If Rajeev probed too much into this then there wud be articles saying how he is interfering in every domain of the show where he has no expertise....!
A host is not obliged or expected to know about the technical things such as polygraph tests on such shows......There are specialists brought in for that....thats y these tests cant be manned by just anyone and everyone!! It was their folly !!
Secondly, SKS creative team.....Will Siddharth Basu please show his face...!
Or is he interested only in taking credit for being the Indian Genius behind successful game shows and he is living in the La-La land of bouquets without taking any responsiblity for the brick bats....Y in the worlld did they send Rajeev for the show ,if they had a inkling about the topic to be discussed on the show....!
Thridly , the host channel.....they have no right to invite a guest and watch them getting demeaned....I suppose they could have intervened and made the so-called experts.....who dont even seem to know what to ask to whom.....that "Rajeev is not the polygraph test administrator or the creative director/script writer of SKS"...😡
Then, any person while talking on camera should have communication ethics.....U cant scream and shout and say whatever you feel like, to the person sitting in front of you just for your 2 minutes of fame.....It was as if this is his lifetime opportunity to be on TV and he wants to say everything he knows in that 30 mins ......They should have respect for the person sitting in front of them,who is a public figure....and has a self respect and standing in the society........Its not a fish-market that you can rant on and on...😡
Lastly, Its high time Indian people came face to face with the actual happenings and stop living in a dream world......There is no lie in this......this is just showing the facts as it is........This is happening in India......This is the truth.....Face it People.....GROW UP !! Agreed that there is no need for numayish in front of the world .....but ......Those contestants got 20-30 days to choose if they want to take part or not........Its their choice.......No one is going door to door and keeping people on gunpoint to make them take part in the show....!
Its their life.....Its their choice....!
Agar itna hi aitraaz hai to why did u give permission to shoot this show......!😡They shouldnt have given permission to telecast the show....Where is Star Plus.....where are they hiding when fingers are being pointed at them......Its beyond me how you can blame the host for the concept of the show !
And it was clear that yesterday those people were screaming their heads of without even watching the show....because the questions that were shown were of Moment Of Truth.....the US version.....Not of SKS.....!
I refuse to acknowledge them as experts...!🤢
And btw, that one so-called actor.....Who cant even act.........Sumone needs to tell him that he makes the shows he is a part of ...seem the worst shows of the decade.....He can hardly pass judgements on others shows........Also.....I happen to have seen the guy in real life...at the airport and he doesnt even have anything about him which he can be proud of....in terms of looks !! So its better for him not to invoke the wrath of the "Rajeev" fans.....coz clearly the guy is jealous of Rajeev....
Infact , M sure....right now if u ask any TV actor , they WILL give a negative comment......Coz Rajeev signed a Sanjay Bhansali film....so it is everyone else's birthright to pull him down and what better way than this.....a show that is already under attack and which Rajeev is hosting !!! Sum ppl just stoop down to any level !! Sad !!
Had the show been accepted the channel would have taken the credit....but if a show faces flak then everyone backs out and lets all the blame be put on the Host..........Nice ....!😡👏😡.....Siddharth Basu pestered Rajeev and even made him watch Moment of Truth ......so that Rajeev wud sign the show....coz Rajeev had refused to host.....but Basu persisted till Rajeev signed the show....and now Mr.Basu is hiding,is it?😡
I only hope the Bollywood Directors are intelligent enough not to hold Rajeev responsible for this show...even if it gets banned...which m assuming it will be.......We Indians.....will close eyes and ears to all the burai....and just pretend that we are the perfect society...!
It would be really retarded if this incident affects Rajeev's career adversely.......I m hoping our directors have sumthing called the brain.....and hopefully they put it to use !!
Luv,
Vandu
Edited by togepe30 - 16 years ago
Bugger thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
@topege - nice write up buddy .....very well said!! even i blive teh same .....tht participants r mature enuff to know tht whetehr they shud enter such type of show or not ........they r not getting kids here who cant decide for themsellves
btw can u plz tell me who the actor was who passed comments bout teh show ..i havent see it and if u cant tell here plzz do pm me!
Bluefalls thumbnail
18th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10
written very well vandu ...and thanks for the info ranju diiii!!!!

Though i m not at all surprised....headlines today is the english version of aaj tak i.e both the channels are headed by same ppl... ....its sometimes called as aaj tak's english sister news channel and knowing aaj tak's enemity with him since aamir...And knowing the kind of controversy this show may create this should not come as a surprise to rajeevians.I wonder why rajeev agreed to go there unprepared😕.Even there was some mishap in India TV i heard...😕

And another info....Rajeev will be there on NDTV India on sunday at 8:00 pm. I guess Video will be uploaded so those who cant watch dont be sad😆.
Edited by SAHELIGSWM - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".