~*Creative's Jannat # 12 - Future Scenes*~

First Previous

Page

116

Next Last

Frequent Posters

Preethi

@preethis

Rocker

Posted: 16 years ago

#51

S Sana dear a episode of only Mayur.....

Quote

Nothing

@AnonymousUser

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#52

Originally posted by: nureat01

I know, Ash.....this was the ONLY positive place left on the forum...and now this has been turned negative as well😭 How will we ever be able to bear all this negativity??

Lets go and spread some sunshine dude!!!

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shazia

@shockalot

Sparkler

+ 7

Posted: 16 years ago

#53

Originally posted by: ofcourse
@shockalot - Ok..agreed PD knows about the actors more than we do.

So if the actors were not able to deliver to their caliber, is it not the creatives job to see "why" this has happened? As CrazyKaShFan has mentioned.... the characters have been butchered to such an extent and that too in a blink of an eye that the actors are not even able to recognize what they are actually playing. They were not even given enough time to adapt themselves to the sudden changes their characters were undergoing..So why state that the actors were not up to the mark?

And this is what the MaYur fans(the so called Negative group) have been ranting over and again.....

Because as a creative, she and other creatives expect their actors to slip into whatever character they sketch out in the blink of an eye....whether said character is well-sketched out or some ghissa-phita sketch....and maybe she was disappointed that it didnt happen the way she had imagined....like i said, I'm not blaming ArTi in anyway...i'm just saying that our way of thinking and a creatives way of thinking is different...

Quote

AreYaar

@AreYaar

Icon

+ 19

Posted: 16 years ago

#54

Originally posted by: shockalot
Oh no, i truly agree...PD herself shouldnt have given so much out about the confession....her scoop should have been something like "MayUr confession coming up, get ready for it!" and that's it......THAT is something to get excited about....by knowing SO much about it already, we're gonna obviously set our expectations high, naturally, and we'll end upp being disappointed!

Exactly Shaz....I don't even mind little details being leaked...but given the extremely 'vivid' descriptions PD used to describe how amazing the confession scene will be....can you blame a lot of the fans for having high expectations??? And to now see her pull a 180 and say the scene wasn't all that....it's odd to say the least.

Quote

@Ra92

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#55

Originally posted by: preethis
S Sana dear a episode of only Mayur.....

yeah..prethi i have read

Quote

StarshineHues

@StarshineHues

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#56

All right, I don't know why, but I'm suddenly feeling brave enough to express my views on the much awaited confession, and I'd like to emphasise that these are my views only.

Honestly, I found the confession scene much below expectations, and this is after PD'S scoops and the scenes we have been getting recently had already dampened any enthusiasm that I might have had for this scene. The editing, as usual, was below par, especially in the initial part of the scene, where the camera never really focuses on the person saying the dialogue, so that it appears that the voices are coming from random portions of the screen.

Also, one major drawback is that the flashbacks Nupur had today during the "realization" of her "love", included scenes that she could possibly not have any recollection of, i.e. the sequence during Khudaa Jaane when Mayank imagines that Nupur was dancing with him and the amazing barn scenes which occured after Nupur was drunk. Even the other flashback scenes did not seem to gel with the voiceover.

At the end, I couldn't exactly understand the need for Nupur to walk away while Mayank was waiting with his arms outstretched to hug her. It appeared that just to lend additional drama to the scene, Nupur was made to take off like an aircraft off a runway before she "leaps" into her "hero's" arms, the end result being that all subtlety (I'm not sure if there was any left after the scenes we have been getting lately) of the moment was completely tarnished.

However, I'd still like to say that Rati was magnificent in the scene. Her eyes talked. Arjun, too, was great when Nupur starts talking about her "Raj" and the "Sadoo".

All in all, I thought that such a moment, which is the defining point of any love story, was handled in an extremely ham-handed manner. If the creatives think that the actors were not up to par in the scene, it could be because the scene, like all their scenes recently, lacked conviction.

Again, I'd like to reiterate that these are my views only. I do not intend to offend anyone.

Quote

Kavya

@Bazinga

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#57

@PD: With due to respect to your personal opinions about the actors on this show , let me add that whatever you write here is free for our interpretation because your posts are viewed as inside information, so we are bound to receive it in some way - negative or positive! As someone who visits this forum as representative of the show (at least according to us), we expect you to take it all in your stride.

Secondly, we are still watching Mayank n Nupur not because we are greatly impressed with your "creative skills" in handling their "love" and their "track" but because Rati n Arjun are making us watch it somehow ,especially Rati NEVER fails to entertain us with her flawless performance n amazing expressions despite all the unpleasant-on-our-ears lines her character is made to mouth, poor Arjun, it seems to us, got lost in Mayank's confusion n rapid character changes that he sometimes fails to give in his best- he cannot be blamed because there is only so much he can do . However, both of them are still doing a fair job of entertaining us on some level and making us watch this show despite the inanity of their scenes, cheesiness of their dialogues and the death of their original characters. I am daring to say that you and your team are purely banking on the Rati n Arjun's capabilities n their chemistry to make us watch this show instead of extracting the best of their powerhouse talent by giving MN characters a good storyline with a strong script. I am sorry but if we have liked any scenes of MN off late, its because of Rati n Arjun's capability to make us like them , not because you have penned something great for them which can automatically be liked everyone. Your approach towards MN makes us feel that you have taken MN fans for granted because Rati n Arjun will make even a dull or weak scene worth a watch anyway (despite the terrible costumes that are given to them, poor direction of their scenes n bad editing), therefore, it is unfair of you to comment on their acting abilities in the first place because clearly your team is purely dwelling on the mercy of their natural acting abilities wrt MN- sorry to say, but this is the truth.

Thirdly, you have told (rather promised) us that we would go weak-kneed, we would rejoice etc after watching this confession scene a week ago, its quite amusing to see you back tracking just a day before the episode airs- how come the confession that was supposedly 'euphoric' a week ago, suddenly 'not above excellence' today? After reading your comment , I felt disoriented to watch the episode today , not that I felt oriented to watch it after seeing the promo anyway, nevertheless, I was willing to give it a shot but after reading your scoop I did not watch it!

All I request of you is to be a bit more clear in your communication with us so that we do not misunderstand you or feel mislead or cheated by your scoops.

Thanks

Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 16 years ago

Quote

Mitsy

@mits002

Dazzler

Posted: 16 years ago

#58

Originally posted by: StarshineHues
All right, I don't know why, but I'm suddenly feeling brave enough to express my views on the much awaited confession, and I'd like to emphasise that these are my views only.

Honestly, I found the confession scene much below expectations, and this is after PD'S scoops and the scenes we have been getting recently had already dampened any enthusiasm that I might have had for this scene. The editing, as usual, was below par, especially in the initial part of the scene, where the camera never really focuses on the person saying the dialogue, so that it appears that the voices are coming from random portions of the screen.

Also, one major drawback is that the flashbacks Nupur had today during the "realization" of her "love", included scenes that she could possibly not have any recollection of, i.e. the sequence during Khudaa Jaane when Mayank imagines that Nupur was dancing with him and the amazing barn scenes which occured after Nupur was drunk. Even the other flashback scenes did not seem to gel with the voiceover.

At the end, I couldn't exactly understand the need for Nupur to walk away while Mayank was waiting with his arms outstretched to hug her. It appeared that just to lend additional drama to the scene, Nupur was made to take off like an aircraft off a runway before she "leaps" into her "hero's" arms, the end result being that all subtlety (I'm not sure if there was any left after the scenes we have been getting lately) of the moment was completely tarnished.

However, I'd still like to say that Rati was magnificent in the scene. Her eyes talked. Arjun, too, was great when Nupur starts talking about her "Raj" and the "Sadoo".

All in all, I thought that such a moment, which is the defining point of any love story, was handled in an extremely ham-handed manner. If the creatives think that the actors were not up to par in the scene, it could be because the scene, like all their scenes recently, lacked conviction.

Again, I'd like to reiterate that these are my views only. I do not intend to offend anyone.

I agree 100%! Especially the bolded parts!!!

Quote

GamesOfLife

@GamesOfLife

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#59

My intake on the confession :

pd why were u guys worried ????? it was gr8 ...👏

when u love a person ... everything speaks ... that is ur body language , ur smile , ur eyes , Ur words .... in .the confession scene ..... u will c... that u say it best when u say nothing at all .........

then there r words ... which r very necessary ... somebody rightly said that till u declare ur love it is useless ... as it is very imp that u say up front ...." i Lov u " these 3 words r easiest as well as most difficult to say ....but r Mayu did it for his Love ... I am so Proud of Arjun and Rati ... rati expression ... and Arjun intensity were sizzling and it created one Hell of a scene ......👏....

then finally ... all the times which Nups remember .... editors and whoever is responsible this time did great .... bec ... flash back scenes were all gr8 ones and important one 👏....

finally Nups faced and said it to Mayu also ...that He is different from her dream guy ...but he is better than any dreams Nups ever had .......these were the words which Mayu needed to Know ... as he had an insecurity that he is a different guy ...Nups for once and for all cleared it .... and Let Mayu Know ...how Much he is loved ..👏

Pd ...u had nothing to fear ..... I totally Loved this scene ... Arjun and Rati did really very very good ....👏... i am very happy for them and for u .... u guys go and Pat each others back .... brilliant creatives .... simply brilliant 👏

@ one thing u made them cry and u made them cry 👏...... very very sweet yaar 👏... so touching 👏

I am Proud to call Myself .... Mjht fan and a Mayurian 👏

Quote

DiscoDhokla

@DiscoDhokla

Stunner

+ 23

Posted: 16 years ago

#60

PD d confession was rocking... brilliant scene... thanks for d wonderful scene.. like sana said proud 2 b a mayurian... i was blushn for whole 30 mins n till now i can see mayank's smile right infront of me...