Why Cant they go by the book? - Page 3

Originally posted by: ..sukhi..

thats pretty much it. if they keep this up, imma end up remaking the twilight movies but then again robert fits edwards role perfectly and so does jake, sometimes kirsten. but seriously just go by the book! for goodness sake, i wish harry potter directors were makin the movie :(

twilight sorta did disappoint me...i really wanted to see the scene where mike, eric, and tyler asked Bella to the dance and Edward laughed at her from his car from hearing their thoughts and her irritated reaction by pressing on the gas, now that was HILARIOUS!!

honestly, even harry potter isn't the same...have you ever noticed that Hermione doesn't argue to protect the house elves at Hogwarts and Ron doesn't make fun of her for it? There's only so much that can be put into the movies. I'd like for New Moon, Eclipse, and Breaking Dawn to go as close to the books as possible but they may have to spice things up to make it interesting...Face it, Stephenie wrote a love story, but to get the guys to watch the film, it will have to be a little more action packed....

Have you ever wondered how the movie to Breaking Dawn would be like if it went by the book? Bella gets married, has her honeymoon, is pregnant, comes back, has Reneesme, becomes a vampire, Volturi try to kill Nessie, and then the Volturi walk away, with the option to return later?? and EB have their happy ending afterwards?? and Jacob-Nessie's future is just assumed?? that would be an awkward film (although i loved how Bella opened her mind to Edward, finally!!)

Originally posted by: * ~ Roshni ~ *

Are u talking abt twilight or new moon?

If its regarding twilight then they have tried - i'll give them that but there were huge chunks they missed which i would have loved to see like the blood typing part but overall twilight the film wasnt how i imagined it would be. Obviously the books are better - usually are better than the films. I think taylor and rob are perfect as edward and jake according to description from the book but the image i had of bella - kristen doesnt match it (a little by description - the hair and figure yea but personality wise as bella not really) and thats prob why i was disappointed with the film because bella is the lead character and i dont think she suited it 100% but she wasnt that bad either. I know there must be many kristen fans who might not have liked what i said but to me bella is soft/warm/friendly who can put up a hard face and be strong but kristen to me has a bit more of hard face if u kno what i mean (not insulting her in anyway just the way i feel)

i agree with ya