REPLACE THE JUDGES ON INDIAN IDOL

Page

jagb78

@jagb78

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I really wonder how people judge others ? You guys just listen to the judges, a bunch of idi...., dont you ? They dont even know how to speak and just sitting there arguing for the sake of their egos - Anu Malik deserves to be nowhere in music world.

Edited by jagb78 - 19 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

wizgal

@wizgal

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

They are paid to say all this. Its similar to American Idol, the judges are meant to be rude & arrogant.
But, even I agree, Anu Malik is himself such a pathetic singer, how can he judge others.
Sonu Nigam is the only one who deserves to be a judge

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Nalini.Sharma

@pl-person

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

I really thought that they should appreciate the contestants hard work,good or not good but should always encourage them.Ok so if some one is besura let them down but gently not crush them.I don't think that there is a necessity to cut them down,insult and worst to worst make them cry.Everyone has a dream and there is no harm trying to make that dream come true.These judges should be a role model not macho man cause there is nothing for them to prove,but yes they surely can make these kids work harder towards achieving something better,just like parents do.It is sad to see the reactions that judges pass onto those contestants who have everything put on line for just a dream.

Edited by pl-person - 19 years ago

Quote

lakshmi

@lucky_lakshmi

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

i feel they r better than fg judges for sure!xcepting anu, both farah and sonu r great!esp:sonu...he always says the right thing

Quote

Sumesh

@sumesh

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 19 years ago

whatever it is judges wont impact public...they r just add masalas for teh show....

Public wont care abt these & if they argue or angry to soemone public will take them....

So pls judges dont make any controversies for not deserving winners becoz they may win title in teh end....

just say oen sentence that u dont liek or not....

JOLLY PANNA YESHSHREE & RAVI came becoz of tehse things

Quote

52703

Suspended

Posted: 19 years ago

I really don't understand y they have anu and farah on d judges panel.Anu mallik has such a horrible voice so i prefer not listenin to d songs he sings and d songs he composes r pretty weird.Farah is a choreographer and has nuthin to do with singin.All she is bothered abt is d performance 🤢 .I know d performance is cumpolsory but cmon does she never listen to how they sing ??????😡

Edited by sanah-misra - 19 years ago

Quote

Ahmed Shahan Khalid

@Ahmed143

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

Originally posted by: jagb78

I really wonder how people judge others ? You guys just listen to the judges, a bunch of idi...., dont you ? They dont even know how to speak and just sitting there arguing for the sake of their egos - Anu Malik deserves to be nowhere in music world.

totally DISAGREED.....the show is interesting just coz of these judges...if they keep saying plain YES and plain NO to everyone, then it would turn out to be a pathetic show....i think these 3 r the best

n those who say that Anu is not a good singer...so ppl, is it all abt singing, if yes, then please take the X factor out of the competition...and Anu is a good composer (though not great)...and he knows music...as for Farah, there has to be someone to judge the start power and Farah does it....

If all the 3 judges r singers, then they all wud see the contestants from the same point of view...this mix of judges provide the opportunity to scrutinize the performers from all angles....

and most of all, they all r funny ppl with good sense of humor.....just see the judges of FG, all serious ppl, all serious comments....😕

even if u r not satisfied, name any others who can replace these 3....

Quote

Shraddha

@lashy

Trailblazer

+ 4

Posted: 19 years ago

well judges do have an impact on the public.. if they turn down a good singer having a bad day, he gets a lot of sympathy votes....

Quote

breathing_irony

@breathing_irony

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

they've copied the format frm American Idol...if u find the judges at II rude, then u shd see American Idol....esp. Simon...HE"S ONE HELL OF A NASTY GUY...but then such things dont come naturally 2 Anu Malik.....it suits Simon coz he's ALWAYS very critical n his comments r BANG ON...he'll pick the best on doubt.......but all Anu Malik does is his shero-shayari.....infact Anu Malik shd tell them want they did rite n wat not....or lik Simon does, just tell them to get out if they rnt good.....who wants his poetry?
Farah is a needed coz we obviously dont want a n II who just sings with their eyes closed. do we? We want a performer...not a brilliant dancer or something...but some1 with stage presence
Sonu is the BEST JUDGE EVER...of all the music shows...He's really good...he's very frank but at the same time not ridiculing...n he tells ppl wat the need to knw...

Sayin tht, I think having farah khan is not totally justified...she doesnt knw ANYTHING abt singin n here the MAIN criteria is SINGIN..Id have preferred Sunidhi Chauhan in farah's place...coz Sunidhi is the ONLY singer who ROCKS at performing as well

Quote

Shyama

@sonu_nigamfan

Inactive

Posted: 19 years ago

#10

ya u can change Anu and Farah but plsssssssssss noone shud change Sonu coz he is the best judge ang always gives the right comments.he is soooo wunderful.But somehow I dont think Indian Idol will b complete without Anu and Farah either 😊

Quote

1 2

REPLACE THE JUDGES ON INDIAN IDOL

Related Topics

Explore Topics