Mayur: good moments or good track?

Page

Next Last

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Okay after a log time I am making a serious topic on the forum and I would like to hear good opinions about it....

Im not forcing my opinion on anyone..

when I look at the SG track which makes sense to me..
it was from being strangers...to respecting each other..trusting each other... misunderstandings... then realisation that they are the best each other could hae and now progressing towards lowe... i am not talking about shammy

in my opinion some MN moments like the beach moments, the barn moments were so wonderful that they stood out beautifully..

but lookin at the track...
strangers to
saduu mayank and talkative mayank becoming project partners
friendship
huge anger
an underlying current of enmity/lowe/sarcasm throughout
realisation of lowe
misunderstanding
friendship
saduu mayank
sarcasm

somehow it looks lke following the circular path all over again....

do mayur have better moments that erase the necessity of a story all together.. we look at a scene and we say wah wah..but does it relate to the overall story....

PS: there is always a difference of opinion.... a story i might like may sound trashy to u... that doesnt mean my opinion or urs is trashy :) repect :)

Quote

Frequent Posters

Sid

@Sid4TeamCanada

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

i think that is wht has been abt mayur since the TP days Caro.. at first there was a gradual change from enmity to friendship to misunderstanding...per uske baad...CIRCLE CIRCLE CIRCLE....

and after that...all that we have been seeing...is one or two magical M moments that made us all go : "wowwww...waah ji waah"...but the track remained 👎🏼

achanak se on the trip mayank started having "feelings" for her...alll his anger (the way he was angrily punching that boxing bag) evaporated...it's all so wierd..

and then they came out of this trip with mayank having fallen in love and turned into a full pappu...

then we have him drunk...then we have them play this saddooo mayank and clingy nupur following him around , tom and jerry kinda track - what did it all mean???hadn't we had enough of it in the post TP days with nupur constantly begging him for forgiveness????

then we have this play stuff with mayank acting as samrat to get the role in the play - that was total 🤬 what was the POINT OF THAT?

so in aswer to ur post, MN have more of good moments - but not a good track..i can list a variety of good SCENES...but i can't come up with one good compliment abt the flow of the track..the track has always been so confusing..

it's like..they have this lousy track...and all of us MN fans are criticising this..and then all of a sudden they give us this amazing MN scene.....we all start applauding it...but thsoe scenes do nothing to make the track improve...

mayank giving his shirt to nupur- scene was amazing...per wht was the meaning of it??? that nupur sees wht a caring and understanding guy mayank is?? well she HAS seenthat before - when he saved her from those goons! then she didn't fall for him...now she did! where's the sense in that? the only sense is us wakt creatives cudnt make her fall for him now they had to make her fall!

mayank saying sorry to nupur in the rehearsal scene - amazing scene!👏 point of it?😕

at the end he had to go and apologise t her anyways...what the the POINT OF that rehearsal scene then? 😕

we want to see something different - them making their friendship stronger!! aise scenes kyu nahi milte? aisa track kyu nahi milta??😕 im done with having to see such confusing, circling MN tracks, and then have one or two outstanding scenes, and then back to the same fluctuating track!😕

Edited by SidraLuvMayurBL - 16 years ago

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

Shipra

@Shipra_S

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

Ya Caro....i agree with u😊.....although till now i was saying in every post ki i am loving the Mayur track...but now after reading ur post,i got the clear pic. in my head....i m actually loving the good Mayur moments...not the track....coz it's actually not good.....u r rite,it's very fast and illogical.....nupur falling in love in just 1 night is something unpredictable....thanks yaar for clearing the confusion in my head!!.....😳
and yes Mayur don't really have a story👎🏼.....they have moments.....the story is of Sajan's or even Rania's.....but Mayur have just moments which take their so-called track forward!!😳

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

woa krishmjht I was thinkig u woulbe on the other side of the fence..thank u soo much fr the reply..im glad ki it made sense to u! this is what we negatives were ralking about all along!😛

we lowe the moments..we dont say no.. but the story somehow is still going in circles...

Quote

Kavya

@Bazinga

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

*camera flashes on my face three times* Caro opening a Serious topic ? Excuse me *goes aside, ROFLs and comes back* *rubs her eyes in disbelief and pinches herself* Yes, Caro HAS opened a SERIOUS Topic OMG!
Jokes apart, nice topic Caro 👏 👏 👏 I agree about the circular fashion of MN's track with their characters going tangential to that circle. I also liked the way you pointed how there is a lot of difference between SG n MN track handling.

Coming to your question -do mayur have better moments that erase the necessity of a story all together.. we look at a scene and we say wah wah..but does it relate to the overall story....

I would like to ask how is it a MOMENT when there is no depth? Beach and Barn scenes were MOMENTS because there was profound thought process involved with the characters staying true to their original sketch, what we get to see now are SCENES because I only enjoy seeing ArTi enacting them (if I see MN wise, it has no effect on me ). I am not sure if scenes require the foundation of a strong story or not but personally, I'd go for a scene which goes with a sensible storyline because then, that scene would become a MOMENT between the characters

Edited by Kavya_KraZQueen - 16 years ago

Quote

Anwaya

@anwaya

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

yup!

i m not follower of MN but it did stucked me sum how, that they r reverising the characters over all!

i mean Mayoo becoming sumthing else n Nupz sumthing!

i miss the old charm between them!

Quote

None

@ImmaculateDream

Sparkler

Posted: 16 years ago

well couldnt hold my self .. so came back to reply in ur post carao dear ...

well ia gree with u . mayur doesnt have a story ... n i m gald they dun have .. strange na??? wot they have is a beautiful interplay of caracters ... which is yet to find on tv these days .. n we are lucky to have ARjun n RAti to play them ... honestly thts y i m watching them since the begining.. ... n will continue to do so ... if creatives didnt contradict them or add a bhankaas story to them ... abhi tak they havent disappointed me ... less ahmedabad track ... but still there were tose beautiful moments ... interplays are not easy to deal with ... anyways .. lets wait n watch ... sabr ka phal meetha hota hai .. 😊

as far as sajans sotry is cncerned? i better watch kuch kuch hota hai .. with sharhrukh rani n kajol ...anyday ...

to add more .. i hope the creatives manages to keep it this way ....

thanks .. it snot necessary to agree with me ... :)

Edited by SAra_Spiritual - 16 years ago

Quote

petticoat

@petticoat

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Kavya_KraZQueen
*camera flashes on my face three times* Caro opening a Serious topic ? Excuse me *goes asides, ROFLs and comes back* *rubs her eyes in disbelief and pinches herself* Yes, Caro HAS opened a SERIOUS Topic OMG!
*holds a danda..tu meri mazaak uda rahi hain!*
Jokes apart, nice topic Caro 👏 👏 👏 I agree about the circular fashion of MN's track with their characters going tangential to that circle. I also liked the way you pointed how there is a lot of difference between SG n MN track handling.
I am not jealous of SG track ..the progress is missing..its always one stpe forward and 2 steps backward..MN are different characters agreed..but still the story has to move ahead and not in circles :D
Coming to your question -do mayur have better moments that erase the necessity of a story all together.. we look at a scene and we say wah wah..but does it relate to the overall story....
I would like to ask how is it a MOMENT when there is no depth? Beach and Barn scenes were MOMENTS because there was profound thought process involved, what we get to see now are SCENES because I only enjoy seeing ArTi enacting them (if I see MN wise, it has not effect on me). I am not sure if scenes require a story or not but personally, I'd go for a scene which goes with a sensible storyline because then that scene would become a MOMENT between the characters
Seriously the actos-Arti make the scene watchable right now... the scenes if deeply entrenched within the story will blow u away...! but thats where the problem lies for us

Quote

Shipra

@Shipra_S

Rocker

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: SAra_Spiritual
well couldnt hold my self .. so came back to reply in ur post carao dear ...

well ia gree with u . mayur doesnt have a story ... n i m gald they dun have .. strange na??? wot they have is a beautiful interplay of caracters ... which is yet to find on tv these days .. n we are lucky to have ARjun n RAti to play them ... honestly thts y i m watching them since the begining.. ... n will continue to do so ... if creatives didnt contradict them or add a bhankaas story to them ... abhi tak they havent disappointed me ... less ahmedabad track ... but still there were tose beautiful moments ... interplays are not easy to deal with ... anyways .. lets wait n watch ... sabr ka phal meetha hota hai .. 😊

as far as sajans sotry is cncerned? i better watch kuch kuch hota hai .. with sharhrukh rani n kajol ...anyday ...

to add more .. i hope the creatives manages to keep it this way ....

thanks .. it snot necessary to agree with me ... :)

@red-😉....Sara i hope no Sajanian reads this!!😆😆

Quote

Sid

@Sid4TeamCanada

Sparkler

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#10

@sara: kkhh is only a part of sajan track...sajan track isn't all abt that...

because gunjan's character is very different than kajol's... in sajan we saw the MAKING of a beautiful friendship...then we saw misunderstandings....and right now we are seeing the journey of the two friends falling in love..it all ties together...in MN - nothing ties together...and that's the main problem i have - that why do we have to tie everything together ourselves by our assumptions? why doesn't the mayur track FLOW SOOTHLY??😕

@Caro: Yeeehaaaw - i have the longest post in ur thread...yeaah!! ab me going to kavz's thread to unreserve my post there!😛

Edited by SidraLuvMayurBL - 16 years ago