The quality of mercy is not strained...

judyp thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
For me some of the scenes from SP brings back sayings and life teachings. One occurred to me during the Bhaboo/Shweta scene...
In her rage and anger the forever praying Bhaboo threw at Shweta the truth of her birth it showed a totally callousness and a totally lack of compassion or understanding of the young girl. The only fault of Shweta is having a child's love for a parent but Bhaboo is so blinded by her hatred for the child's mother she lost sight of her supposed love of the Child's father. She was totally merciless.
This reminded me of the Saying the Quality of Mercy is not strained. It comes from the Shakespeare's play The Merchant of Venice.

PORTIA: The quality of mercy is not strain'd,

It droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven
Upon the place beneath: it is twice blest;
It blesseth him that gives and him that takes:
'Tis mightiest in the mightiest: it becomes
The throned monarch better than his crown;
His sceptre shows the force of temporal power,
The attribute to awe and majesty,
Wherein doth sit the dread and fear of kings;
But mercy is above this sceptred sway;
It is enthroned in the hearts of kings,
It is an attribute to God himself;
And earthly power doth then show likest God's
When mercy seasons justice. Therefore, Jew,
Though justice be thy plea, consider this,
That, in the course of justice, none of us
Should see salvation: we do pray for mercy;
And that same prayer doth teach us all to render
The deeds of mercy. I have spoke thus much
To mitigate the justice of thy plea;
Which if thou follow, this strict court of Venice
Must needs give sentence 'gainst the merchant there.

http://www.phrases.org.uk/meanings/297200.html

Created

Last reply

Replies

3

Views

934

Users

2

Frequent Posters

koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
Beautiful judy . it brought tears to my eyes as i read and re read it . did merchant of venice when i was studying literature in college quite some years back .........i relived those moments of my professor reading this to just 6 of us students , over a small room on the top of the teacher's staffroom [ that small the lierature class was ].........
I think now Bhabho is beyond resurrection . She didn't allow Saloni to meet her sick child in hospital [ and for some silly reason they didn't show that law was on saloni's side and bhabho wasn't above it ]
she didn't show mercy to sawri and bluntly told brijesh that had it been a girl from their family she wudn't have got her married to an older guy but hey sawri isn't from their family so why bother .........a very callous answer showing a merciless heart
she coolly broke news of saloni's death although shweta was having psychological problems and when sum one told her shweta will be affected she made stone face and said shweta simply will have to accept it bas
Now , she mercilessly broke news to Shweta that is adopted not Nahar's real offspring . Her anger towards Saloni was much more than the life of Nahar's nishaani .
All the great spoiling pampering of Nahar's nishaani and doing Nahar Nahar Nahar is only a bid to keep authority in her hands by showing immense love for the two sons of the house .........Brijesh and Nahar .
her authority in the house is only coz of the great love she has for these two princes , and all that power she wields comes only due to that love . But that love seems to be a sham .........for she didnt really care that shweta wud die .............not back then , nor now !
If this serial ends without Bhabho and Tara's servant origins being flung on their faces , there will be something incomplete about SP . UNclassy as this is , it is what viewers want .
judyp thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
Thanks, I never read did the play in school but I loved Literature. In college I did Natural Sciences...
For me justice comes in different form or fashion..
In your post what's the last scene you wanted to see I chose the scene where Bhaboo rejected Amrit. I wanted Bhaboo to be punished and the greatest justice would be for Bhaboo to have rejected all she claimed to have loved - Nahar. After all, all her injustices were done in the name of Nahar. If she had shown a shred of mercy or compassion she would have been the person she claimed to be. Maybe she would have gotten back Nahar by embracing Amrit (that's my justice).
Bhaboo prayed and prayed to God to bring Nahar back Amrit came as an answer to that prayer. Bhaboo forgot everything including What Nahar stood for. I always believed Amrit never came for saloni but for Bhaboo. The least she owed the man was to hear him out...
In Saloni's case the saying the End doesn't justify the means come to mind. Although bringing Amrit saved the family is it right to bring an impersonate into the house. No, Is it right to continue this after 12 years No. Saloni prayed to God to help her in her hours of need and after she would go back to being a widow. So, she got her punishment. In the process her good deeds was not forgotten she got 2 sons...It's funny but Saloni through her strength got through her misery. The fact that those two boys never had to pay for her loss of her daughters by her grieving and be-moaning is the quality she has of making the best of a bad situation. If she had secretly skulk around like Jiji trying to get back the Singh's property or look at ways to get revenge of Tara and Bhaboo her life would have been filled of misery.
It's also funny for the last six years Bhaboo, Tara and by extension Brijesh lives was filled with hatred for Saloni and they took it out on Saawri - the daughter of the man they claim to love. While saloni last six years would be grieving for her daughters but holding no animosity or stressing her life over Tara et al. In the process her daughters would get two great husbands... What better quality in a husband is there than having a son's love for his mother-in-law.
One of the greatest cruelty Tara and Bhaboo did aided by Dheer was sending Saawri to the Orphange at 12 years of age. Again that was hatred in the highest form. The child lost Saloni and Amrit and they dumped her as garbage. Regardless of her love for Saloni they could have paid a family to take her in etc. Again they forgot they promised Savitri to take care off her daughter. As they believed that Sawri was Savitri's child they failed to fullfil that promise.
The greatest justice for Bhaboo, Tara etc.. when the truth of Saawri birth comes out she should be about to get married and move to her husband's house. Saawri in her goodness will off forgive them but by leaving they would never get an opportunity to right the wrong.. She is now the Bahu of another family she's no longer their daughter.. To find something and then lost it immediately is going to be the greatest punishment - exactly what they did to Saloni - after 12 years of searching for her daughter she found her and then lost her because of that family...
I loved the scene where the two boys stood up to Tara etc. Tara could never get that love and affection from her child - It's funny she did everything possible for her child. She claimed to want to be a mother. There were many children yearning for a mother's love and no one loves Tara. Eshaan loved Saloni. Saawri and shweta loved Saloni. Aditiya did love Saloni. After six(6) years Shweta can reject everything that was given to her and run to Saloni's defence. I think one of the greatest lesson in SP would be as seen in Tara's case also the End doesn't justify the means - she wanted a child and she didn't care what she did to get a child. She got a child that hates the ground she walks on...
I don't believe that Saloni or Saawri should or do anything to Tara or Bhaboo or even Brijesh. Nahar loved his family and dgrading or insulting them is an insult to what he stood for. I don't believe Saloni or Saawri should continue to live in that house....
koolsadhu1000 thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: judyp

Thanks, I never read did the play in school but I loved Literature. In college I did Natural Sciences...
For me justice comes in different form or fashion..
In your post what's the last scene you wanted to see I chose the scene where Bhaboo rejected Amrit. I wanted Bhaboo to be punished and the greatest justice would be for Bhaboo to have rejected all she claimed to have loved - Nahar. After all, all her injustices were done in the name of Nahar. If she had shown a shred of mercy or compassion she would have been the person she claimed to be. Maybe she would have gotten back Nahar by embracing Amrit (that's my justice).
Bhaboo prayed and prayed to God to bring Nahar back Amrit came as an answer to that prayer. Bhaboo forgot everything including What Nahar stood for. I always believed Amrit never came for saloni but for Bhaboo. The least she owed the man was to hear him out...
In Saloni's case the saying the End doesn't justify the means come to mind. Although bringing Amrit saved the family is it right to bring an impersonate into the house. No, Is it right to continue this after 12 years No. Saloni prayed to God to help her in her hours of need and after she would go back to being a widow. So, she got her punishment. In the process her good deeds was not forgotten she got 2 sons...It's funny but Saloni through her strength got through her misery. The fact that those two boys never had to pay for her loss of her daughters by her grieving and be-moaning is the quality she has of making the best of a bad situation. If she had secretly skulk around like Jiji trying to get back the Singh's property or look at ways to get revenge of Tara and Bhaboo her life would have been filled of misery.
It's also funny for the last six years Bhaboo, Tara and by extension Brijesh lives was filled with hatred for Saloni and they took it out on Saawri - the daughter of the man they claim to love. While saloni last six years would be grieving for her daughters but holding no animosity or stressing her life over Tara et al. In the process her daughters would get two great husbands... What better quality in a husband is there than having a son's love for his mother-in-law.
One of the greatest cruelty Tara and Bhaboo did aided by Dheer was sending Saawri to the Orphange at 12 years of age. Again that was hatred in the highest form. The child lost Saloni and Amrit and they dumped her as garbage. Regardless of her love for Saloni they could have paid a family to take her in etc. Again they forgot they promised Savitri to take care off her daughter. As they believed that Sawri was Savitri's child they failed to fullfil that promise.
The greatest justice for Bhaboo, Tara etc.. when the truth of Saawri birth comes out she should be about to get married and move to her husband's house. Saawri in her goodness will off forgive them but by leaving they would never get an opportunity to right the wrong.. She is now the Bahu of another family she's no longer their daughter.. To find something and then lost it immediately is going to be the greatest punishment - exactly what they did to Saloni - after 12 years of searching for her daughter she found her and then lost her because of that family...
I loved the scene where the two boys stood up to Tara etc. Tara could never get that love and affection from her child - It's funny she did everything possible for her child. She claimed to want to be a mother. There were many children yearning for a mother's love and no one loves Tara. Eshaan loved Saloni. Saawri and shweta loved Saloni. Aditiya did love Saloni. After six(6) years Shweta can reject everything that was given to her and run to Saloni's defence. I think one of the greatest lesson in SP would be as seen in Tara's case also the End doesn't justify the means - she wanted a child and she didn't care what she did to get a child. She got a child that hates the ground she walks on...
I don't believe that Saloni or Saawri should or do anything to Tara or Bhaboo or even Brijesh. Nahar loved his family and dgrading or insulting them is an insult to what he stood for. I don't believe Saloni or Saawri should continue to live in that house....

I like your concept of justice judy . Just wanted u to know that . It is poetic justice , called as God's silent whiplash for bad karma . It needn't be as humans wish it to be ...........but it always reminds the evildoer of his bad karma . Incidentally , my husband believes in this concept of justice just like u , and always says that it is pointless to hate the ones who wrong u as u allow them to control ur mind . And poetic justice is a reality .
Poetic justice cud have been shown if Kaveri had never conceived after that miscarraige and Samar had been more attached to Nikita always .
It wud have been there if after all that rigmarole of Jiji as surrogate mom etc only a daughter wud have been born to Tara [ who wud have hated her later like Adi ] but Saloni wud have got the son , the ultimate heir to the Singhs .[ Not that i believe in it , I am simply telling from point of view of Indian masses and their sick waaris concept .]
It wud have been there if Adi had improved and chosen Nikita for his bride instead of Kamini by bluntly publicly making this proposal and Samar wud have in delight , agreed . I
It wud have been there if Kamini wud have become pregnant before marraige and the boy had absconded , and abortion option wud be too late and Kaveri's hi fi friends had ditched her and she wud totally fall in Samar's eyes who wud keep her and kamini away from mandap of Adi and Nikita's marraige .
Nikita wud enter Saloni's sasuraal as bahu , not Kamini .
It wud have been there if they had shown [ and this was my most favorite wish ] SAloni losing on personal front but gaining immensely professionally . They shud have shown her being spotted singing for prison programmes , released on good behaviour and since now she has no family responsibilities she can do what she earlier never do , dedicate full time to her singing and becoming internationally famous and much much richer than the singhs and Samar ! This same kaveri who humiliated her wud stand in line to enter her dressing room with her hi fi friends and Bhabho's lies wud be exposed and both her daughters wud simply get up and go to her ! Instead the idiots turned her into a Daasa .
They never utilized a single avenue for poetic justice . they made the ending crappy .
Edited by koolsadhu1000 - 16 years ago

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".