sahiltandon thumbnail
Explorer Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#1
Well u might have notice many times, that the JUDGES discuss lots of things after the performance, so they might even decide how much marks to give... I try to figure out, why had they cut one mark and i am not here to blame only sweetie Juhi Chawla... Even if i would have been at her place i would have cut Karan's just one or half a mark... Reasons can be:-

1. The steps that he performed in the very beginning, were repetitive... I mean he performed the same steps in U my love also.....

2. Then yes, it might also be the plan of Production House to not to give him full marks.... may be because of such argument... As what i feel reality shows are no real any more, till i participate in one......

3. Because it was Circus Round, no doubt some of his steps were actually involved stunts or need strength to perform them, but in spite of that it doesnt involve much feel of circus, like HARD KAUR or GAUHAR HAD....

4. And yes if i remember Juhi clearly mentioned that the performance was Dramatic, Cool and very unusual... but the word "DRAMATIC" clearly mentions that the dancing was little less because of kind of drama in it.......

But in any way, he performed really much better than GAUHAR, PARUL and BAICHUNG.... but he was little lacking behing from HARD KAUR. I missed out parul's performance but if her score is not a discussion point then surely there wont be any problem as such...

And guys finally i was so impressed with his Costume, The way they coloured their faces, and their impressive movement...

And i know there will be questions about where Juhi found steps to be dramatic... Here they are:-

1. When they left that KHULA DABA (sorry i dont know what to call that thing), and they started doing some steps Oh Suniyo Re.... No doubt it was dance, but dramatic in the sense, u cant see something like that in circus... When its circus round, then should be completely like circus..... I know many of you especially KSG fans not going to agree to this fact.... But see what i feel that there's not any biasedness of Juhi Chawla or Saroj Khan or Vaibhavi Merchant... Because if They were biased... then each of them given even once 10 Marks to every contestant............. That shows that they are not biased... I am totally with judges... No doubt they had mentioned the reason why they are deducting one mark, and its quite unfair to deduct it without giving any proper reason..... Still the word "DRAMATIC" makes it somehow clear for deducting one mark... Anyways one more thing i want to make one thing very clear as JDJ is coming to an end soon.. that why judges are always one the tip of knife, when KARAN got marks (less or more, doesnt matter)??? They are always criticized, if he got less marks then they are biased to Baichung (if they are so then they had given him 28 or 29 marks for yesterday's performance) because it was very different.... but they didnt because the way they executed was not that better.... What i feel, as even i had judged a dance show, it is based on personal Judgment of people and calling some one Blind, stupid... using similes like 🤬, saying that i hate her now so much.... U cant make image about any person without knowing him/her properly, u never know what was in her mind... May be she expected very much from him, as we have seen from the very first episode that Juhi Chawla is the only judge who keep on motivating every single contestant, she never said that I didnt liked your performance it was WAHIYAAD, like saroj and VAIBHAVI normally do........
Edited by sahiltandon - 16 years ago

Created

Last reply

Replies

12

Views

1.5k

Users

12

Frequent Posters

BlueSoul thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Rocker Thumbnail Engager Level 1 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#2
I disagree...specially when there is another hot topic going on saying...Karan's act dint had any dancing...just monkey steps...which i dont feel is correct.....Here ur pov is he got 1 marks less for 'Doing Steps'😛 Its correct it was a Circus theme..but they just incorporated some good steps in it coz as everyone knows afterall its a 'Dance Competetion'.
As far as Judges are concerned...I've seen in other reality shows where Saroj ji and vaibhavi pointed out that whatever be the theme...dancing should be there...and they deducted marks if the dancing was not there.
Their performance had everything dancing, sync, lip-sync, X factor, energy, costumes, Yin Yan face make-up😃 juggling and what not...
And for juhi...she just comments sweetly...that is not all for encouraging if u cut their marks for no reason...n im not talking about karan's latest act...but many and for other contestants too...i guess Juhi has no clue...why she's givng her guldasta or why she's cutting marks....she just there for that glamour and her smile...Thats it!
surbhi.. thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Voyager Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#3
actually karan's dance wes superb ,,,,,,
bcoz of his popularity judge never give him full marks!!
he have 100% votes with him .....😆
Asad-Kii-Arzoo thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#4

Originally posted by: bhumi143

Actual more then dance it was a circus round thats why he got 29 by doing monkey act. And 1 mark wz deducted cuz it waz not up to the mark.

hahahahahaahahahah u r making me so much laugh is it 2day a laughter..tell me wich judge said it was nt upto d mrk...
well i know u r very much trained dan d judges dere....😆
hey wait a while let me laugh on dis dat u r well experienced dan judges....


ok now i cant stop laughing coz its so funny dat u think urself best dan....dem.....hahahahahaahahhaha


well cuming 2 d topic...i dint get it why 1 mrk was cut out......but for me he got 30 as he said 29 or mujhe ye saroj ji se rs milley mere liye 30 ho gye.....n our votes r always wid him....nt coz of his popularity but coz of his hard wrk n prformence.....
-Divz- thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#5

Originally posted by: armaanbasket

hahahahahaahahahah u r making me so much laugh is it 2day a laughter..tell me wich judge said it was nt upto d mrk...
well i know u r very much trained dan d judges dere....😆
hey wait a while let me laugh on dis dat u r well experienced dan judges....


ok now i cant stop laughing coz its so funny dat u think urself best dan....dem.....hahahahahaahahhaha


well cuming 2 d topic...i dint get it why 1 mrk was cut out......but for me he got 30 as he said 29 or mujhe ye saroj ji se rs milley mere liye 30 ho gye.....n our votes r always wid him....nt coz of his popularity but coz of his hard wrk n prformence.....



totally agree wid u dear!!

let them jealous!!

karan will be in semi-finals for sure!!!
Asad-Kii-Arzoo thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#6

Originally posted by: divya_dmg



totally agree wid u dear!!

let them jealous!!

karan will be in semi-finals for sure!!!

thnxx for agreeing n ksg will nt b in semi-finals he will b in finale...
Radhika_ksgian thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail Commentator Level 2 Thumbnail
Posted: 16 years ago
#7
karan fully deserves 30 bt i dnt no wat iz d prob. dat koi to 1 mark kat ta hi hai
4 me he deserves 30
d best dance of d evening
Swap-Arhi thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Dazzler Thumbnail + 5
Posted: 16 years ago
#8
I saw KSG's performance it was mindblowing. the energy co-ord was superb. He deserved 30 just coz he is popular does not mean he shud get less!!!! I frankly feel he is hardworking and is popular so why not win? what is wrong when the show format is based like this!!!! And I thnk its gonna be HK and KSG in finals....they both are really gud...!
Sanju_ thumbnail
17th Anniversary Thumbnail Stunner Thumbnail + 3
Posted: 16 years ago
#9
i so wanted him to get 30...i truly think he deserved...but i'm happy he got 29.
roshaaan thumbnail
16th Anniversary Thumbnail Sparkler Thumbnail + 2
Posted: 16 years ago
#10

Originally posted by: sajan_kash21

actually karan's dance wes superb ,,,,,,
bcoz of his popularity judge never give him full marks!!
he have 100% votes with him .....😆




totally agree its only jealousy of judges

Related Topics

Top

Stay Connected with IndiaForums!

Be the first to know about the latest news, updates, and exclusive content.

Add to Home Screen!

Install this web app on your iPhone for the best experience. It's easy, just tap and then "Add to Home Screen".