Complaints about Judges Marks

First Previous

Page

Frequent Posters

Wrackspurt

@Wrackspurt

Trailblazer

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#11

I agree that it was good that they brought out the inconsistency about the judges marking..........i thought despite Parul fainting during her performance she was one of the best.......i loved her performance that day but the judges gave her bad marks.......also her first performance was way better than many others.........specially the guys......but then also she had got very less marks where as Ugesh(showed only magic),Amarnath, and Baichung who did not dance got so many marks.So their judgement according to me was🤢.

However Karan did an awesome job this week........even if he would not have opened his shirt he would have got good scores😳

Lastly i would like to say that it would have been better if someone like Shaimak Davar was their in the judges panel.........he was the most honest judge......i am missing him terribly this season.

Quote

missing Vmars

@missing Vmars

Inactive

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#12

Originally posted by: lats55
shown in today's episode, it was good to bring it out so open, and you should watch their faces when it was shown to the public... the comparison shows how incompetent the judges are..

i agree n dere justification was even more lousy .. v giving less marks 2 da girls coz v expect more out of dem ... how silly it dat ... reallly !!!!

very disappointed wit da Season 3 judges .. actually i dont knw wat is disappointing me more .. da contestants .... da judges or da hosts .....everything's a big BLAH for me 😕

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

kashforlife

@kashforlife

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

#13

i disagree i thin the judges are maring fairly the comparisons shown in my oinon were baseless, they were just pointing on one pont but there were other fators in the prformance which g into scoring.

i swaer these are the judges sp just accept it (unless they are unfair to my ksg then i have no rehem for them lol)

Quote

desicrowd

@desicrowd

Sparkler

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#14

There is definitely some disparity in the points pattern by the judges. When we have is an all lady judge panel then men will definitely be favored, I think Shamiak Savar would have been ideal instead of Saroj Khan. SK doesn't know the difference between Samba and Sambha. I agree with all the girls on that, however I didn't like Gauhar's attitude on saying that she was the best dancer of all. how cn someone be so self absorbed. She is getting too cocky nd I am sure this will work against her.

Quote

Dabulls23

@Dabulls23

Stunner

+ 2

Posted: 16 years ago

#15

Women are women's worst enemies...

We see hot guys and drool....vote for them .....lose our logics.....

where guys do drool at gals but will not vote or lose logic to make right judgement...

all 3 female judges are suckers for male species......Not being objective when judging....Harsh on girls with comments and marks and easy on boys with marks...

Quote

srkbest

@srkbest

Inactive

+ 3

Posted: 16 years ago

#16

judging a little bit unfair to the girls yes......some of the non dancers got higher points then some girls who danced better....
but you can't put the thing on Karan......he isn't being given points by the judges on his looks or body but his performance....they didn't really like his 1st performance so he got the lowest marks...(good body or not.....as for saroj's comment sirf physique dikhane se kuch nahi hota dance bhi karna chahiye) This week he was excellent in his dance.....(don't take away from his hard work by saying that he got points for taking his shirt off.......he did the whole dance with the shirt on......and the move was added because it is nicole the choreographer who decides and the reason for that being he was suppose to be performing as Salman on his song and Salman is famous for taking off his shirt. Karan only took it off at the very end.....acting like salman part of the act not just for fun to show the judges) He got what he deserved.....that is why they didn't include him in that comparison video......he was lowest first week and highest 2nd ......getting points he deserved the judges weren't being biased towards him.