The Viel: What Happend that Night?

Okay as you may rmr in tha 5th book, ther was a veil, where a. harry heard strange noises from and b. sirius fell behind and lupin said tat sirius couldn't come back. Luna too heard voices from the viel and Nearly Headless Nick said ther were things inside the Dept. of Mysteries tat most ppl couldnt understand. Do you think the veil is a portal to death?

maybe/maybe not. But it sure is in sumway connected to the way ppl die.

regards,

tejas

it could b...not sure though! 😉

u didn't say i agree 5 coz there were nos going on here 😆

YAY!! I agree 6 n 7 n 8 and infinitely!! Hahah..
But I tink, there is a way that ppl behind the veil can talk to ppl outside, there must be! Coz they said Luna n Harry heard voices: does that mean tht all those who went behind the veil, their spirits live on? 😳

May be but i dont want it to be. 😛
'coz i want Sirius to come back.

Originally posted by: fire_on_ice

YAY!! I agree 6 n 7 n 8 and infinitely!! Hahah..
But I tink, there is a way that ppl behind the veil can talk to ppl outside, there must be! Coz they said Luna n Harry heard voices: does that mean tht all those who went behind the veil, their spirits live on? 😳

Yeah, that's a possibility.. And, also Luna and Harry r among the only ones who could see the thestrals, since they both have someone close to them dead.. So, could it possibly be that only they could hear the voices but only of the people they have lost if not all the dead people? I don't think that the book mentions anything about others hearing those voices, so it's a possibility. What do u guys think?

Originally posted by: daniel_4ever

i agrre with u achal

Thanks!😃

Originally posted by: achal

Thanks!😃

😃

im not sure, but it probably is!