CHANGE OF ROLES IN VIVAH&WHY VIVAH IS FAILURE?

Page

komal raza

@lovelygunjan

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

why this show is a failure? Mainly the way story is executed, the role doesnt fit with actors/actresses personalityand so many other reasons.I think roles doesnt fit the personalities is to be discussed.

Trishna the main protagonist, doesnt look protagonist.She has some look to her that would make her a better "VAMP" instead.She doesnt fit into role of a good bahu or wife.Her facial features and makeup is like VAMPS.Also she can give mean looks easily and when she is mean people can hate her easily like when she mistreated tanya.Although they focus on her postive side of personality but nobody is impressed because the role doesnt fit her.She can be better support actress like in bhabi, as alpa, or like saathi re saath kadam saath janam,but not as main lead.In vivah she is focused very much , sometime more what people can handle, her role with her personality doesnt fit in people's mind so its hard for them to accept her.she doesnt have sweetness like others like sakshi tanwar,panchi bhora, divya , Neha bamb,simriti irani and many others.

Tanya on the other hand has totally different personality.She is very simple still alluring like SAKSHI TANWAR AKA PARVATI.She has potential as she was main lead after parvati and already has performed role of good bahu and wife in kahani ghar ghar ki. She looks very natural and innocent like panchi bora and all other main lead actresses.

Her acting has no other example she is extra-ordinary and extremly talented.Her voice adds into that and makes her very easily a main lead protagonist, very good and dutiful bahu and a good wife.

Everyone like me after the story of her rape and marriage predicted she would lead the show but that didnt happen.so that caused a big failure for this show.

lol my mom says she would like a bahu like her, because she loves her simplicity.

Sujata on the other hand looks good as elder sister but not as main lead she is good support actress.Maybe her pairing with raghav is bad, she deserves better.

Mansha is a kid so cant talk about her alot.

Raj malhotra was so good in the beginning when he married tanya, after that he became a robot. He looks very nice as main lead with shalini aka tanya.He doesnt have any flaw in his character, if we see shabbir in kayamath has flaws but still very famous character, jai had flaws, shabd in maayka has flaws.But people kind of expect from raj , his character is so predictable that its becoming boring there is no curiousity.

The roles should be opposite as tanya looks good as maithli who does things for others and make sacrifices, raj would look good with some personality shades.

Rajdeep, in the beginning people hated him now they like him, why because there are some shades inhis personality.You cannot predict his behavior and what he is going to do next which makes it interesting.Also his character has been improved so much.To add into this sanjit is a very good actor .

No comments for raghav he looks like someone who has been severly beaten, his role is role of a looser.

rest are just fine.

Express your thoughts and think about it.DO you agree or not just imagine those charactres in different roles

Edited by lovelygunjan - 16 years ago

Quote

Frequent Posters

Shaheen

@Sumit-Kumkum

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

wow good analysis. I actually though this would be another I hate trishna, tanya is my goddess post 🤢 sick of those. I agree with everything you said. The execution is very bad. if we compare all the tv bahus to trishna, she is no one. No one cares. There is nothing wrong with her role. Most people just don't relate to her. If she had a negative role maybe it would've been better. Even though tanya barely gets attention audience finds a connection with her. hence they love her. Sujata is ok on her place, Raghav ruins it. mansha is too young and I am not interested in her romantic life unless it is teenage romance involving a guy her age.

Best thing you said about Raj's character was his flaws. It's about time they realize flaws make character. No one likes Raj anymore. he has nothing to do, no personality. I am a huge huge huge Milind fan and he is basically filled with flaws. Jai walia is definitely one of the most popular character on tv and i don't think anyone has made more mistake than him.

they need to fix the show or end this crap already so better show can take it's place.

Quote

Looks like you are new here. Register for free, learn and contribute.

komal raza

@lovelygunjan

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

nothing against parvia!Trishna's role doesnt suit her, thats my point.she can be a hit vamp,haha.The way she treated tanya, and she speaks up infront of nupur, which other bahus like tulsi does too.But she cant fit into role like tulsi , tulsi has different personality.thats my point.People love it when tulsi or parvati are bold and confronting but people hate it when trishna does it why??simply this role isnt for her,now the character is not bad, it has been most well developed character in vivah so far but pariva doesnt fit for that. Also from your User ID,I would like to say one thing, summit kumkum is one of the most popular couple of tv industry,they have been offered movies together.I love old summit/kumkum their love story was perfectly developed, summit was oblivious of renuka in the beggining.

Im not saying they should turn raj into a negative character but like summit commited a mistake of trusting renuka in the beginning, jai wasnt a bad person at all but he mistreated bani in thebeginning because he thought that he was hurt, shabbir aka milland was not a bad person either but he was hurting parachi and trusting ayesha....but still there is something to watch...people dont like plain characters like raj, to some extent they can like all sacrifices he made and all that, but his character is predictable

Raghav is a character that has no dignity, but they are showing he has dignity, people cant see what they are trying to show, raj and tanya are in love but people cant see it ."Tanya's character hasnt been developed nor as a wife and as a bahu."

Also all the time girls are doing things for their own family, you never see them doing things for their inlaws eventhough they are bad.

Edited by lovelygunjan - 16 years ago

Quote

nivine shammas

@nivine shammas

Explorer

Posted: 16 years ago

Intelligent!trishna as vamp😆.So you mean right now she is trying to fit into someone's else shoes😆.So true tanya's character is least developed.Her job is just to get scared and RAJ IS JUST EATING ALL THE TIME🤣OR LOOKING AT OTHERS BUT NOT AT HIS WIFE.Raj can atleast jump from the cliff like raghav😆😆😆raghav is a baccha or chotto.bukwass roles and everything,kidz show.

Mansha needs to get her eyesight checked 😆😆,she is drooling over kanahiya, trishna needs a huge break from the show so she can sleep and we can get up, Im ywaning when she is on.

Edited by nivine shammas - 16 years ago

Quote

Fatima

@Rhimjhimsawan

Sparkler

+ 5

Posted: 16 years ago

A brilliant post. I agree. Everything is perfect with trish's character it's just the role that doesnt suit her. Actually if we compare the show to a lot of shows it's not bad. But none of the feel is there. I am a HUGEE ekta fan. She picks out random people who are not even that good of actors for roles. But one thing she blesses us with is the right feel. If one sucks at acting she can improve. But if the right feel isn't there you can't create it. Honestly Trish is the only character that has been developed. She started out as a spunky immature sort of person. Moved into a total cold almost heartless person. Now she is is trying her best to be a good wife and a sister. She also tries to be a good daughter..not daught in law but daughter. If they had a more appropriate actress playing the role maybe the show would've done better. I loved Pariva in SZ but here I don't feel much connection with her.

The most flawed character in the show has to be Raj. As a lead actor one should always look at him. he should be such a important part where the story is nothing without him. In Vivaah they treat Raj worse than Shakti. Even these days Shakti has some sort of screen presence. But Raj just walks around, eats, listens to people, answers questions. It's like the whole story is going on around him and he has no part in it. I really wish they would shown Raj and Tanya fall in love. They are one of the worst couples I have seen on tv. Honestly! and this is after I thought oh wow they have such great potentials to be a good couple on ZEE. (not good enough to compete with the major couples but other couples on zee)

Next is Raghav. They can't just redeem his character. You can't be so damn annoying one day, do the most immature thing in life, take a stupid decision for no reason, act like a kid, ruin a girl's life then get a job and try to redeem yourself. It just doesn't work like that. maybe if he was Mansha's husband it would be somewhat understandble. But he is suppose to be the oldest Damad. Sujata's husband. Suj is pretty mature. He is older than Rajdeep and Raj. Both Rajdeep and Raj has shown they can handle responsibilty very well. In a place like that Raghav is like a sissy boy. Just not good enough.

Then comes Tanya. I am not like other Tanya fans who is about to break the tv because she wasn't shown. I just want something decent on tv that doesn't hurt my brain and still manages to enteratin me. Tanya's character was written in a way where she is a complete sweetheart. She was the caring, meek sister. That was her role. Now she doesn't have a role. She is not a bahu, not a wife, not even a daughter. These days one of the sisters to suj. She needs a story. The fact that she is kanaiyah's obsession makes her almost like an object. A center piece with nothing to do but frown once in a while.

Last but not least the show has a really slow pace. You can summarize a whole month in few lines.

Quote

sweethina

@sweethina

Inactive

Posted: 16 years ago

👏👏very sweet of you to post that!Maybe if they read that they can get some idea.Im so positive that tanya was good for trishna's role as good wife and the most important one.They are loosing viewers by not showing tanya and raj and both of them are becoming so useless.

Quote

komal raza

@lovelygunjan

Beginner

Posted: 16 years ago

Originally posted by: Perfangel5655

Tanya's character was written in a way where she is a complete sweetheart. She was the caring, meek sister. That was her role. Now she doesn't have a role. She is not a bahu, not a wife, not even a daughter. These days one of the sisters to suj. She needs a story. The fact that she is kanaiyah's obsession makes her almost like an object. A center piece with nothing to do but frown once in a while.

Last but not least the show has a really slow pace. You can summarize a whole month in few lines.

I so much agree with you..Tanya's character is becoming like an object.She doesnt have any story that links her with others or bonds her with raj.Also the pace of show is so slow after the wedding you can sumarrize whole thing in 10 mins.

Also everyone is so busy solving problems, that they are lacking fun or romance, even new entry nisha sareen was god entry but didnt stay that long, Sanjana disappeared and nobody talks about her now, raghav parents disappeared all the sudden, mansha is never shown practicing tennis and also her friends circle,Instead of stupid kanaiya track why doesnt he come against raj like the movie darr where SRK was after the girl but he tried to kill the husband....that is much better.I mentioned it before in one of my posts but Im not sure if creatives read it but in other forums they do..

Also Mr.kohli said he will never step into nupur's again but he did and nupur said that too but she was in party, kaniaya trying to get faour of mansha is lame as Mr.kohli knows him back from college days and if mansha marries him that would be the worst thing, instead they should make the character suffer this time instead of abusing, I wish tanya sees him, if raj is not meant for tanya they should bring in another guy , I loved the jodi but they are no morea jodi but just a married couple .

This show is emphasising on an individual instead of couple especially in case of raj and tanya.Raj and tanya has no connection , nobdy knows why raj fell so much for her that he started claiming that she is his life, for tanya its understandable, he doesnt appreciate her character or even appreciate her appearance why is he in love, what is the foundation just because he has no other choice or what??.

The stories are not bad except raj doesnt have one.I wonder creatives visit forums or not , If not we should write petitions,this show was one of my favourites and addictive until tanya got pregnant and then they ruined everything, trishna apologising tanya wasnt very dramatic, also was tanya jealous of trishna when she talked to raj or just a doubt they left that part there too no development, what does tanya think about her marriage about raj they never show it, what does raj thinks about her they never show it except tanya is scared how I can save her, I have to bring her back and all that.Sujata story was hanging forever and rajdeep story was powerful but didnt impact anyone because people cant connect with pariva.

I dont know where vivah creatives get feedback from.This show needs to end if they are not going to fix it ..

Last Im die hard shalini fan, since I first saw her on screen, but disappointing to see her just serving, or going in and out with mansha and being paranoid with kanaiya stuff.

Edited by lovelygunjan - 16 years ago

Quote

CHANGE OF ROLES IN VIVAH&WHY VIVAH IS FAILURE?

Related Topics

Explore Topics