Remo and Kapil - the underdogs?

Hi I am new on IF. I have been watching Idol. I was thinking that Remo and Kapil are portrayed as weak players. Even the judges constantly keep on discouraging them.

It doesn't matter how cute Remo is or how much of a gentleman Kapil is. This is a SINGING competition. One must sing properly above everything else.

I think that they should kiss Idol goodbye, and while they're leaving, take Kuldeep and Mohit with them.

Welcome to the forum, hun!

^Arghh, grrr ... you ruined it for me. I haven't seen Saturday's elimination episode yet. 😆

I would agree with you about Mohit, but unfortunately, his Khuda Jaane performance was horrendous. I would say that yes, he has shown some improvement since then, but that's not good enough. We need singers who are good singers already. This competition is looking for the best singer, not who can improve the most. You know what i mean?

The problem is that the overall talent this season is very lacking, and that's causing the judges to highly praise singing that on other shows will be considered below average.

Originally posted by: zainab25

Thanks for the warm welcome.

Lol isn't kuldeep already out? I thought he was.

Mohit isn't that bad of a singer after all...he's being portrayed as the "bad" guy becuz of the producers'creative team as he's shown with tulika one day and then torsha the other day. I think mohit should concentrate more on his singing though.

I 100% agree with you on the fact that its a singing competition and the best deserves to win, but judges should not be that rude when it comes to comments. I don't understand why they even picked them in the first place when they were soo "besura" to beign with.

anu malik at the beginning of indian idol started snapping his fingers and said "yaa, we want rafi's,asha's,kishore's ya ya we want to raise the standard"

then he started picking good looking ppl like mohit with bad sur.

THEN he insults them. theres a limit to how moody one can be.

OMG Woh Ajnabee I am soo sorry you had not seen the episode. sorry again that i spoiled it for you

Originally posted by: zainab25

Hi I am new on IF. I have been watching Idol. I was thinking that Remo and Kapil are portrayed as weak players. Even the judges constantly keep on discouraging them.

What do you all think? Do you like them at all? If not why? What are your views on them.

To me, I think they should be encouraged rather than demoralized on the show. After all they were picked by the judges so i don't know why they are being bashed now.

Don't get me wrong now. I do think that they need to improve a lot and they are weak compared to others, but i also feel that they should be given the same respect as others.

Thanks, sorry if my comment is taken in a negative way.