Did Hemani sing well?

I am talking about Amrita's song from Main Hoon Na. The mentors gave her high points, but I think ID's comment about who trained her was sarcastic. And though I really like her voice, I do not think she sang that song well. Her voice was coming out to be too harsh for the song.

And the Adesh went on about Hema instead of commenting about Himani. I think he realised too that she did not sing that well.

I agree. I was surprised that the mentors gave her 10 and 9 when I thought she didn't sing that great and gave Nihira only 8s when I thought she sang extraordinaly well, as usual. I don't know what's up with that show anymore.

MrsPetLUSji, pl.check the post "Himani & hema....Jodi no 1" post....I have sumthing for u 😊

HIMANI NEEDS A LOT OF MENTORING, HAND HOLDING, EGO STROKING, SPOON FEEDING, LOT OF ENCOURAGEMENT,ETC... I FEEL EVEN AS HAS HAD IT WITH HER AS WAS EVIDENT YESTERDAY.

ONE DAY HIMANI WILL GET THERE BUT FOR NOW THERE IS ONLY ONE LADY THAT HAS IT - AAAMCHI TUMCHI MULGI - NIHIRA JOSHI

Guys look for this posting as well, some interesting hot discussion to follow:
http://www.india-forums.com/forum_posts.asp?TID=151960&PN=1& TPN=2
Enjoy

I do not think she sang very well but she was smart enough to choose a more popular song than Nihira's.
She comes across to me as being a little overconfident these days and did not sing the song well yesterday. That is why the mentors points did not count and the public seems to have given more votes to Nihira.... My opinion only.

i thought himani,debo,haema were the best of the round...and twinle started of nicely but then seemed to have troubles with breating!

i think that hemani sang the main ho na song really well, actually i think that she sang it better than the original singer 😊